The Doukhobor Problem
Media Representations of Sons of Freedom Women, 1952–1960
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/rsth.v26i1.59Keywords:
Doukhobors, Church and State, Media representationsAbstract
This paper analyses the process of the media in British Columbia and in Canada in the stigmatizing of members of the radical Doukhobor Russian religious community known as the “svobodniki” or the Sons of Freedom. This process lasted from the late 1920s through to the end of the 1960s. A key issue of their protest was the disruption to their way of life in the Kootenay region in British Columbia by an unsympathetic cultural environment—secularized and pro-militarist—which they regarded as the antipathy of their values. Despite the clarity of their demands and the open statements of the reasons for their protests, their methods of protest were
presented by the media as acts of insanity. When women led the protests, the media portrayed them as monstrous and unfeminine. My analysis of the media shows how female Sons of Freedom protestors presented a direct challenge to the conservative gender roles which middle-class women of the 1950s were being asked to adopt. The response of the state was to declare these protestors “bad mothers” and to imprison their children for up to six years.
References
Breyfogle, Nicholas B. 1995 Building Doukhoboriia: Religious Culture, Social Identity and Russian Colonization in Transcaucasia, 1845–1895. Canadian Ethnic Studies 27(3): 24–51.
Halsall, Walter 1955 Children of the Sons. Victoria Daily Times February 5: 4.
Holt, Simma 1957 Doukhobor Tots Enjoy Schooling. Vancouver Sun February 15: 1.
Terror in the Name of God: The Story of the Sons of Freedom Doukhobors. Toronto/Montreal: McLelland and Stewart.
Janzen, William 1990 Limits on Liberty: the experience of Mennonite, Hutterite and Doukhbor communities in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Maloff , Peter 1957 In Quest of a Solution (Three Reports on Doukhobor Problem). Second Edition. In English. First report plus preface. Unpaginated. University of British Columbia Archives, Doukhobor Collection.
McKay, Louise 1953 Even Doukhobors Open Door to Public Health Nurse. Vancouver Sun April 10: 30.
McLaren, John 1995 Creating “Slaves of Satan” or “New Canadians”? The Law, Education and the Socialization of Doukhobor Children, 1911–1935. In Hamar Foster and John McLaren (eds.), Essays in the History of Canadian Law: British Columbia and the Yukon, 313–352. Toronto: Osgood Society for Canadian Legal History.
The Despicable Crime of Nudity: Law, the State and Civil Protest Among the Sons of Freedom Sect of Doukhobors, 1899–1935. Journal of the West 38(3): 27–33.
The State, Child Snatching, and the Law: The Seizure and Indoctrination of Sons of Freedom Children in British Columbia, 1950–1960. In John McLaren, Robert Menzies and Dorothy E. Chunn (eds.), Regulating Lives: Historical Essays on the State, Society, the Individual and the Law, 259–293. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.
Nelson Daily News, Th e 1953 Punishment Alone Futile; Move on Sons Should be Starting Point. Editorial. Sept. 17: 4.
Education and the Freedomites. Editorial. March 23: 4.
Krestova Spring Cleaning. Editorial. April 14: 4.
Ombudsman Province of British Columbia 1999 Righting the Wrong: The Confinement of the Sons of Freedom Doukhobor Children. Public Report No. 38 to the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia.
Rak, Julie 2004 Negotiated Memory: Doukhobor Autobiographical Discourse. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press.
Rideout, Page 1953 Advocates “Slapper” to Halt Terrorism. Nelson Daily News, September 16: 4.
Tarasoff , Koozma 1982 Plakun Trava: the Doukhobors. Grand Forks, BC: Mir Publication Society.
Victoria Daily Times 1955 “Why Make Children Suffer?” Douks Ask. February 19: 5.
Senators Slap Down McCarthy. June 22: 5.
Douk Mothers Ask Return of Children. June 22: 5.
Vancouver Province 1952 We Want a Permanent Cure. Editorial. May (n.d.).
Understand Douks’ Religion, Anglican Archdeacon Urges. May (n.d.).
United Church Demands “Positive” Douk Solution. May (n.d.).
Vancouver Sun, The 1959 Doukhobor Mothers Happy But You’d Never Know It. August 2 (n.p).
Webster, Jack 1953 Why Not Lash Those Douks? Grand Forks Asks Wismer. Victoria Daily Times April 8. n.p.
Woodcock, George and Ivan Avakumovic 1977 The Doukhobors. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.
Yerbury, J.C. 1984 The “Sons of Freedom” Doukhobors and the Canadian State. Canadian Ethnic Studies 16(2): 47–70.
