Tiqtiq, Brother Tadger, and Charles Dickens
The Theatre-in-the Round of Mackenzie Inuit Missions 1857–1863
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/rsth.v30i1.27Keywords:
Culture transition, mission historiography, women’s history, Inuit, Dene, Arctic, fur-tradeAbstract
This study of the Mackenzie Inuit’s initial encounter with missionaries (at Fort Simpson in 1859) makes four points. First, that native peoples were very much in control, and held an even hand in negotiations with whites, whether clerics, traders, or other outsiders. Second, that native-white interaction resembled theater-in-the-round—the two sides each acting out roles and speaking lines set by a distant audience invested in the outcome. Third, that no matter how remote a mission site, its history was closely tied to events in European centers of power. Last, that in contrast to the violent evangelization of the hemisphere’s South, that of the Far North was of the gentlest kind. Given time (half a century of church contact in the case of the Mackenzie Inuit) all Arctic tribes converted. Coercion, that suggests, need never have been applied west of the Atlantic by conquering nations to make their subjects Christian.
References
Anglican Church in Canada, Dioceses of the Mackenzie and Yukon. 1909-26 Dates in endnote 19. Registers of Eskimo Baptism, Confirmation, Marriage, and Death 1909–26. Public Archives of Alberta, Edmonton, 70.387.
Aborigines Protection Society. 1856 Canada West and the Hudson’s Bay Company: A Political and Humane Question of Vital Importance to the Honour of Great Britain, to the Prosperity of Canada, and to the Existence of the Native Tribes, being an Address to the Right Honourable Henry Labouchère, Her Majesty’s Principal Secretary of State for the Colonies. London. Pamphlet. Web. Canadiana.org
Alunik, Ishmael, Eddie D. Kolausok, and David Morrison. 2003 Across Time and Tundra: The Inuvialuit of the Western Arctic. Raincoast Books, U. of Washington, and Canadian Museum of Civilization.
Anderson, James. 1852a To HBC Governor, 1852, 01, 07. HBCA B200/b/29.
b To Augustus Peers, 1852, 25, 08. HBCA B200/b/29.
c To Governor, 1852, 30, 11. HBCA B00/b/29.
To Governor, 1855, 29, 11. HBCA B200/b/31.
Anderson, R. M. 1910 Photo album. National Archives of Canada, PA 187698.
Amer. Mus. of Natural History, New York. Anderson-Stefannson Expedition. Anderson Photos. Filing No. 57.2 (98). Photo 16997, 1910, 16, 06.
Anonymous. 2011 The Frozen Deep—A Drama in Three Acts, in The Plays of Wilkie Collins. Web. Accessed 2011, 12, 01.
Armstrong, Alexander. 1857 A Personal Narrative of the Discovery of the Northwest Passage. London. 1857. p. 155, 167, 198
Arnold, Charles. 2011. Personal communication, 2011, 12, 03.
Barr, William. 2002 From Barrow to Boothia: The Arctic Journal of Chief Factor Peter Warren Dease, 1836–1839. McGill-Queen’s UP.
Bell, John. 1826 To Edward Smith and Peter Dease, 1826, 21, 08. HBCA B200/b/3.
To Smith, 1830, 08, 08. HBCA B200/b/3.
a To Smith, 1831, 31, 01. HBCA B200/b/6.
b To Smith, 1831, 09, 08. HBCA B200/b/7.
To Smith, 1832, 31, 01. HBCA B200/b/7.
a To John Lewes, 1841, 04, 04. B200/b/13.
b To Lewes, 1841, 04, 07. HBCA B200/b/14.
To Lewes, 1843, 03, 04. HBCA B200/6/16.
To HBC Governor (from Fort Simpson), 1850, n.d., fall. HBCA B200/b/25.
Berger, Francesco (composer of the overture for Charles Dickens’s The Frozen Deep) 1913 Reminiscences, Impressions and Anecdotes. Library Reprints 2001.
“The mid-Victorian entertainers, a nonagerian’s memories.” London Times 1931, 14, 04, p. 12.
Bodfish, Capt. Hartson H. 1936 Chasing the Whale. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1936. Entry for 1895, 04, 06.
Boreski, Thomas G. 2000 “Griffith Owen Corbett.” Web. DCBO. Accessed 2011, 01, 01.
Brannan, Robert Louis. 1966 Under the Management of Charles Dickens: His Production of “The Frozen Deep.” New York: Cornell UP.
Breton, P. E. 1963 Irish of the Arctic. Edmonton: Éditions de L’Hermitage.
Brisebois, Charles. 1825 To Edouard Smith, 1825, 07, 01. HBCA B200/b/1.
Brockey, Liam Matthew. 2007 Journey to the East: The Jesuit Mission to China, 1579–1724. Harvard University Press.
Brown, Jennifer S. H. 1987 “‘I Wish to be as I see you’: An Ojibway-Methodist encounter in fur trade country, Rainy Lake, 1854–55.” Arctic Anthropology 24(1): 19–31.
Brownlee, John. 2011 Personal Communication from Edmonton, 2011, 31, 01.
Burch, Ernest S. 1994 “The Inupiat and the Christianization of Arctic Alaska.” Etudes/Inuit/Studies 18(1–2): 81–108.
Button, David. 2011 Personal communication from Inuvik, 2011, 22, 04.
Carrière, Gaston. 1977 “Pierre-Henri Grollier.” Dictionnaire Biographique des Oblats de Marie Immaculée au Canada, vol. 2, University of Ottawa, 114–115. See also DCBO.
“Pierre-Henri Grollier.” DCBO. Web. 2010, 12, 10.
Champagne, Joseph Étienne. 1949 Les Missions Catholiques dans l’Ouest Canadien, 1818–1875. Ottawa: L’Institut de Missiologie de l’Université Pontificale d’Ottawa.
Choquette, Robert. 1995 The Oblate Assault on Canada’s Northwest. Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press.
Clarke, Lawrence. 1865 To Robert Kennicott, 1865, 16, 01 in Lindsay, Modern Beginnings.
Clunas, Craig. 2008 “Who has the biggest books?” (re: Brockey, Journey), London Review of Books, 2008, 07, 02.
Coates, Kenneth. 1987 “The Commerce of Discovery: The Hudson’s Bay Company and the Simpson and Dease Expedition.” Paper presented at Symposium on Early Investigations of the Western Arctic, Twentieth Annual Conference of the Canadian Archaeological Association, Calgary.
Cooper, Barry. 1988 Alexander Kennedy Isbister: A Respectable Critic of the Honourable Company. Ottawa: Carleton University Press.
Dallas, A. G. 1863 To W. L. Hardisty, 1863, 22, 05. HBCA 200/b/34.
David, Robert G. 2000 The Arctic in the British Imagination 1818–1914. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Dyck, Noel. 1980 Platform presentation quoted in Brown, “I wish.”
Duchaussois, Pierre. 1937 Mid Snow and Ice: The Apostles of the North-West. Buffalo: Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate.
Fitzgerald, James Edward. 1849 An Examination of the Charter and Proceedings of the Hudson’s Bay Company, With Reference to the Grant of Vancouver’s Island. London. Web. Canadiana.org.
Galbraith, John S. 2000 “Sir George Simpson.” DCBO. Accessed 2007, 11, 12.
Great Britain. Parliament. House of Commons. Select Committee on the Hudson’s Bay Company. 1858 Report from the Select Committee together with the proceedings of the committee, minutes of evidence, appendix, and index. London. Canadiana.org. Accessed 2008, 02, 10.
Gaudet, Charles. 1860 To William Kirkby, n.d., received at Ft. Simpson 1860, 19, 03 when Kirkby transcribed it into his journal, q.v.
To Bernard Rogan Ross, 1861, 02, 02. HBCA B200/b/34.
To Ross, 1862, 09, 02. HBCA B200/b/34.
Grollier, Henri. 1858 “Missions Étrangères: Vicariat du Mackenzie, Souvenirs: récit inédit d’un voyage du R. P. Grollier au Fort Simpson en 1858.” Missions de la Congrégation des Missionnaires Oblats de Marie Immaculée. March 1886, 409–419.
Hardisty, William Lucas. 1871a To Andrew Flett at Peel’s River, 1871, 10, 03. HBCA B200/39/vol. 1.
b To Governor, 1871, 30, 11. HBCA B200/39/vol. 1.
a To Donald A. Smith, 1872, 28, 02. HBCA B200/39/vol. 1.
b To Smith, 1872, 06, 08. HBCA B200/39/vol. 1.
Hargrave, Letitia. 1851 To James Hargrave, 1851, 10, 08, in McLeod, Letters.
Healey, W.J. 1923 Women of Red River: Being a Book Written from the Recollections of Women from the Red River Era. Winnipeg: Women’s Canadian Club, 1923. Web.
Hooper, Lieut. W. H. 1853 Ten Months Among the Tents of the Tuski, With Incidents of an Arctic Boat Expedition in Search of Sir John Franklin, As Far As the Mackenzie River and Cape Bathurst. London: John Murray. AMS Press, New York, 1976.
Hudson’s Bay Company, Fort Good Hope journal. 1822-34 HBCA, B/80/a/1-12.
Hudson’s Bay Company, Peel’s River (i.e. Fort McPherson) journal (PRJ). 1873, 05, 06. HBCA B157/a/4.
, 04, 11. HBCA B157/a/5.
Hunter, James. 1857 To CMS, 1857, 04, 11. A91.
a To CMS, 1858, 11, 02. A91.
b To CMS, 1858, 09, 04. A91.
c To CMS, 1858, 11, 05. A91.
d Journal, 1858, 08, 06. A91.
e Journal, 1858, 11, 08. A91.
f Journal, 1858, 16, 08. A91.
To CMS, 1858, 30, 11. A80.
Isbister, Alexander Kennedy. 1846 A few Words on the Hudson’s Bay Company; with a Statement of the Grievances of the Native an Half-Caste Indians, Addressed to the British Government through their Delegates now in London. London. Pamphlet. Web. Canadiana.org
Q+A 2495–2500, 2486–2488.
James, James Alton. 1942 The First Scientific Exploration Of Russian America And The Purchase Of Alaska. Northwestern University Studies In The Social Sciences, 1942, no. 4. Evanston, IL.
Kennicott, Robert. 1859 To Spencer Baird, 1859, 17, 11, in Lindsay, Beginnings, 28.
“Journal Of Robert Kennicott: Chicago To Fort Yukon And Return,” in James, First Scientific. See also Vanast, Rubaboo.
Kirkby, William West. 1859a Journal, 1859, 15, 08. A93.
b Journal, 1859, 20, 08. A93.
c Journal, 1859, 22, 08. A93.
d Journal, 1859, 23, 08. A93.
e Journal, 1859, 26, 08. A93.
f Journal, 1859, 27, 08. A93.
g Journal, 1859, 08, 09. A93.
h Journal, 1859, 09, 09. A93.
i Journal, 1859, 10, 11. A93.
a Journal, 1860, 19, 03. A93.
b Journal, 1860, 25, 03. A93.
To CMS, 1862, 29, 11. A93.
“A Journey to the Youcan Russian America.” Smithsonian Institution Ann. Reports 19: 416–420.
Laugrand, Frédéric. 2001 “Les missions Oblates auprès des Amérindiens et des Inuit du Nord canadien. Un chantier pour l’anthropologie historique.” Études d’histoires religieuses 67, 113–130.
Levasseur, Donat. 1995 Les Oblats de Marie-Immaculée dans le Grand Nord du Canada 1845–1967. Edmonton: Western Canadian Publisher.
Lewes, John. 1842 To Governor George Simpson, 1842, 07, 09. HBCA B200/b/16.
To Governor, 1843, 30, 07. HBCA B200/b/19.
Lindsay, Debra J. 1991 The Modern Beginnings of Subarctic Ornithology, Northern Correspondence with the Smithsonian Institution, 1856–1868. Winnipeg: The Manitoba Record Society.
Löwith, Karl. 1945 “Nietzsche’s Doctrine of Eternal Recurrence.” Journal of the History of Ideas 6(3): 273–284. http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/2707291
Appendix II. “Nietzsche’s Revival of the Doctrine of Eternal Recurrence.” In Meaning in History. Phoenix Books, University of Chicago Press, 1949.
Lyons, Natasha, Kate Hennessey, Charles Arnold, and Mervin Joe. 2011 The Inuvialuit Smithsonian Project: Winter 2009-Spring 2011. Vol. 1. June.
Mackenzie, Alexander. 1854 To J. Anderson, 1854, 22, 12. HBCA B200/b/32.
To Gntlm. in Charge, 1855, 10, 12. HBCA B200/b/32.
Mackenzie, Hector. 1840 To R. McLeod, 1840, 28, 07. HBCA B200/b/17.
Mamayauk (young woman from Kittigaryuit in the Mackenzie Delta). 1912 Told to Stefansson 1912, 06, 03. See Stefansson, 1914.
McCarthy, Martha. 1995 From the Great River to the Ends of the Earth. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.
McGhee, Robert. 1988 Beluga Hunters: An archeologic reconstruction of the history and culture of the Mackenzie Delta Kittegaryumiut. Hull: Canadian Museum of Civilization. Original edition: University of Newfoundland, 1974.
McGoogan, Ken. 2005 Lady Franklin’s Revenge: A True Story of Ambition, Obsession, and the Remaking of Arctic History. Toronto: Harper-Collins.
MacLeod, Margarett Arnett, ed. 1947 The Letters of Letitia Hargrave. Toronto: The Champlain Society.
McLean, John and W. Stewart Wallace. 1932 John McLean’s Notes of a Twenty-Five Year’s Service in the Hudson’s Bay Territory. Toronto: Champlain Society (reproduction of the 1849 original).
McPherson, Murdo. 1840 To John Bell, 1840, 02, 06. HBCA B200/b/12.
Merriman, C. D. 2006 “Charles Dickens,” Literature Network, web. Accessed 2008, 10, 01.
Morton, Desmond. 2001 A Short History of Canada. Toronto: McLelland.
Nuligak, [Robert]. 1966 I, Nuligak. Maurice Métayer, transl. and ed. Toronto: Martin.
Oosenbrug, Joslyn. 2011 Interview with W. Vanast, 2011, 17, 02, and with John Brownlee, 2011, 24, 02, on her radio program The Trailbraker, Canadian Broadcasting Corporation North, Yellowknife, NWT.
Owram, Doug. 1992 Promise of Eden: The Canadian Expansionist Movement and the Idea of the West, 1856-1900. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. (first issue in 1980; 1992 version has new introduction).
Palssen, Gisli. 2001 Writing on Ice: The Ethnographic Notebooks of Vilhjalmur Stefansson. Hanover: New England University Press.
Pannekoek, Frits. 1970 Protestant Agricultural Missions in the Canadian West to 1870. Dissertation, University of Alberta.
“The Anglican Church and the Disintegration of Red River Society, 1818-1870.” In The Prairie West, Historical Readings, edited by Douglas, Francis R. and Howard Palmer, 100–116. Edmonton: Pica Press. Originally in Berger, Carl and Ramsay Cook, eds. 1976. The West and the Nation. Toronto: McLellan and Stewart.
Payment, Diane. 2003 “Marie Fisher Gaudet (1813–1914): ‘la Providence du fort Good Hope.’” Ecclectica 2: 1–14. Web. Accessed 2009, 03, 12.
Peel, Bruce. 2000 “James Hunter.” DCBO. Web. Accessed 2007, 12, 04.
Peers, Augustus. 1849, 04, 07. Peel’s River House. Journals kept by Angus [sic] R. Peers. NAC MG19, D12, Reel H2341.
, 31, 08. Peel’s River House. Journals. NAC source as above.
Petitot, Émile. 1865 To Oblate Director General L. Fabre in Rome, 1865, 21, 03. Oblate Archives, Rome.
Porter, Andrew. 1985 “‘Commerce and Christianity’: The Rise and Fall of a Nineteenth-Century Missionary Slogan.” The Historical Journal 28(3): 597–621. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0018246X00003320
Porter, Sophie E. 1895 Jesse H. Freeman log,1895, 04, 06. Old Dartmouth Historical Society, Roll 1010, frame 362-422. Catalogue # 1080.
Rae, John. 1851 To Sir George Simpson, 1851, 23, 04. In Rich, Rae’s Correspondence, 174–175. Web.
Rasmussen, Knud. 1942 The Mackenzie Eskimos, after Knud Rasmussen’s Posthumous Notes. H. Osterman ed. Copenhagen: Gyldenhalske Boghandel.
Rich, Edwin Ernest and A. M. Johnson. 1953 Rae’s Correspondence with the Hudson’s Bay Company on Arctic Exploration 1844–1855 Hudson’s Bay Record Society. Web.
Richardson, John. 1851 Arctic Searching Expedition: A Journal of a Boat-Voyage Through Rupert’s Land and the Arctic Sea in Search of the Discovery Ships Under Command of Sir John Franklin. London. Greenman Press, New York, 1969, vol. 1, 214–215.
Rivera Pagán, Luis N. 1992 A Violent Evangelism: The Political and Religious Conquest of the Americas. Westminster: John Knox Press. Transl. from Evangelización y Violencia: La conquista de América. San Juan: CEMI, 1991.
Ross, Bernard Rogan. 1858 To Governor, 1858, 29, 11. HBCA B200/b/33.
To Governor, 1859, 26, 03. HBCA B200/b/33.
To Spencer Baird, 1860, 20, 06. In Lindsay, Modern Beginnings.
a To Baird, 1860, 20, 06. In Lindsay.
b To Governor, 1861, 20, 03. HBCA B200/b/33.
c To Charles Gaudet, 1861, 26, 03. HBCA B200/b/33.
d To Baird, 1861, 10, 07. In Lindsay.
e To Baird, 1861, 20, 11. In Lindsay.
Samson, Jane. 2004 “The problem of colonialism in the western historiography of Christian mission,” Religious Studies and Theology 23(2): 3–25.
Simpson, George. 1854 To James Anderson, 1854, 10, 11. HBCA B200/c/1.
To Bernard R. Ross, 1859, 15, 06. HBCA B200/b/34.
Simpson, Thomas. 1845 Narrative of the Discoveries of the North Coast of America: Effected by the Officers of the Hudson’s Bay Company During the Years 1836–1839. London: Richard Bentley.
Smith, Edward (Édouard). 1826 To HBC Governor, 1826, 29, 11. HBCA B200/b/3.
a To John Bell, 1830, n.d., 10. HBCA B200/b/6.
b To Governor, 1830, 28, 11. HBCA B200/b/6.
To Governor, 1831, 03, 06. HBCA B200/b/7.
Stanley, Brian. 1983 “‘Commerce and Christianity’: Providence Theory, the Missionary Movement, and the Imperialism of Free Trade, 1842-1860.” The Historical Journal 26(1): 71–94. http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0018246X00019609
Stefansson, Vilhjalmur. 1906 Diary, 1906, 17, 02. Palssen 122.
Diary, 1907, 05, 02. In Stefansson 1914, 180.
a Diary, 1912, 06, 03. In Stefannson 1914, 358.
b Diary, 1912, 18, 04. In Stefansson, 1914, 380-1 (missing from Palssen).
The Stefansson-Anderson Arctic Expedition of the American Museum: Preliminary Report. Anthropological Papers of the Amer. Mus. of Natural History, XIV, part 1.
Diary, 1916, 29, 02. Typed transcript. Dartmouth College Library Stef. MSS 98 (5): V-9.
Stringer, Isaac. 1895-1909. Journal dates in endnote 18. Anglican Church in Canada, Toronto, General Synod Archives, Stringer Family Fonds, M74-3, Box 5, Series 1-B.
Journal, 1900, 08, 08.
Journal, 1909, 27, 07.
Stringer, Sarah Ann. 1901 Journal, 1901, 08-18, 04. Anglican Church in Canada, Toronto, General Synod Archives, Stringer Family Fonds, M74-3, Box 14, Series 2-C, Diaries, No. 1, 1896–1901.
Vanast, Walter. 2006a “‘Une Faute d’Orthographe’: A Sexual History of Missions to the Mackenzie Inuit.” Unpublished article.
b From Adam to Yekipegiak: An Alphabetic Compilation of References to Canadian Inuit (the Kukpugmiut) in the Mackenzie Delta 1859–1924. Docstoc.com. Web.
c From A’bouk to Zexana: An alphabetic listing of references to Inuit of Alaskan Origin (the Nunatagmiut) in the Mackenzie Delta, 1859–1924. Docstoc.com. Web.
“The Bad Side to The Good Story: Vilhjalmur Stefansson and Christian Conversion in the Mackenzie Delta 1906–1925.” Religious Study and Theology 26: 77–116.
“‘Hold the Fort for I am Coming,’ Primary Data related to the link between Inuit missions and HBC promises of a fur-trade post in the Mackenzie Delta.” Draft 2. Docstoc.com. Web.
a Tupilaq: Inuit and Spirits in the Eastern Mackenzie Delta, 1865–1912, as told by Mamayauk, Guninana, Tannaumirk, and others to V. Stefansson. Docstoc.com. Web.
b Rubaboo: Robert Kennicot’s Journal of the Lower Mackenziezie District, 1859–1852. Modified version of the journal published in 1942 by James Alton James. Docstoc.com. Web.
c “Sorciers, Eunuques, et Libertins Hypocrites”: Citations from the Letters of Fathers Petitot and Séguin relevant to the Inuit of the Mackenzie Delta, 1865–1882. Docstoc.com. Web.
d Oblate Defeat: Father Camille Lefebvre, Reverend Isaac Stringer and the Competition for Mackenzie Inuit allegiance, 1892–1894. Primary data from diaries and correspondence. Scribd.com. Web.
Van Kirk, Sylvia. 1983 Many Tender Ties. Tulsa: Univversity of Oklahoma Press.
Wilfong-Pritchard, Geoffrey. 1999 Cloven Hoof: Historical Drama and the Construction of Narrative History. Theology Thesis (D. Min.), St. Stephen’s College, University of Alberta. Web.
