When Johnny comes marching home
The long march from recruitment to counterculture of a Civil War song
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/pomh.22293Keywords:
propaganda, Civil War music, recruitment, Patrick Gilmore, minstrelsy, World War I music, British music hall, Vietnam War music, Anglo-Sudanese War, Penny Dreadfuls, Boer War music, Irish Republicanism, animation, World War II music, anti-war musicAbstract
Patrick Gilmore’s ‘When Johnny Comes Marching Home’ is one of the best-known American Civil War songs. By addressing the return of a single soldier—Johnny—it promises those who enlist a glorious return and the appreciation of a grateful society. As a piece of propaganda, it has been remarkably resilient, outliving the conflict for which it was composed and even today is frequently performed by military marching bands within the United States. But the song contains a level of ambiguity which allows it to be reimagined. It is this ambiguity that has allowed it to evolve, and even whilst retaining its original meaning, it has become its own antithesis, decrying the indifference of society to the plight of the returning soldier and highlighting the cost of their sacrifice.
References
Newspapers
Bury Times. 1865. ‘Butterworth’s Christy’s Minstrels’, 18 November.
Dundee Courier and Argus. 1865. ‘Dunfirmline—Abbey Church Soiree’, 18 March.
Dwight’s Journal of Music. 1862. ‘Gilmore’s Celebrated Band’, 13 September: 207.
Era. 1865. ‘Scotia Music Hall’, 2 July.
Era. 1899. ‘Music Hall Gossip’, 2 December.
Evening Telegraph. 1898. ‘Current Opinion: Victory in the Soudan’, 9 April.
Exeter and Plymouth Gazette. 1924. ‘Exeter Rotarians—Addressed by Chairman’, 30 January.
Halfpenny Marvel. 1895. ‘The Phantom Mountain’, 12 March.
Illustrated Chips. 1900. ‘When Tommy Comes Marching Home’, 3 March.
Liverpool Mercury. 1865. ‘Public Entertainments’, 25 September.
Manchester Times. 1898. ‘How the Boers Fight’, 9 December.
Newcastle Journal. 1865. ‘News’, 30 December.
Pall Mall Gazette. 1882. ‘The Literature of Crime’, 27 May.
The Times. 1899. ‘The Transvaal Crisis’, 7 October.
Western Gazette. 1931. ‘Advertisements and Notices’, 6 March.
Yorkshire Evening Post. 1898. ‘When Tommy Comes Marching Home Again’, 7 October.
Articles
Badillo, Gilbert, and G. David Curry. 1976. ‘The Social Incidence of Vietnam Casualties: Social Class or Race?’ Armed Forces and Society 2/3: 397–406. https://doi.org/10.1177/0095327X7600200305
Bateson, Catherine V. 2019. ‘“Forward for our Homes!” Lyrical Expressions of Home Heard in Irish American Civil-War Songs’. Journal of History and Cultures 9: 86–100.
Behrman, Cynthia. 1971. ‘The After-Life of General Gordon’. Albion 3/2: 47–61. https://doi.org/10.2307/4048413
Billings, Elden B. 1968. ‘The Civil War and Conscription’. Current History 52/322: 333–38. https://doi.org/10.1525/curh.1968.54.322.333
Blair, John. 1992. ‘Blackface Minstrels in Cross-Cultural Perspective’. American Studies International 28/2: 52–65.
Cipolla, Frank J. 1988. ‘Patrick S. Gilmore: The Boston Years’. American Music 6/3: 281–92. https://doi.org/10.2307/3051884
Cohen, Wilbur J. 1945. ‘The Federal Government’s Program for Ex-Servicemen’. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 238: 63–70. https://doi.org/10.1177/000271624523800109
De Nie, Michael. 2012. ‘“Speed the Mahdi!” The Irish Press and Empire during the Sudan Conflict of 1883–1885’. Journal of British Studies 51/4: 883–909. https://doi.org/10.1086/667397
Dupree, A. Hunter, and Leslie H. Fishel, Jr. 1960. ‘An Eyewitness Account of the New York Draft Riots, 1863’. The Mississippi Valley Historical Review 47/3: 472–79. https://doi.org/10.2307/1888878
Fearing, Franklin. 1945. ‘Warriors Return: Normal or Neurotic’. Hollywood Quarterly 1/1: 91–109. https://doi.org/10.1525/fq.1945.1.1.04a00160
Fish, Lydia M. 1989. ‘General Edward G. Lansdale and the Folksongs of Americans in the Vietnam War’. Journal of American Folklore 102/406: 390–411. https://doi.org/10.2307/541780
Fulton, Richard. 2009. ‘The Sudan Sensation of 1898’. Victorian Periodicals Review 42/1: 37–63. https://doi.org/10.1353/vpr.0.0061
Gordon, Michelle. 2019. ‘Viewing Violence in the British Empire: Images of Atrocity from the Battle of Omdurman, 1898’. Journal of Perpetrator Research 2/2: 65–100. https://doi.org/10.21039/jpr.2.2.10
Hacker, J. David. 2011. ‘A Census Based Count of the Civil War Dead’. Civil War History 57/4: 307–348. https://doi.org/10.1353/cwh.2011.0061
Hall, Mitchell. 1995. ‘Unsell the War: Vietnam and the Antiwar Advertising’. The Historian 58/1: 69–86. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6563.1995.tb00939.x
Healy, Catherine. 2022. ‘Ethnic Jokes: Mocking the Irish Working Woman’. Journal of Victorian Culture 27/1: 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1093/jvcult/vcab058
Humphreys, Jere T. 1987. ‘Strike Up the Band! The Legacy of Patrick S. Gilmore’. Music Educators’ Journal 74/2: 22–26. https://doi.org/10.2307/3401252
Jalland, Patricia, and John Stubbs. 1981. ‘The Irish Question After the Outbreak of War in 1914: Some Unfinished Party Business’. The English Historical Review 96/381: 778–807. https://doi.org/10.1093/ehr/XCVI.CCCLXXXI.778
James, David. 1989. ‘The Vietnam War and American Music’. Social Text 23: 122–43. https://doi.org/10.2307/466424
KMC. 1922. ‘Thomas Atkins’. Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research 1/5: 135.
Layish, Aharon. 1997. ‘The Legal Methodology of the Mahdi in the Sudan 1881–1885: Issues in Marriage and Divorce’. Sudanic Africa 8: 37–66.
Levine, Peter. 1981. ‘Draft Evasion in the North during the Civil War, 1863–1865’. Journal of American History 67/4: 816–35. https://doi.org/10.2307/1888051
McConnel, James. 2007. ‘Recruiting Sergeants for John Bull? Irish Nationalist MPs and Enlistment During the Early Months of the Great War’. War in History 14/4: 408–428. https://doi.org/10.1177/0968344507081552
Newsinger, James. 1983. ‘James Connolly and the Easter Rising’. Science and Society 47/2: 152–77.
Poston, Lawrence. 2005. ‘Henry Wood, the “Proms” and National Identity in Music, 1894–1905’. Victorian Studies 47/3: 397–426. https://doi.org/10.2979/VIC.2005.47.3.397
Robinson, Peter. 2008. ‘The Search for Mobility During the Second Boer War’. Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research 86.346: 140–57.
Senelick, Laurence, 1975. ‘Politics as Entertainment: Victorian Music Hall Songs’. Victorian Studies 19/2: 149–80.
Shields, Patricia M. 1981. ‘The Burden of the Draft: The Vietnam Years’. Journal of Political and Military Sociology 9: 215–28.
Springhall, John. 1990. ‘“A Life Story for the People”? Edwin J. Brett and the Low Life “Penny Dreadfuls” of the 1860s’. Victorian Studies 33/2: 223–46.
Springhall, John. 1994. ‘“Pernicious Reading”? “The Penny Dreadful” as Scapegoat for Late-Victorian Juvenile Crime’. Victorian Periodicals Review 27/4: 326–49.
Wegner, Ansley Herring. 2008. ‘When Johnny Couldn’t Come Marching Home Again—Civil War Amputations’. Tar Heel Junior Historian. North Carolina: NC Museum of History.
Yates, Mike. 2020. (Insert) Wait ’Till the Clouds Roll By. Stroud, UK: Musical Tradition Records – MTCD518-0.
Books
Ayto, John, and John Simpson. 2010. Oxford Dictionary of Modern Slang. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bowen, Thomas, and Lydia M. Fish. 1990. The Longest Year: A Collection of Songs by Advisors and Civilians in the Vietnam War. n.p.: privately printed.
Bradley, Doug, and Craig Werner. 2015. We Got to Get Out of this Place: The Soundtrack to the Vietnam War. Massachusetts: University of Massachusetts Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt1cx3srf
Dungan, Myles. 2014. Irish Voices from the Great War. Co. Kildare: Irish Academic Press.
Farwell, Byron. 1973. Queen Victoria’s Little Wars. Trowbridge, UK: Pen and Sword.
Goud, Brandon R., and Stanley A. Horowitz. 2011. ‘History of Combat Pay’. In The Eleventh Quadrennial Review of Military Compensation, 207–266. Alexandria, VA: Institute for Defense Analyses.
Grant, James. 1897. Recent British Battles at Land and Sea, Vol. 4. London and Paris: Cassel.
Hamm, Charles. 1979. Yesterdays: Popular Songs in America. New York: Norton.
Judd, Denis, and Keith Surridge. 2002. The Boer War. London: John Murray.
Lighter, Jonathan. 2012. The Best Anti-War Song Ever Written—Occasional Papers in Folklore. New Jersey: Loomis House.
Little, Donald D., and Barry Spink. 2013. USAF Personnel Rotation in Southeast Asia (A Chronology), 1961 through 1971. Alabama: Air Force Historical Research Agency.
McKenzie, John M. 1984. Propaganda and Empire: The Manipulation of British Public Opinion, 1880–1960. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
McWhirter, Christian. 2012. Battle Hymns: The Power and Popularity of Music in the Civil War. North Carolina: University of North Carolina Press. https://doi.org/10.5149/9780807882627_mcwhirter
Mellor, John. 1916. British War Songs, Old English Ballads and Other Miscellaneous Selections. Pittsburgh: Mellor & Sons.
Meyer, Jessica. 2018. When Tommy Comes Limping Home: Caring for the British War Disabled After 1918. London: British Commission for Military History.
Mulcahy, Michael, and Marie Fitzgibbon. 1982. The Voice of the People—Songs and History of Ireland. Dublin: Obrien Press.
Neufeld, Charles. 1899. A Prisoner of the Khaleefa: Twelve Years’ Captivity at Omdurman. London: Chapman & Hall.
Ohrwalder, Joseph. 1892. Ten Years’ Captivity in the Mahdi’s Camp. London: S. Low, Marston.
Parkenham, T. 1991. The Scramble for Africa, 1876–1912. London: Random House.
Regan, Geoffrey. 1997. Great British Battles. London: Michael O’Mara.
Shull, Michael S., and David E. Wilt. 2004. Doing Their Bit: Wartime American Animated Short Films, 1939–1945. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
Smurthwaite, David. 2002. The Boer War 1899–1902. London: Hamlyn.
Spiers, Edward M. 2004. The Victorian Soldier in Africa. Manchester: Manchester University Press. https://doi.org/10.7228/manchester/9780719061219.001.0001
Stevens, G. W. 1898. With Kitchener to Khartoum. New York: Mean & Company.
Tuso, Joseph. 1990. Singing the Vietnam Blues: Songs of the Airforce in South-East Asia. Texas: A&M University Press.
Van Ronk, Dave, and Richard Ellington. 1959. The Bosses Songbook: Songs to Stifle the Flames of Discontent, 2nd edn. New York: Richard Ellington.
Wessels, André. 2016. ‘The Anglo-Boer War (1899–1902) and its Traumatic Consequences’. In Breaking International Cycles of Repetition: A Global Dialogue on Historical Trauma and Memory, ed. Pumla Gobodo-Madikizela, 160–73. Opladen: Verlag Barbara Budrich. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvdf03jc.14
Winfield, Rhonda. 2006. When Johnny Doesn’t Come Marching Home—A Mother’s Story of the Price of Freedom. Topsail Beach, NC: Caisson Press.
Yates, Lt. Colonel, William T. 2008. ‘When Johnny Comes Limping Home’. Terre Haute, IN: United States Air Force Chaplin Service.
Songs
Anon. 1856. ‘Welcome Home Our Gallant Soldiers’. London: Rail & co. National Library of Scotland. Crawford.EB.1738.
Anon. 1865. ‘Victory at Last!’ New York: Wm. B. Bradbury. www.loc.gov/item/amss.as203740/
Beckel, J. C. 1863. ‘The Battle of Gettysburg’. Philadelphia: Winner & Co. https://www.loc.gov/item/ihas.200000042/
Costello, Tom. 1900. ‘The Boers Have Got My Daddy’. Tom, Day & Hunter.
Emmett, Dan D. 1859. ‘(I Wish I Was in) Dixie’s Land’. New York: Firth, Pond & Co.
Gilmore, Patrick S. 1863. ‘When Johnny Comes Marching Home’. Boston: Henry Tolman & Co.
Haynes, Chas, and Jas. Edward Haynes. 1864. ‘The Massacre at Fort Pillow’. Chicago: Winner & Co. www.loc.gov/item/ihas.200001351/
Jessie, Patrick. 1863(?) ‘When This Cruel Draft is Over’. J. Wrigley (publisher), BLL01016048483.
McCarthy, Harry. 1861. ‘The Bonnie Blue Flag’. A. E. Blackmar & Bro., New Orleans. https://www.loc.gov/item/ihas.200002490/
Marlow, Harry. 1914. ‘Pack up Your Troubles in Your Old Kit Bag’. Bulldog 595/313.
Marlow, Harry. 1914. ‘Stand Back Boys Here Comes a Soldier’. Bulldog 595/304.
Marlow, Harry. 1914. ‘When Tommy Comes Marching Home’. Bulldog Records 599/311.
O’Connor, Jack, and Arthur Le Clerq. 1915. ‘Somewhere in France, Dear Mother’. London: Lawrence Wright Music Co.
Patton, William. 1861. ‘John Brown Song’. https://www.loc.gov/item/amss.as106750/
Sandy & Sue (The Powell Sisters). 1967. ‘Our Daddy’s in Vietnam’. Basic Records (5).
Sullivan, Thomas D., and J. Harry Heywood. 1862. ‘The Flag of Sumter’. New York: John J. Daly. www.loc.gov/item/ihas.200002030/
Webster J. P., and S. Fillmore Bennet. 1862. ‘The Irish Volunteer’. Chicago: H.M. Higgens.
Work, Henry C. 1862. ‘Kingdom Coming’. Chicago: Root & Cady. www.loc.gov/item/ihas.200002350
Work, Henry C. 1865. ‘Marching Through Georgia’. Cleveland: S. Brainard’s Son’s, www.loc.gov/item/ihas.200002356/
Recordings
Bérurier Noir. 1984. ‘Johnny Reviens d’la Guerre’. Macadam Massacre. Rock Radical Records RRR006.
Clash, The. 1979. English Civil War. London: CBS 7082.
Freedom Toast and Parody Project. 2019. When Johnny Comes Rolling Home. YouTube video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1eR0ckpJ3bk
Lloyd, Marie. 1915. Now You’ve Got Your Khaki On. Regal Records G7263.
Parton, Dolly. 2003. ‘When Johnny Comes Marching Home’. For God and Country. Blue Eyes Records 79756-2.
Reubens, Paul A. 1914. Your King and Country Want You. His Master’s Voice 17495.
Sadler, Sgt. Barry. 1966. Ballads of the Green Berets. RCA-Victor, LPM 3547.
Wright, Johnny. 1965. Hello Vietnam. Decca, DL74698.
Online Resources
Committee to Help Unsell the War. c.1965–1975. When Johnny Comes Marching Home Again, Hurrah, Hurrah [Photograph]. Retrieved from the Library of Congress. https://www.loc.gov/item/2016649864/
Crafts, Nicholas. 2014. ‘Walking Wounded: The British Economy in the Aftermath of World War I’. Vox Eu Cepr: Research Based Policy Analysis and Commentary from Leading Economists. https://voxeu.org/article/walking-wounded-british-economy-aftermath-world-war-i
Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum. n.d. ‘Republic F-105D Thunderchief’. https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/republic-f-105d-thunderchief/nasm_A19820064000
