Breast Cancer Narratives as Public Rhetoric

Genre Itself and the Maintenance of Igorance

Authors

  • Judy Z. Segal University of British Columbia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1558/lhs.v3i1.3

Keywords:

Rhetoric, Genre, Breast Cancer, Narrative, Ignorance

Abstract

This paper explores questions of the permissible and the impermissible in breast cancer narratives. It deploys (inter alia) a theory of discourse and counterdiscourse to argue that the genre itself of the personal narrative performs a regulatory function in public discourse on cancer. The paper is inspired by an idea introduced into science studies by Schiebinger and Proctor—the idea of agnotology: the cultural production of ignorance. The paper argues that ignorance about cancer is maintained, in part, by the rehearsal of stories that have standard plots and features, and that suppress or displace other stories. The paper turns on examples of both conventional and unconventional stories. It focuses on Barbara Ehrenreich’s renegade cancer story and its public reception, and Wendy Mesley’s renegade cancer television documentary and the public reception of that. The paper seeks to contribute to genre studies by analyzing instances of a genre of public discourse, and suggesting the nature of the social action performed by the genre itself.

Author Biography

Judy Z. Segal, University of British Columbia

Judy Z. Segal is Professor of English at the University of British Columbia, where she teaches the history and theory of rhetoric as well as the rhetoric of science and medicine.

References

Allemang, J. (2002) Accentuating the positive produces negative results. Globe and Mail 16 November: F7.

Arimidex. (2006) AstraZeneca advertisement. Beyond Fall/Winter: 17.

Broom, D. (2001) Reading breast cancer: reflections on a dangerous intersection. Health 5: 249–268.

Burke, K. (1969) A Grammar of Motives. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Bury, M. (2001) Illness narratives: fact or fiction? Sociology of Health and Illness 23: 263–285.

Castleman, M. (2006) Breast cancer is one of the best things that ever happened to me: three women get a new outlook on life after cancer. Beyond Fall/Winter: 31–37.

Charon, R. (2006) Narrative Medicine: Honoring the Stories of Illness. New York: Oxford University Press.

Collishaw, N.E. (2006) An open letter to Wendy Mesley. Physicians for a Smoke-Free Canada 10 March. Retrieved on 10 October 2006 from www.smoke-free.ca.

Couser, G.T. (1997) Recovering Bodies: Illness, Disability, and Life Writing. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

Davis, D. (2007) The Secret History of the War on Cancer. New York: Basic Books

Donaldson, J. (2007) Curly hair and other gifts cancer gave me. Beyond Spring/Summer: 26

Dube, R. and Agrell, S. (2007) Still a case for checking your breasts. Globe and Mail 28 September: L1, L3.

Ehrenreich, B. (2001) Welcome to Cancerland. Harper’s November: 43–53.

Engelberg, M. (2006) Cancer Made Me a Shallower Person: A Memoir in Comics. New York: HarperCollins.

Frank, A. (1995) The Wounded Storyteller: Body, Illness, and Ethics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995.

Fraser, L. (2007) The bad girls of breast cancer: why Breast Cancer Action’s women don’t wear pink. Beyond Spring/Summer: 87–89.

Gee, D. (2007) Breast cancer made me … . Beyond Spring/Summer: 39–43.

Gelman, P. and Zemsky, L. (2004) Humor after the Tumor: One Woman’s Look at Her Year with Breast Canccer. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.

Genentech (2006) Genentech advertisement. Harper’s September: back cover.

Gold, K. (2008) Singer Bif Naked diagnosed with breast cancer. Globe and Mail 7 January: A3.

Gross, K.J. (2006) Express yourself. Beyond Fall/Winter: 66–75.

Gross, K.J. (2007) Give yourself a beauty boost. Beyond Spring/Summer: 95–99.

Harvey, S. (2006) A cartoon but no joke: a review of Cancer Vixen: A True Story. Globe and Mail 7 October: D14.

Herndl, D.P. (2006) Our breasts, our selves: identity, community, and ethics in cancer autobiographies. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 32: 221–245.

Hunt, M. (2006) Undefeated. Vancouver, BC: Greystone Books.

King, S. (2006) Pink Ribbons, Inc.: Breast Cancer and the Politics of Philanthropy. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

King, S. (2008) The great pinkwashing: breast cancer, cause marketing, and the politics of women’s health. Public lecture, Simon Fraser University, 18 February.

Lantz, P.M. and Booth, K.M. (1998) The social construction of the breast cancer epidemic. Social Science and Medicine 46: 907–918.

Lerner, Barron H. (2001) The Breast Cancer Wars: Hope, Fear, and the Pursuit of a Cure in Twentieth-Century America. New York: Oxford University Press.

Lippman, A. (2006) Breast cancer: the personal and the political. Globe and Mail 7 October: D15.

Lorde, A. ([1980] 1997) The Cancer Journals. San Francisco: Aunt Lute Books.

Lucas, G. (2004) Why I Wore Lipstick to My Mastectomy. New York: St. Martin’s Press.

Marchetto, M.A. (2006) Cancer Vixen. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.

Mesley, W. (2006) Chasing the cancer answer. Marketplace. CBC Television. Broadcast 5 March.

Miller, C.R. (1994) Rhetorical community: the cultural basis of genre. In A. Freedman and P. Medway (eds) Genre and the New Rhetoric. London and New York: Taylor & Francis.

Pezzullo, P. (2003) Resisting ‘National Breast Cancer Awareness Month’: the rhetoric of counterpublics and their cultural performances. Quarterly Journal of Speech 89: 345–365.

Pitts, V. (2004) Illness and internet empowerment: writing and reading breast cancer in cyberspace. Health 8: 33–59.

Porter, K. (2007) Tomorrow is the new now. Globe and Mail 24 May: L8.

Potts, L.K. (2000) Publishing the personal: autobiographical narratives of breast cancer and the self. In L.K. Potts (ed.) Ideologies of Breast Cancer: Feminist Perspectives 98–127. New York: St. Martin’s Press.

Rollin, B. (1976) First You Cry. New York: New American Library.

Ryan, C. (2005) Struggling to survive: a study of editorial decision-making strategies at Mamm magazine. Journal of Business and Technical Communication 19: 353–376.

Ryan, G. (2008) The cancer roller coaster. Globe and Mail 6 March: L8.

Salinas, E. (2006) Global donor search ends as girl, 3, dies. Globe and Mail 28 June: S2.

Schiebinger, L. and Proctor, R. (2005) Agnotology: the cultural production of ignorance. Conference web site. Retrieved on 15 October 2006 from http://www.stanford.edu/ dept/HPS/AgnotologyConference.html

Segal, J.Z. (2005) Health and the Rhetoric of Medicine. Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.

Shapiro, M. (2006a) Life in the Balance: My Journey with Breast Cancer. Toronto: HarperCollins.

Shapiro, M. (2006b) Family just one factor in breast-cancer risk. Globe and Mail.10 October: A11.

Solomon, M. (2007) Epistemological reflections on the ‘art’ of medicine and ‘narrative medicine’. Paper presented to the Department of Philosophy, University of Washington, Seattle, WA.

Sontag, S. ([1978] 1990) Illness as Metaphor and AIDS and Its Metaphors. New York: Anchor Books.

Spiegelman, A. (1986) Maus: A Survivor’s Tale, Part 1. New York: Pantheon Books.

Spiegelman, A. (1991) Maus: A Survivor’s Tale, Part 2. New York: Pantheon Books.

Taber, J. (2007) Belinda Stronach on staying strong: ‘I wasn’t expecting to face mortality.’ Globe and Mail 6 December: A6.

Tauber, M. (2006) Sheryl Crow strong enough. People 13 March 2006: 55–57.

Thomas-MacLean, R. (2004) Understanding breast cancer stories via Frank’s narrative types. Social Science and Medicine 58: 1647–1657.

Wente, M. (2006) The cancer answer is no answer. Globe and Mail 29 April: A17.

Yadlon, S. (1997) Skinny women and good mothers: the rhetoric of risk, control and culpability in the production of knowledge about breast cancer. Feminist Studies 23: 645–678.

Yandle, S. (2002) Letter. Harper’s February: 4–5.

Znaimer, L. (2007) Interview with Shannon Nelson. The Standard, Vancouver Channel 10. Broadcast 25 November.

Published

2008-09-09

How to Cite

Segal, J. Z. (2008). Breast Cancer Narratives as Public Rhetoric: Genre Itself and the Maintenance of Igorance. Linguistics and the Human Sciences, 3(1), 3–23. https://doi.org/10.1558/lhs.v3i1.3

Issue

Section

Articles