Ambiguous Matter
The Life of Mine Waste
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/jca.21645Keywords:
waste, heritage, commodity, resource extraction, iron, industrial archaeologyAbstract
This paper explores mine waste that originates from resource extraction by specifically focusing on waste rock, tailings, dust and material culture from the resource extraction industry. By drawing on examples from fieldwork, archives, local media commentary and limited interviews from two iron-mining regions in Arctic Norway and sub-Arctic Canada, this paper follows mine waste as it routinely transgresses attempts to be managed. Mine waste spills out of its prescribed sinks, it oscillates between being considered waste to heritage to potentially valuable commodity, and it blurs the boundaries between spaces dedicated for mining and for non-mining. In following these trends, the paper calls for attentiveness to the ambiguous materiality of mine waste and how heterogeneity and excess circumscribe attempts at easy characterisation and management of the ubiquitous wastes that come to dominate mining regions. As such, archaeological approaches to studying mine waste can illustrate how mine waste becomes the default, lived-with condition of life in regions dominated by ongoing mining operations.
References
North. 2004. “Dust on the Rise in Labrador West During Labour Dispute.” 53 North, 1 August, 9.
A/S Sydvaranger. 1970. “Nytt avgangssystem ved A/S Sydvaranger Kirkenes.” Letter, 5 May. Sydvaranger Arkiv, Svarkverket 2.1 Oppredingsverk 1. Box 322. Grenselandmuseet, Kirkenes, Norway.
____. 1973. Vedr: Registrering av spillvannsutslipp i Kirkenes. Letter, 16 January. Sydvaranger Arkiv, Svark Bolig-Eiendom-Infrast. 9.1 Bygningsavd. 31. Box 392. Grenselandsmuseet, Kirkenes, Norway.
Abarkach, M. 2021. “Dumperen hører til Bjørnevatn.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 20 July. Online: https://www.sva.no/2021/nyheter/dumperen-horer-til-bjornevatn/
Arvola, S. S. 2004. “Sydvaranger A/S 1906-2003: Fra Storindustri til Kulturminne.” In Kulturvern ved Bergverk 2003, edited by B. I. Berg, 48–65. Kongsberg: Norsk Bergverkmuseum.
Bartolini, N. and C. DeSilvey. 2020. “Making Space for Hybridity: Industrial Heritage Maturecultures at West Carclaze Garden Village, Cornwall.” Geoforum 113: 39–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoforum.2020.04.010
Beckett, C. and A. Keeling. 2018. “Rethinking Remediation: Mine Reclamation, Environmental Justice, and Relations of Care.” Local Environment 24 (3): 216–230. https://doi.org/10.1080/13549839.2018.1557127
Berg, B. I., F. Sæland, A. J. Nyland, P. Ø. Østensen, F. S. Nordrum and K. Kullerud. 2016. Bergverk i Norge: Kulturminner og Historie. Bergen: Fagbokforlaget.
Berger, A. 2002. Reclaiming the American West. New York: Princeton Architectural Press.
Bjørgan, A. M. 2002. “Steinflytteren.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 17 January: 12–13.
____. 2003. “Kan Bli Knutepunkthavn.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 20 February: 5.
Bleicher, A., M. David and H. Rutjes. 2019. “When Environmental Legacy becomes a Resource: On the Making of Secondary Resources.” Geoforum 101: 18–27. https://doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.geoforum.2019.02.018
Butcher, H., ed. 1997. Catalogue By Order of Sydvaranger ASA Due to Mine Closure, Major Sale by Auction. London: Henry Butcher.
Cabinet Briefs. 1979. Briefs Presented to Cabinet Meeting Held at Wabush Labrador Sep 27, 1979. Unpublished briefs, Wabush, NL, Canada.
Careen, E. 2021. “Something in the Air: Labrador West Residents Worried about Dust Cloud from Mine.” Saltwire Network, 26 July. Online: https://www.saltwire.com/atlantic-canada/news/something-in-the-air-labrador-west-residents-worried-about-dust-cloud-from-mine-100616274/
Darvill, T., ed. 2009. The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Archaeology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dawdy, S. L. 2016. Patina: A Profane Archaeology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. https://doi.org/10.7208/chicago/9780226351223.001.0001
Farstadvoll, S. 2019. “Vestigial Matters: Contemporary Archaeology and Hyperart.” Norwegian Archaeological Review 52 (1): 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1080/00293652.2019.1577913
Fløtten, F. 1996. “Ta Vare på Fortiden.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 24 October: 4.
Genge, N. 2009. “Unseasonable Weather Causes Extreme Dust Lift Off Over Towns.” 53 North 6 (12) [17 May]: 5.
Genge, N. and P. Genge. 2005. “Wabush Council Wants Answers on Dust - We Certainly Think Wabush Mines Can Do More: Skinner.” 53 North 2 (16) [19 June]: 3.
Genge, P. and N. Genge. 2005. “Active Weather Buries Wabush in Dust, Takes Trailer Roof.” 53 North 2 (14) [5 June]: 3.
Geren, R. and B. McCullough. 1990. Cain’s Legacy: The Building of Iron Ore Company of Canada. Sept-Iles, Quebec: Iron Ore Company of Canada.
Goin, P. and E. Raymond. 2001. “Living in Anthracite: Mining Landscape and Sense of Place in Wyoming Valley, Pennsylvania.” The Public Historian 23 (2): 29–45. https://doi.org/10.1525/tph.2001.23.2.29
Greiner, R. 1970. Notat vedr. utslipp av slam fra verket og 1 sjøen. Note, 2 April. Sydvaranger Arkiv, Svarkverket 2.1 Oppredingsverk 1. Box 322. Grenselandmuseet, Kirkenes, Norway.
Grønvik, Y. 2014. “Vi Vil Være med i Beslutningene.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 9 September: 4–5. Online: https://www.sva.no/2014/nyheter/vi-vil-vaere-med-i-beslutningene/
____. 2016. “Slambanken Kan Være Gullgruve.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 20 December: 5. Online: https://www.sva.no/2016/nyheter/slambanken-kan-vaere-gullgruve/
____. 2017. “Ønsker Drift i Slambanken og Gruva.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 5 May: 7. Online: https://www.sva.no/2017/nyheter/onsker-drift-i-slambanken-og-gruva/
____. 2019. “Demper Forventningene.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 21 March: 4–5.
Hammond, J. 2010. Labrador City Mine and Town: Fighting to Sustain the Land and People, BA diss., Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John’s.
Harrison, R. 2021. “Legacies: Rethinking the Futures of Heritage and Waste in the Anthropocene.” In Heritage Ecologies, edited by T. R. Bangstad and Þ. Pétursdóttir, 31–48. London: Routledge.
____. and C. Sterling, eds. 2020. Deterritorializing the Future: Heritage in, of and after the Anthropocene. London: Open Humanities Press.
Henriksen, H. 2013. “Sparer Deler av Bjørnevannet.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 21 March: 9.
Holmøy, T. 1974. Tillatelse for utslipp av avgang (gråberg). Letter, 21 October. Sydvaranger Arkiv, Svarkverket 2.1 Oppredingsverk 1. Box 322. Grenselandmuseet, Kirkenes, Norway.
Hudson-Edwards, K. A., H. E. Jamieson and B. G. Lottermoser. 2011. “Mine Wastes: Past, Present, Future.” Elements 7 (6): 375–380. https://doi.org/10.2113/gselements.7.6.375
Hynes, T. 2021. Workhorse. Montreal: BookArt.
Jakobsen, J. 2000. “Gjør Gråberg til Penger.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 22 August: 5.
Jerijervi, D. R. 2010. “Nytt Navn og Mange Mulighter.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 10 August: 11.
Keating, D. 2018. “A Town Marking Time.” Atlantic Business 29 (6): 17–21.
Keeling, A. and J. Sandlos, 2017. “Ghost Towns and Zombie Mines: The Historical Dimensions of Mine Abandonment, Reclamation, and Redevelopment in the Canadian North.” In Ice Blink, edited by S. Bocking and B. Martin, 377–420). Calgary: University of Calgary Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv6cfrkx.13
Kivinen, S. 2017. “Sustainable Post-Mining Land Use: Are Closed Metal Mines Abandoned or Re-Used Space?” Sustainability 9 (10): Article 1705. https://doi.org/10.3390/su9101705
Koivurova, T., V. Masloboev, K. Hossain, V. Nygaard, A. Petrétei and S. Vinogradova. 2015. “Legal Protection of Sami Traditional Livelihoods from the Adverse Impacts of Mining: A Comparison of the Level of Protection Enjoyed by Sami in Their Four Home States.” Arctic Review on Law and Politics 6 (1): 11–51. https://doi.org/10.17585/arctic.v6.76
Kojola, E. 2020. “Divergent Memories and Visions of the Future in Conflicts over Mining Development.” Journal of Political Ecology 27: 898–916. https://doi.org/10.2458/v27i1.23210
LeCain, T. J. 2009. Mass Destruction: The Men and Giant Mines that Wired America and Scarred the Planet. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
Lepawsky, J. 2018. Reassembling Rubbish: Worlding Electronic Waste. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/11111.001.0001
Liboiron, M. 2014. “Why Discard Studies?” Online: https://discardstudies.com/2014/05/07/why-discard-studies/
____. 2021. Pollution is Colonialism. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781478021445
Lottermoser, B. G. 2010. Mine Wastes: Characterization, Treatment, and Environmental Impacts. Townsville, QLD: Springer.
Lund, S. 2015. Gull, Gråstein, og Grums: Omstridde Gruver 1: Omstridde Gurver. Karasjok, Norway: Davvi Girji.
MacBride, S. 2012. Recycling Reconsidered: The Present Failure and Future Promise of Environmental Action in the United States. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/8829.001.0001
Measham, T., A. Walton and S. Felton. 2021. “Mining Heritage and Community Identity in the Social Licence of Proposed Renewed Mining.” The Extractive Industries and Society 8 (3): Article 100891. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.exis.2021.02.011
Næss, R. N. 2000. “Slambanken Uten Betydning.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 15 January: 2.
Nystad, O. 1974. Vedr.: Undersøkelse av avgangsmasse i Kirkenes. Report, 30 December. Sydvaranger Arkiv, Svarkverket 2.6 Prosj./forsking 4. Box 437, Grenselandmuseet, Kirkenes, Norway.
Olsen, B. J. 2003. “Material Culture After Text: Re?Membering Things.” Norwegian Archaeological Review 36 (2): 87–104. https://doi.org/10.1080/00293650310000650
____. 2010. In Defense of Things: Archaeology and the Ontology of Objects. Lanham, MD: AltaMira Press.
____. and Þ. Pétursdóttir. 2016. “Unruly Heritage Tracing Legacies in the Anthropocene.” Arkæologisk Forum 35: 38–45.
Olsen, B. J. and S. Vinogradova. 2019. “(In)significantly Soviet: The Heritage of Teriberka.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 26 (9): 901–918. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2019.1620831
Olsen, B. W. 2009. “Kan Stå Ferdig Om Ett År.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 5 March: 1.
____. 2010. “Vernet skipsvrak ved Slambanken.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 7 January: 3.
____. 2014. “Vil Påføre Reindriften Betydelige Skader og Ulemper.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 10 July: 7.
Øvrewall, F. ????. “Langfjorden Nesten Tettet Igjen på Få År.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 10 November: 8.
Payne, J. F., B. French, D. Hamoutene, P. Yeats, A. Rahimtula, D. Scruton and C. Andrews. 2001. “Are Metal Mining Effluent Regulations Adequate: Identification of a Novel Bleached Fish Syndrome in Association with Iron-Ore Mining Effluents in Labrador, Newfoundland.” Aquatic Toxicology 52 (3–4): 311–317. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0166-445X(00)00166-1
Pickards Mather & Co. 1968. Wabush Mines, Pickands Mather & Co., Managing Agent. Wabush, NL: Wabush Mines.
Pickett, J. 2005. “Wabush Tailings Revegetation Massive Project: Long-term Planning Required for Success.” 53 North 2 (24) [7 August]: 28.
Prieto, D. 2021. On Tending the Fog, the Stone, the Chisel, and the Marrow. St. John’s, NL: The Rooms.
Quivik, F. L. 2007. “The Historical Significance of Tailings and Slag: Industrial Waste as Cultural Resource.” Society for Industrial Archaeology 33 (2): 35–52.
____. 2013. “Nuisance, Source of Wealth, or Potentially Practical Material: Visions of Tailings in Idaho’s Coeur d’Alene Mining District, 1888-2001.” IA: The Journal of the Society for Industrial Archeology 39 (1–2): 41–64.
Rhatigan, J. 2020. “Mining Meaning: Telling Spatial Histories of the Britannia Mine.” Journal of Historical Geography 67: 36–47. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhg.2019.10.010
Rio Tinto. 2007. IOC 2007 Sustainable Development Report. Montreal: Iron Ore Company.
Robertson, D. 2006. Hard as the Rock Itself: Place and Identitty in the American Mining Town. Boulder: University Press of Colorado.
Royal Commission on Labrador. 1974. Report of the Royal Commission on Labrador. 6 vols. St. John’s, NL: The Commission.
Sandø, T. 1995. “Norgesrekord i Dioksinutslipp.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 6 April: 8–9.
____. 2002. “Strid om Pukkavtale.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 23 March: 5.
Sør-Varanger Avis. 1956. “Slig-slam som Betongblanding.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 9 June: 1.
____. 1960. “Slamrennen på A.S. Sydvaranger er nu 2000 m Lang.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 3 September: 1.
____. 1971. “Det Ventes på Komunalt Utspill i Kloakksaken.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 5 August: 1, 4.
____. 1976. “Miljøvern i Norge: Trange Fjorder Skaper Spesielle Problemer.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 20 November: 2.
____. 1978a. “Efter Utslippene i Landfjorden: Sydvaranger Finner Opprenskning Unødvendig.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 15 August: 1, 5.
____. 1978b. “Profilmålinger Beviser Sydvarangers Skadeverk.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 30 September: 9.
____. 1978c. “Spansertur på Langfjorden Beviser Sydvarangers Skadeverk.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 12 October: 7.
____. 1980. “Hva ville du gjøre hvis du fikk bestemme i Sør-Varanger?” Sør-Varanger Avis, 30 September: 2.
____. 1981. “Slig for Millioner på Slambanken i Kirkenes.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 16 June: 1.
Spracklin, A. 1993. Andy Spracklin / Interviewer: Unknown. Wabush, NL: Wabush Community Library.
Staniscia, S. and C. Yuill. 2017. “Reflections On Mountaintop Mining As Industrial Heritage.” Change Over Time 7 (1): 30–51. https://doi.org/10.1353/cot.2017.0002
Storm, A. 2014. Post-Industrial Landscapes Scars. New York: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137025999
____. 2021. “Scars: Living with Ambiguous Pasts.” In Heritage Ecologies, edited by T. R. Bangstad and Þ. Pétursdóttir, 49–65. London: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315101019-5
Sundland, K. 2019. “En Gigantisk Ansvarsfraskrivelse.” Sør-Varanger Avis, 21 March: 7.
Sweco. 2009. Vindkraftverk på Bjørnevatn Sydvaranger Gruve AS: Melding med Forslag til Konsekvensutredningsprogram. Tromsø: Troms Kraft. Online: https://webfileservice.nve.no/API/PublishedFiles/Download/200902421/200256
Sydvaranger Gruve AS. 2012. Sydvaranger Gruve AS: Forslag til Planprogram for Områderegulering med Konsekvensutredning. [Kirkenes]: Sør-Varanger Kommune and Sydvaranger Gruve AS.
Syrstad, S. E. 1991. “Gråberg gir Arbeid.” Sør-Varanger Avis 48: 27 April, 18.
Taranrød, J. b. 1993. “Gråberg-eksport for Milliarder.” Sør-Varanger Avis 73: 3 July, 12.
Tschudi Kirkenes and Sør-Varanger kommune. ????. Kirkenes Industrial Logistics Area (KILA): Forslag til områderegulering planbeskrivelse. [Kirkenes]: Tschudi Kirkenes and Sør-Varanger kommune.
Ureta, S. 2016a. “Caring for Waste: Handling Tailings in a Chilean Copper Mine.” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 48 (8): 1532–1548. https://doi.org/10.1177/0308518x16645103
____. 2016b. “Chemical Rubble: Historicizing Toxic Waste on a Former Mining Town in Northern Chile.” Arcadia 20. Environment & Society Portal. Online: http://www.environmentandsociety.org/node/7704
____. and P. Flores. 2018. “Don’t Wake Up the Dragon! Monstrous Geontologies in a Mining Waste Impoundment.” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 36 (6): 1063–1080. https://doi.org/10.1177/0263775818780373
Valestrand, H. E. 2014. “Text and Object: The Bus Shelter that Became Cultural Heritage.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 21 (1): 81–98. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2014.914558
Venovcevs, A. 2020a. “Extracted Frontiers: A Call from the North.” In Deterritorializing the Future: Heritage in, of and after the Anthropocene, edited by R. Harrison and C. Sterling, 311–317. London: Open Humanities Press.
____. 2020b. “Living with Socialism: Toward an Archaeology of a Post-Soviet Industrial Town.” The Extractive Industries and Society 8 (4): Article 100835. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.exis.2020.10.017
____. 2020c. “Twin Falls – Labrador’s Unruly Industrial Heritage.” Provincial Archaeology Office Annual Review 18: 214–226.
____. 2022. “A Contemporary Archaeology of Labrador West.” Provincial Archaeology Office Annual Review 20: 219–260.
____. in press. “Industrial Vestiges: Legacies of Ancillary Impacts of Resource Development.” Historical Archaeology.
____. and J. Williamson 2022. “Twin Falls Revisited – A Survey of Labrador’s First Industrial Community.” In Provincial Archaeology Office Annual Review 20: 261–282.
Wikan, S. 2006. Grubeforeningen Nordens Klippe. Olso: Pax Forlag.
Wråkberg, U. 2019. “Collective Memory of the Kirkenes Iron Mine in Sub-Arctic Norway: Its Role in Forming the Future.” Polar Record 56: Article e16. https://doi.org/10.1017/S003224741900038X
