New light on an old problem
Child-related archaeological finds and the impact of the ‘Radburn’ council estate plan.
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/jca.39686Keywords:
child, community, council estates, excavation, post-war, Radburn, social housingAbstract
This paper uses new data from archaeological excavations to explore the effectiveness of the “Radburn” layout used in many post-war social housing estates in the UK, the name referring to a design modelled on Radburn in New Jersey in the United States. Their design aimed to provide healthy living environments for less-affluent families by fronting homes onto communal pedestrianized “greens”, enabling people to circulate and children to “play out” safely near their homes. However, many Radburn estates are now socially deprived and explanations for this have included suggestions that the Radburn plan was inappropriate to the wants and needs of resident families. Analysis of 20 small archaeological excavations carried out in 2016 by residents of a Radburn-type council estate in Lincolnshire recovered lost aspects of its heritage, including a large number of child-related items from sites on the communal greens. This suggests that the greens were indeed used as intended for children’s play, undermining suggestions that inappropriate design was a significant factor in the decline of estates such as this. Open Access Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives: CC BY-NC-NDReferences
Allen, M. 2007. Archaeological desk-based assessment and metal detector survey; Land off Foxby Lane, Gainsborough, Lincolnshire. Unpublished archive report by Pre-Construct Archaeology available at https://archaeologydataservice.ac.uk/archsearch/record?titleId=1956291 (accessed 16/5/2019).
Arnot, C. 2003. “Art of the matter.” The Guardian, 13 August 2003. Accessible online at https://www.theguardian.com/society/2003/aug/13/housingpolicy.guardiansocietysupplement (accessed 14/5/2019).
Beckett, J. V. 1988. The East Midlands from AD 1000. London: Longman.
Beckwith, I. 1972. The History of Farms and Fields in Gainsborough. Gainsborough: Gainsborough Urban District Council.
Beckwith, I. 1991. The Book of Gainsborough. Oxford: Nuffield Press.
Beresford, M. and Finberg, H. P. R. 1973. English Medieval Boroughs: a Handlist. Newton Abbot: David and Charles.
Blazevicius, P. 2013. “Toys as a reflection of player’s social status.” In Child and Childhood in the Light of Archaeology, edited by P. Romanowicz, 137-152. Wroclaw: Chromicon Wydawnictwo.
Boughton, J. 2018. Municipal Dreams: The Rise and Fall of Council Housing. London: Verso Books.
Brown, B., Mackett, R., Gong, Y., Kitazawa, K. and Paskins, J. 2008. “Gender differences in children's pathways to independent mobility.” Children's Geographies 6 (4), 385-401.
Cameron, K. 1998. A Dictionary of Lincolnshire Place-Names. Nottingham: English Place-Name Society Popular Series No. 1.
Clark, R. H. 1998. Steam Engine Builders of Lincolnshire. Lincoln: Society for Lincolnshire History & Archaeology
Clay, C. 2007. Archaeological Investigation by Trial Trenching, The Becket School, Gainsborough, Lincolnshire. Unpublished report available at https://archaeologydataservice.ac.uk/archsearch/record?titleId=1927335 (accessed 16/5/2019)
Coleman, Alice M. 1985. Utopia on Trial: Vision and Reality in Planned Housing. London: Hilary Shipman.
Coleman, Alice. 2009. “The Psychology of Housing.” The Salisbury Review 28 (2), 10-12.
Cooper, N. and Priest, V. 2003. “Sampling a medieval village in a day.” Medieval Settlement Research Group Annual Report 18. 53-56.
Dalken, L. 1949. Children’s Games throughout the Year. London: Batsford.
Davis, O. 2017. Excavations at the deserted medieval village, Michaelston-Super-Ely, 2016. Cardiff: University of Cardiff Studies in Archaeology Specialist Report 37.
Davis, O, Sharples, N. M. and Wyatt, D. 2014. “The CAER Heritage Project: A preliminary note on recent research and community engagement at Caerau Hillfort, Cardiff.” Archaeology in Wales 53, 119-125.
Davis, O., Sharples, N. and Wyatt, D. 2015. Excavations at Caerau hillfort, Cardiff, South Wales, 2014: an interim report. Unpublished Project Report by Cardiff School of History Archaeology and Religion available at: https://caerheritageprojectdotcom1.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/caerau-interim-v1-1.pdf (accessed 16/5/2019)
Dunleavy, P. 1981. The Politics of Mass Housing in Britain, 1945-75: Study of Corporate Power and Professional Influence in the Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Esher, L. 1981. A Broken Wave: The Rebuilding of England 1940-1980. London: Allen Lane.
Everson, P. L., Taylor, C. C. and Dunn, C. J. 1991. Change and Continuity. Rural Settlement in North-West Lincolnshire. London: HMSO.
Foster, C. W. and Longley, T. (eds). 1976. The Lincolnshire Domesday and the Lindsey Survey. Lincoln: The Lincoln Record Society (19).
Glendinning, M., and Muthesius, S. 1994. Tower Block: Modern Public Housing in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. London: Yale University Press.
Grindrod, J. 2014. Concretopia: A Journey around the Rebuilding of Postwar Britain. London: Old Street.
Gomme, A. B. 1894. The Traditional Games of England, Scotland and Ireland, Volume 1. London: David Nutt (repr. 1984, London: Thames and Hudson).
Gomme, A. B. 1898. The Traditional Games of England, Scotland and Ireland, Volume 2. London: David Nutt (repr. 1984, London: Thames and Hudson).
Hadley, D.M. and Richards, J.D. 2016. “The Winter Camp of the Viking Great Army, AD 872-3, Torksey, Lincolnshire.” Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries 96, 23-67.
Hanley, L. 2007. Estates: An Intimate History. London: Granta.
Harrison, R. 2009. “Towards an Archaeology of the Welfare State in Britain, 1945–2009.” Archaeologies, 5 (2), 238–262.
Harrison, R and J. Schofield, 2010. After modernity: Archaeological approaches to the contemporary past. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Harwood, E and Powers A. 2008. Housing the Twentieth Century Nation, London: Historic England.
Heck, S. 1987. “Oscar Newman Revisited.” The Architect’s Journal 185, 30
Hills, J. 2004. Inequality and the State. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Historic England. Undated. Record for Gainsborough https://archaeologydataservice.ac.uk/archsearch/record?titleId=1188598
Letters, S. (ed.), 2005. Gazetteer of Markets and Fairs in England and Wales to 1516. Kew: List and Index Society.
Lewis, C. 2007. “New avenues in the investigation of currently-occupied rural settlements – preliminary results from the Higher Education Field Academy.” Medieval Archaeology 51, 133-164.
Lewis, C. 2009. Children’s play in the later medieval countryside. Childhood in the Past 2, 86-108.
Lewis, C. 2014. ‘The Power of Pits: Archaeology, outreach and research in living landscapes’ in Living in the Landscape, edited by K. Boyle, R. Rabett and C. Hunt, 321-338. Cambridge: McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research Monograph.
Lewis, C. 2015. ‘Archaeological Excavation and Deep Mapping in Historic Rural Communities’ Humanities 2015, 4: 393–417.
Lewis, C. 2019. “Test pit excavation as a method for reconstructing the development of currently occupied rural settlements: evidence from England” in Archaeology of Medieval Villages Currently Inhabited in Europe, edited by J. Fernández Fernández and M. Fernández Mier, 7-34. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Lewis, C. and Waites, I. (In prep.) “Tales of the Unexpected: the social impact of community excavations on a Lincolnshire council estate”
Macfarlane, A. 2002. “The non-use of night soil (human excrement) in England.” Unpublished appendix to The Savage Wars of Peace by A. Macfarlane 2003. Basingstoke: Palgrave. Available at http://www.alanmacfarlane.com/savage/A-NIGHT.PDF accessed 19/8/2019)
Mullins, D. and Murie, A. 2006. Housing policy in the UK. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Newman, R. and Collins, C. 2017. Peterborough Cathedral. Unpublished excavation report available at https://www.access.arch.cam.ac.uk/communities/current/1365PeterboroughCathedral.pdf (access 21/8/2019)
Newman, O. 1972. Defensible space: crime prevention through urban design. New York: Macmillan.
Parker, T. 1983. The People of Providence: A Housing Estate and Some of Its Inhabitants. London: Hutchinson.
Parker, N. and Lewis, C., 2016. Archaeological test pit excavations at Middlefield Lane, Gainsborough, Lincolnshire in 2016. Archive report by Archaeological Project Services and University of Lincoln.
Perry, G. 2016. “Pottery production in Anglo-Scandinavian Torksey (Lincolnshire): reconstructing and contextualising the chaîne opératoire.” Medieval Archaeology 60, 72-114.
Prezza, M., Pilloni, S., Morabito,C., Sersante,C., Alparone,F.R. and Giuliani, M. V. 2001. “The influence of psychosocial and environmental factors on children's independent mobility and relationship to peer frequentation”. Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology 11 (6), 435-50.
Ravetz, A. 2001. Council Housing and Culture: The History of a Social Experiment. London: Routledge.
Ravetz. A., and Turkington R. 1995. The Place of Home: English Domestic Environments 1914–2000. London, Taylor and Francis.
Richards, J. M. 1953. ‘Failure of the New Towns’, Architectural Review (July), 32.
Romanowicz, P. 2013. Archaeological finds of playthings in late medieval towns. In P Romanowicz (ed) Child and childhood in the light of archaeology. Wroclaw: Chromicon Wydawnictwo, 163-184.
Rowlandson, I. 2003. Heapham Road, Gainsborough, Lincs: Archaeological Watching Brief. Unpublished report by Lindsey Archaeological Services available at https://archaeologydataservice.ac.uk/library/browse/issue.xhtml?recordId=1022566&recordType=GreyLit (accessed 19/8/2019)
Santos, S. C., Bertolino, N., Hicks, S., Lewis, C. and May, V. 2018. Home and Community: Lessons from a Modernist Housing Scheme. London: Routledge.
Somerville, P and N Sprigings. 2005. Housing and social policy contemporary themes and critical perspectives. London: Routledge.
Tann, G. 2010 Proposed SEN School, The William Harrison School, Middlefield Lane, Gainsborough, Lincolnshire, Archaeological Monitoring and Recording Report 09/582. Unpublished archive report available at https://archaeologydataservice.ac.uk/library/browse/issue.xhtml?recordId=1148124&recordType=GreyLitSeries (accessed 19/8/2019).
Towers, G. and Turkington, R. 2000. Shelter is Not Enough: Transforming Multi-storey Housing. London: Policy Press.
Tucker, F. and Matthews, H. 2001. “They don’t like girls hanging around there: conflicts over recreational space in rural Northamptonshire.” Area 33 (2),161-168.
Waites, I, 2015. “Middlefield: The Development of a Provincial Post-World War Two Council Estate in Lincolnshire 1960-1965.” Midland History 40 (2), 264-285.
Waites, I, 2018. ‘One Big Playground for Kids’: A Contextual Appraisal of some 1970s Photographs of Children Hanging Out on a Post-Second-World-War British Council Estate, Childhood in the Past, 11:2, 114-128.
White, W. 1856. History, Gazetteer and Directory of Lincolnshire. Sheffield: R. Leader.
Wyatt, D. 2016. “Community impact.” in Excavations at Caerau Hillfort, Cardiff, South Wales 2015: An Interim Report edited by N. Sharples and O. Davis. Cardiff: Department of Archaeology and Conservation
Womersley, J. L. 1954. “Some Housing Experiments on Radburn Principles.” The Town Planning Review 25 (3, Oct), 182-194.
Young, M. and Willmott, P. 1957. Family and Kinship in East London. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
