Gender-sensitive language use in Serbia
Between linguistic nationalism and box-checking performance
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/genl.21190Keywords:
language change, language mainstreaming, social femininatives, gender sesitive language, Serbia, postsocialism, EU accessionAbstract
Charting dominant views on gender-sensitive language in the Serbian public sphere, this article points to the ways sociopolitical transformations are grasped and dealt with in postsocialist Serbia. It looks at a case where the legislative action by the state, namely the adoption of the Gender Equality Bill in 2021, disrupted the usual pattern of mutual support between national linguistic experts and the nationalist politics of the state. The debate on the use of social femininatives in Serbian reveals the political force of language ideologies of authenticity, authority, legitimacy and naturalness that mobilise various expert, politicaland social actors whose views often converge in an unexpected manner. It shows that the issue of gender equality in Serbia and in postsocialist Europe in general cannot always be seen as resulting exclusively from the mutually conditioned processes of social movement and countermovement, or of gender mainstreaming and anti-gender backlash; neither can its understanding be reduced to binaries of progressiveness/openness/liberalism/Europeanness vs. conservatism/ nationalism/authoritarianism/anti-Europeanness. Rather, gender equality in these contexts must be seen as part of broader sociopolitical processes at both national and transnational levels.
Mapirajuci preovladujuce poglede na rodno osetljiv jezik koji cirkulisu u javnoj sferi, clanak osvetljava nacine razumevanja i prihvatanja sociopolitickih promena u postsocijalistickoj Srbiji. Kroz uvid u debate oko Zakona o rodnoj ravnopravnosti donetog 2021. godine, clanak analizira slucaj kada je drzavnim zakonodajnim aktom prekinut uobicajeni obrazac medusobne podrske izmedu lingvistickih strucnjaka sa nacionalih akademskih institucija s jedne, i nacionalisticke drzavne politike s druge strane. Debata o upotrebi socijalnih femininativa u spskom jeziku ukazuje na politicku snagu jezickih ideologija autenticnosti, autoriteta, legitimnosti i prirodnosti i njihov kapacitet da mobilisu razilicite strucne, politicke i drustvene aktere ciji se pogledi na pitanja rodno osetljivog jezika cesto priblizavaju na neocekivan nacin. Pokazuje da pitanja rodne ravnopravnosti u Srbiji i sire u postsocijalistickoj Evropi nije uvek moguce razumeti kao rezultat dinamike izmedu drustvenih pokreta i kontra-pokreta ili urodnjavanja javnih politika i mobilizacije nazadnih i konzervativnih snaga, niti ih je moguce redukovati na binarne kategorije progresivnosti/otvorenosti/liberalizma/evropejstva i konzervativnosti/nacionalizma/autoritarnosti/anti-evropejstva, vec ih je neophodno posmatrati kao deo sirih, nacionalnih i transnacionalnih procesa.
References
Abbou, Julie (2011) Double gender marking in French: a linguistic practice of antisexism. Current Issues in Language Planning 12(1): 55-75. https://doi.org/10.1080/14664208.2010.541387
Anicic, Gradimir and Pejovic, Darko (15 June 2021) Lingvistika izmedu zakonske i rodne ravnopravnosti [Linguistics between legislative and gender equality]. Politika. Retrieved from https://www.politika.rs/sr/clanak/481281/Lingvistika-izmedu-zakonske-i-rodne-ravnopravnosti
Arsenijevic, Boban (2018) The language of Dorian Gray: why the social and cultural treatment of genders cannot be improved by acting on their reflections in language. Belgrade English Language and Literature Studies 10: 283-298. https://doi.org/10.18485/bells.2018.10.13
Begagic, Lamija (15 June 2021) Rodovski rat [Gender war]. Nomad. Retrieved from https://nomad.ba/begagic-rodovski-rat?fbclid=IwAR2Nnn37ptZKTeM55B-47dyJBUED2UYSEFyyqWDFHcp8PeHFsP7T61ERwXQU
Berisavljevic, Svetlana (1986) Jezik i pol: titule i zanimanja zene u banci [Language and gender: titles and professions of female bank employees]. Prilozi proucavanju jezika 22: 119-134.
Borba, Rodrigo (2019) Gendered politics of enmity: language ideologies and social polarisation in Brazil. Gender and Language 13(4): 423-448. https://doi.org/10.1558/genl.38416
Borocz, Jozsef (2006) Goodness is elsewhere: the rule of European difference. Comparative Studies in Society and History 48(1): 110-138. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0010417506000053
Bugarski, Ranko (2004) What's in a name: the case of Serbo-Croatian. Revue des etudes slaves 75(1): 11-20. https://doi.org/10.3406/slave.2004.6858
Bugarski, Ranko (7 June 2021) Nisu problem borkinje nego borci i borkinje [Not fightersf but fightersm are the problem]. Danas. Retrieved from https://www.danas.rs/dijalog/licni-stavovi/nisu-problem-borkinje-nego-borci-i-borkinje/
Cameron, Deborah (1997) Demythologizing sociolinguistics. In Nikolas Coupland and Adam Jaworski (eds) Sociolinguistics: A Reader 55-67. London: Palgrave. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-349-25582-5_8
Cavanaugh, Jillian R. (2020) Language ideology revisited. International Journal of the Sociology of Language 2020 (263): 51-57. https://doi.org/10.1515/ijsl-2020-2082
Committee for the Standardization of the Serbian Language (27 Dec 2018) O rodnoj ravnopravnosti [On gender equality]. Retrieved from https://www.ossj.rs/odluke-i-saopstenja/o-rodnoj-ravnopravnosti/
Committee for the Standardization of the Serbian Language (12 May 2021) Zakon o rodnoj ravnopravnosti je zakon protiv srpskog jezika [Gender equality bill is a bill against the Serbian language]. Retrieved from https://www.ossj.rs/odluke-i-saopstenja/zakon-o-rodnoj-ravnopravnosti-je-zakon-protiv-srpskog-jezika/
Coric, Bozo (1982) Mocioni sufiksi u srpskohrvatskom jeziku [Gender suffixes in Serbo-Croatian]. Belgrade: Filoloski fakultet Beogradskog univerziteta.
Corredor, Elizabeth S. (2019) Unpacking 'gender ideology' and the global right's antigender countermovement. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 44(3): 613-638. https://doi.org/10.1086/701171
Cvetincanin Knezevic, Hristina and Lalatovic, Jelena (2019) Prirucnik za upotrebu rodno osetljivog jezika [Handbook for language-sensitive use]. Belgrade: Centar za zenske studije.
Devic, Ana (2021) Paradoxes of gender politics: nationalism, patriarchy and the hijacked feminism of the New Right in Serbia. Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 27(2): 226-245. https://doi.org/10.1080/13537113.2021.1915015
Dragojlo, Sasa (9 May 2016) Serbian workers struggling with 'widespread' poor conditions. Balkan Insight. Retrieved from https://balkaninsight.com/2016/05/09/workers-rights-violations-wide-spread-in-serbia-05-04-2016/
Fangen, Katrine and Lichtenberg, Lisanne (2021) Gender and family rhetoric on the German far right. Patterns of Prejudice 55(1): 71-93. https://doi.org/10.1080/0031322X.2021.1898815
Fejsa, Mihajlo (2018) Gu rodovo chustvovatel'nomu jazyku [Towards gendersensitive language]. Studia Ruthenica 23: 41-48.
Filipovic, Jelena (2009) Rodno osjetljive jezicke politike: teorijske postavke i metodoloski postupci [Gender-sensitive language policies: theoretical foundations and methodological protocols]. Anali filoloskog fakulteta 21: 109-127.
Filipovic, Jelena (2011) Gender and power in the language standardization of Serbian. Gender and Language 5(1): 111-131. https://doi.org/10.1558/genl.v5i1.111
Filipovic, Jelena and Kuzmanovic Jovanovic, Ana (2012) Vodic za rodno osetljiv pristup medijima u Srbiji: Preporuke i dosadasnja praksa [A guide to the gender-sensitive approach to the media in Serbia: recommendations and existing practices]. Belgrade: Kosmos.
Fufaeva, Irina Vladimirovna (2020) Kak nazyvayutsya zhenshchiny. Feminitivy: istoriya, ustroistvo, konkurenciya [How women are named. Feminitives: history, structure, competing variants]. Moscow: Corpus.
Gal, Susan and Woolard, Kathryn A. (1995) Constructing languages and publics: authority and representation. Pragmatics 5(2): 129-138. https://doi.org/10.1075/prag.5.2.01gal
Graff, Agnieszka and Korolczuk, Elzbieta (2021) Anti-Gender Politics in the Populist Movement. London: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003133520
Greenberg, Robert (2000) Language politics in the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia: the crisis over the future of Serbian. Slavic Review 59(3): 625-640. https://doi.org/10.2307/2697348
Grzebalska, Weronika and Petto, Andrea (2018) The gendered modus operandi of the illiberal transformation in Hungary and Poland. Women's Studies International Forum 68: 164-172. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wsif.2017.12.001
Hansen, Malte Breiding (2021) Between two ills: homonationalism, gender ideology and the case of Denmark. Redescriptions: Political Thought, Conceptual History and Feminist Theory 24(1): 60-75. https://doi.org/10.33134/rds.339
Hickey, Raymond (2003) Language change. In Jeff Verschueren, Jan-Ola Ostman and Jan Blommaert (eds) Handbook of Pragmatics, 2001 Instalment 1-35. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. https://doi.org/10.1075/hop.7.lan3
Ivekovic, Rada (1980) Ljubav za Sofiju: Sofijin jezik [Love for Sofia: Sofia's language]. Filozofska istrazivanja 1: 31-42.
Kalogjera, Damir (1979) Jezik in spol [Language and gender]. Godisnjak saveza drustava za primenjenu lingvistiku Jugoslavije 3: 109-114.
Kalogjera, Damir (1981) O jeziku i spolu [On language and gender]. Delo 27(4): 37-52.
Kielkiewicz-Janoviak, Agnieszka (2019) Gender specification of Polish nouns naming people: language system and public debate arguments. Slovenscina 2.0 7(2): 141-171. https://doi.org/10.4312/slo2.0.2019.2.141-171
Kiossev, Alexander (2010) The self-colonizing metaphor. Atlas of Transformation. Retrieved from http://monumenttotransformation.org/atlasof-transformation/html/s/self-colonization/the-self-colonizing-metaphoralexander-kiossev.html
Kolek, Vit and Valdrova, Jana (2020) Czech gender linguistics: topics, attitudes, perspectives. Slovenscina 2.0 8(1): 35-65. https://doi.org/10.4312/slo2.0.2020.1.35-65
Kolorczuk, Elzbieta and Graff, Agnieszka (2018) Gender as 'ebola from Brussels': the anticolonial frame and the rise of illiberal populism. Signs 43(4): 787-821. https://doi.org/10.1086/696691
Kovats, Eszter (2020) Post-socialist conditions and the Orban government's gender politics between 2010 and 2019 in Hungary. In Gabriele Dietze and Julia Roth (eds) Right-wing Populism and Gender: European Perspectives and Beyond 75-99. Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783839449806-005
Kovats, Eszter (2021) Anti-gender politics in East-Central Europe: right-wing defiance to West-Eurocentrism. Gender 1: 76-90. https://doi.org/10.3224/gender.v13i1.06
Krastev, Ivan (2010) Twenty years of postcommunism: deepening dissatisfaction. Journal of Democracy 21(1): 113-119. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.0.0149
Kroskrity, Paul V. (ed) (2000) Regimes of Language: Ideologies, Politics, and Identities. Santa Fe: University of New Mexico Press.
Lalatovic, Jelena (17 June 2021) Jezicka norma i sloboda govora [Language standard and freedom of speech]. Vreme 1589. Retrieved from https://www.vreme.com/vreme/jezicka-norma-i-sloboda-govora/
Markezic, Tjasa and Stramljic Breznik, Irena (2020) Poklicni feminativi v slovarskih virih in v razpisih za delovna mesta [Professional feminatives in dictionaries and job vacancy adverts]. Slavia Centralis 2: 100-119.
Matica Srpska (2021) Saopstenje Matice Srpske povodom pitanja o rodnoj ravnopravnosti [Statement by Matica Srpska regarding the gender equality issue]. Retrieved from https://www.maticasrpska.org.rs/saopshtee-matitse-srpske-povodom-pitaa-o-rodno-ravnopravnosti/
Matkovic, Aleksandar (31 July 2017) Labour strikes in Serbia: the pit of foreign investment. Masina. Retrieved from https://www.masina.rs/eng/labour-strikes-serbia-pit-foreign-investment/
Melegh, Attila (2006) On the East-West Slope. Globalization, Nationalism, Racism and Discourses on Central and Eastern Europe. Budapest: CEU Press.
Mihajlovic Trbovc, Jovana (2023) Alternative infrastructure for gender equality in academic institutions in Slovenia: community of practice approach. In Rachel Palmen and Jorg Muller (eds) A Community of Practice Approach to Improving Gender Equality in Research 101-117. Oxon: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003225546-6
Miloradovic, Sofija (2017) Jezik rodne ravnopravnosti: Rodno diferencirani jezik i gramaticka kategorija roda u srpskom jeziku [Language of gender equality: Gender differentiated language and the grammatical category of gender in Serbian]. Nas jezik XLVIII (1-2): 119-122.
Motschenbacher, Heiko (2016) A discursive approach to structural gender linguistics: theoretical and methodological considerations. Gender and Language 10(2): 149-169. https://doi.org/10.1558/genl.v10i2.25525
Nagornyak, Maya (2020) Feminatives in the news of the first Channel of Public Radio. Scientific Notes of Institute of Journalism T. 1(76): 121-129. https://doi.org/10.17721/2522-1272.2020.76.10
Pauwels, Anne (2003) Linguistic sexism and feminist linguistic activism. In Janet Holmes and Miriam Meyerhoff (eds) The Handbook of Language and Gender 550-570. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470756942.ch24
Pejovic, Darko (7 June 2021) Zakon o rodnoj ravnopravnosti ugrozava ustavne slobode [Gender equality bill threatens constitutional freedoms]. An intervew with Jasmina Grkovic-Mejdzor, Politika. Retrieved from https://www.politika.rs/sr/clanak/480775/Zakon-o-rodnoj-ravnopravnosti-ugrozava-ustavne-slobode
Petrovic, Jelena and Slapsak, Svetlana (2004) Sex/gender distinction, uses and abuses in South Slavic languages in the multilingual Balkan region: Serbian/Croatian/Bosnian in their comparative setting. In Rosi Braidotti, Esther Just, and Marlise Mensink (eds) The Making of European Women's Studies: A Work in Progress Report on Curriculum Development and Related Issues in Gender Education and Research 80-85. Utrecht: Athena.
Petrovic, Tanja (2009) A Long Way Home: Representations of the Western Balkans in Political and Media Discourses. Ljubljana: Peace Institute.
Piper, Predrag (2016) O socijalnim femininativima u srpskom i drugim slovenskim jezicima [On social femininatives in Serbian and other Slavic languages]. Juznoslovenski filolog 72(3-4): 35-65. https://doi.org/10.2298/JFI1604035P
Popic, Damjan and Gorjanc, Vojko (2018) Challenges of adopting gender-inclusive language in Slovene. Suvremena lingvistika 44(86): 329-350. https://doi.org/10.22210/suvlin.2018.086.07
Predlog (n.d.) Rodno osetljiva upotreba jezika: Predlog osnovnih uputstava [Gender-sensitive language use: a proposition for basic instructions]. OEBS misija u Srbiji.
Radic, Jovanka (2013) Dosledna 'feminizacija': Ispoljavanje svesti o ravnopravnosti polova ili put u mentalnu degradaciju [Consistent 'feminisation': an expression of awareness of gender equality or a road to mental degradation]. Philologist: Journal of Language, Literary and Cultural Studies 8(4): 25-36. https://doi.org/10.7251/FIL1308026R
Rajic, Ljubisa (1982) Jezik i pol [Language and gender]. Kultura 57/58: 79-95.
Rajilic, Simone (2014) Silovanje jezika! Vergewaltigung von Sprache! Debatten uber Gender und Sprache in den serbischen Presse 2001-2012 [Rape of the language! Debates about gender and language in the Serbian press 2001-2012]. In Christian Voss and Wolfgang Dahmen (eds) Babel Balkan? Politische und soziokulturelle Kontexte von Sprache in Sudosteuropa [Balkan Babel? Political and Sociocultural Contexts of Language in Southeastern Europe] 271-293. Munich: Kubon & Sagner.
Rajilic, Simone (2017) Is Serbian becoming Croatian? Nationalist counter-reactions to feminist linguistics in Serbia. Gender and Language 11(2): 204-226. https://doi.org/10.1558/genl.25641
Rajkovic, Ivan (24 Mar 2020) Rivers to the People: ecopopulist universality in the Balkan mountains. Fieldsights. Retrieved from https://culanth.org/fieldsights/rivers-to-the-people-ecopopulist-universality-in-the-balkan-mountains
Rakic, Branko (2021) Divlja gradnja u sferi jezika [Illegal construction in the language sphere]. Socioloski pregled 55(3): 771-805. https://doi.org/10.5937/socpreg55-34110
Randeria, Shalini and Romhild, Regina (2013) Das postkoloniale Europa: Verflochtene Genealogies der Gegenwart - Einleitung zur erweiterten Neuauflage [The postcolonial Europe: intertwined genealogies of the present - an introduction to the expanded new edition]. In Sebastian Conrad, Shalini Randeria and Regina Romhild (eds) Jenseits des Eurozentrismus: Postkoloniale Perspektiven in den Geschichts- und Kulturwissenschaften [Beyond Eurocentrism: Postcolonial Perspectives in History and Cultural Studies] 9-31. Frankfurt am Main: Campus.
Rawluszko, Marta (2021) And if the opponents of gender ideology are right? Gender politics, Europeanization, and the democratic deficit. Politics & Gender 17(2): 301-323. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1743923X19000576
Savic, Svenka (1983) Pragmaticki aspekti roda Nomina Agentis u srpskohrvatskom/hrvatskosrpskom jeziku [Pragmatic aspects of gender in Nomina Agentis in Serbo-Croatian]. Naucni sastanak slavista u Vukove dane 13: 247-58.
Savic, Svenka (1989) Language and sex: evidence from Serbo-Croatian. European Journal for Semiotic Studies 1-3: 535-556.
Savic, Svenka (2004) Zena sakrivena jezikom medija: kodeks neseksisticke upotrebe jezika [Women hidden by the media language: recommendations for non-sexist language use]. Novi Sad: Futura publikacije.
Savic, Svenka (2009) Uputstva za standardizaciju rodno osetljivog jezika [Recommendations for the standardization of gender-sensitive language]. Njegosevi dani 2: 301-319.
Savic, Svenka, Canak, Marijana, Mitro, Veronika and Stasni, Gordana (eds) (2009) Rod i jezik [Gender and language]. Novi Sad: Zenske studije i istrazivanje, Futura publikacije.
Schiefffelin, Bambi, Woolard, Kathryn and Kroskrity, Paul (eds) (1998) Language Ideologies: Practice and Theory. New York: Oxford University Press.
Stevanovic, Marijana (2 Jan 2021) Kako su se jos od starog veka razvijale imenice za zanimanja i titule zena? [How have nouns designating female professions and titles been developing since the high Middle Ages?]. Danas. Retrieved from https://www.danas.rs/vesti/drustvo/kako-su-se-jos-od-starog-veka-razvijale-imenice-za-zanimanja-i-titule-zena/
Stijovic, Rada (2021) Komplikovanje govora [Complicating speech]. Slovenski vesnik. Retrieved from http://sloven.org.rs/srb/?p=21497&fbclid=IwAR0nrVmGhzRuWKgCWRafFkMl5d9U2eeE9TFnVnAkQjasgZoJ6__JIiuk0I
Stojanovic, Smiljka (2006) Mocija roda u funkciji emancipacije [Gender suffixes in the function of emancipation]. Srpski jezik 11(1-2): 285-307.
Stubbs, Paul and Lendvai-Bainton, Noemi (2020) Authoritarian neoliberalism, radical conservatism and social policy within the European Union: Croatia, Hungary and Poland. Development and Change 51(2): 540-560. https://doi.org/10.1111/dech.12565
Tanasic, Sreto (3 July 2021) Polozaj srpskoga jezika u savremenom drustvu [Position of the Serbian language in contemporary society]. A contribution to the roundtable organized by Matica Srpska, Novi Sad. Retrieved from https://www.ossj.rs/aktuelnosti/odrzan-skup-polozaj-srpskoga-jezika-u-savremenomdrustvu-izazovi-problemi-resenja/
Tomic, Svetlana (2021) Some methodological problems in contemporary research of social femininatives in the Serbian language. Poznanskie Studia Slawistyczne 20: 323-346. https://doi.org/10.14746/pss.2021.20.17
Valkovicova, Veronika and Mad'arova, Zuzana (2019) From weirdoes to political actors - the journey of Slovak gender ideology rhetoric. Henrich Boll Stiftung. Retrieved from https://www.gwi-boell.de/index.php/en/2019/05/03/weirdoes-political-actors-journey-slovak-gender-ideology-rhetoric
Vince, Zlatko (1955) Drugarica direktor, gospoda profesor ili drugarica direktorica, gospoda profesorica [Comradef director, madam professor, or comradef directorf, madam professorf]? Jezik 2(4): 113-118.
Vulicevic, M. (29 July 2021) Zakonom o rodnoj ravnopravnosti uvodi se nejezik [Gender equality bill introduces a non-language]. Politika. Retrieved from https://www.politika.rs/sr/clanak/484466/Zakonom-o-rodnoj-ravnopravnosti-uvodi-se-nejezik
Wardhaugh, Ronald (2006) An Introduction to Sociolinguistics, 5th edition. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
Woolard, Kathryn A. and Schieffelin, Bambi B. (1994) Language ideology. Annual Review of Anthropology 23: 55-82. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.an.23.100194.000415
Zakon (24 May 2021) Zakon o rodnoj ravnopravnosti [Gender equality bill]. Sluzbeni glasnik Republike Srbije 52.