A Culinary Imponderable
Pigs, Prejudice and Scots
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/ppc.29449Keywords:
Act of Union (1707), Cult of Attis, Christian Isobel Johnstone, pork, Scotland, Sir Walter Scott, superstition, Sir John Sinclair , Dr Samuel Johnson, Statistical Account of ScotlandAbstract
Alone among the peoples of northern Europe, Scots historically have harboured an aversion to pork. The cause, extent and even existence of the aversion, at times ascending to phobia, have been subject to a certain amount of debate for over a century. The degree and scope of the aversion varied across time and space but existed well into the twentieth century. Neither economic nor ecological considerations can explain the phenomenon, which arises from cultural conditions peculiar to Scotland.
References
Anon., Encyclopedia Perthensis, vol. 22 (Edinburgh; John Brown, 1816)
Anon., ‘Sir John Sinclair, 1754-1835,’ The History of Economic Thought <https://www.hetwebsite.net/het/profiles/sinclair.htm> [accessed 29 February 2024]
James Boswell and Samuel Johnson, To the Hebrides: Samuel Johnson’s Journey to the Western Islands of Scotland and James Boswell’s Journal of a Tour of the Hebrides, edited by Ronald Black (Edinburgh: Birlinn, 2007)
Edward Burt, Letters from a Gentleman in the North of Scotland to a Friend in London (London: R. Fenner, 1818)
John Campbell, Superstitions of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland (Glasgow: James MacLehose and Sons, 1900)
R.W. Campbell, ‘The Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707. II.,’ The Economic History Review, New Series, vol. 16, No. 3 (1964) 468-77
L.A. Clarkson & E. Margaret Crawford, Feast and Famine: A History of Food and Nutrition in Ireland 1500-1920 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001)
Elizabeth Cleland, A New and Easy Method of Cookery (Edinburgh: S. Williston and J. Bruce, 1755)
Mrs Dalgairns, The Practice of Cookery: adapted to the business of everyday life (Edinburgh: Robert Cadell, 1830)
George Dalrymple, The Practice of Modern Cookery (Edinburgh: C. Elliot, 1830)
James Dalrymple (tr.), The Historie of Scotland, Written First in Latin by the Most Ruerend Jhone Leslie, vol. 1 (Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons, 1883)
John Graham Dalyell, The Darker Superstitions of Scotland (Edinburgh: Waugh and Innes, 1834)
David Denby, ‘Northern Lights,’ The New Yorker (3 October 2004) <https://www.newyorker/magazine/2004/10/11/northern-lights-3> [accessed 15 March 2024]
J.N. Duggan, John Toland: Ireland’s Forgotten Philosopher, Scholar… and Heretic (Dublin: TAF Publishing 2010) <https://www.amazon.com/John-Toland-Irelands-Forgotten-Philosopher-ebook/dp/B006Q3IM7S?asin=B006Q3IM7S&revisionId=e1e77f11&format=2&depth=1> [accessed 21 February 2024]
Mrs Frazer, The Practice of Cookery (Edinburgh: Peter Hill, 1793)
A.J.S. Gibson & T.C. Smout, Prices, Food and Wages in Scotland 1550-1780 (Cambridge; Cambridge University Press, 1995)
W. Gifford (ed.), The Works of Ben Jonson, vol. 7 (London: Longmans, 1816)
Walter Gregor, Notes on the Folk-lore of the North-east of Scotland (London: Elliot Stock, 1881)
J.E. Handley, Scottish Farming in the Eighteenth Century (London: Faber and Faber, 1953)
Robert Henderson, A Treatise on the Breeding of Swine, and Curing of Bacon; with Hints on Agricultural Subjects (Leith: Archibald Allardice, 1811)
Elizabeth Caldwell Hirschman & Donald Yates, When Scotland Was Jewish (Jefferson NC: McFarland, 2007)
Annette Hope, A Caledonian Feast (London: Grafton, 1989)
Christian Isobel Johnstone [under the pseudonym ‘Mrs Margaret Dods’], The Cook and Housewife’s Manual (Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd, 1826)
Fergus Kelly, Early Irish Farming (Dublin: Dublin Institute of Advanced Study, 2000)
Roger Knight, Martin Wilcox & James Davey, ‘Sustaining the Empire: War, the Navy and the Contractor State, 1793-1815,’ University of Greenwich <https://www.gre.ac.uk/gmc/research/projects/sustaining-the-empire> [accessed 26 February 2024]
Biddy White Lennon, The Poolbeg Book of Traditional Irish Cooking (Baldoyle: Poolbeg Press, 1990)
John Leslie, A History of Scotland, tr. James Dalrymple (1596) (Edinburgh: William Blackwood and Sons, 1895)
J. M. M’Bain, Arbroath: Past and Present (Arbroath: Brodie & Salmond, 1887)
Victor MacClure, Scotland’s Inner Man (London: George Routledge and Sons, 1935)
Victor MacClure, Good Appetite My Companion (London: Odhams Press, 1955)
Donald Mackenzie, Wonder Tales from Scottish Myth and Legend (London: Blackie and Son, 1917)
Donald Mackenzie, Scottish Folk-Lore and Folk Life: Studies in Race, Culture and Tradition (orig. publ. London; Blackie and Son, 1935; also <https://www.ornaverum.org/reference/pdf/260.pdf>
William Mackay Mackenzie, Letter to the editor, The Scotsman (8 October 1921)
John MacKenzie & T.M. Devine, ‘Introduction’ and ‘Scots in the Imperial Economy’ in John MacKenzie & T.M. Devine (eds.), Scotland and the British Empire (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011)
F. Marian McNeill, The Scots Kitchen: Its Lore and Recipes (orig. publ. Edinburgh; Blackie and Son, 1929; Frogmore, St. Albans: Mayflower, 1974)
F. Marian McNeill, The Book of Breakfasts (Edinburgh: Reprographia, 1975)
Sir Arthur Mitchell (ed.), Collections Related to Scotland Made by William MacFarlane, 3 vols. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh Press, 1906-08 (orig. recorded 1748-49)
Rosalind Mitchison, Agricultural Sir John: The Life of Sir John Sinclair of Ulbster 1754-1835 (London: Geoffrey Bles, 1962)
Jordi Morillas, ‘Toland’s Reasons for Naturalizing the Jews,’ John Toland (1670-1722) <https://www.johntoland.com/2018/05/tolands-reasons-for-naturalizing-jews.html> (6 May 2018) [accessed 21 February 2024]
Una Mullally, ‘Flaming poteen herring! Ireland’s long-standing fish aversion,’ Irish Times (19 January 2019)
Stana Nenadic, Lairds and Luxury: The Highland Gentry in Eighteenth-Century Scotland (Edinburgh: John Donald, 2007)
Mark Netzloff, ‘“Counterfeit Egyptians” and Imagined Borders: Jonson’s The Gypsies Metamorphosed,’ English Literary History’, vol. 68 no. 4 (Winter 2001) 763-93
Blake Perkins, ‘Christian Isobel Johnstone and The Cook and Housewife’s Manual by “Meg Dods”,’ Petits Propos Culinaires 105 (April 2016) 16-41
Blake Perkins, ‘Is There an Irish Cuisine?’, British Food in America, no. 72 (Fall/Winter 2023) <https://www.britishfoodinamerica.com/Our-First-Irish-Number/the-critical/Is-There-an-Irish-Cuisine/> [accessed 29 February 2024]
Nicholas Phillipson and Rosalind Mitchison (eds.), Scotland in the Age of Improvement (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1970)
Edward Ramsay, Reminiscences of Scottish Life and Character (Edinburgh: Foulis 1874) <https://www.gutenberg.org/files/12483/12483-h/12483-h.htm> [accessed 7 December 2014]
C.E. Randall, ‘Livestock and landscape: exploring animal exploitation in later prehistory in the South West of England,’ (Bournemouth: Bournemouth University doctoral thesis, 2010) <https://eprints.bournemouth.ac.uk/15958/>
J. Robertson, General view of the Agriculture of the County of Perth (Perth: James Morison, 1799)
Eric Ross, ‘The Riddle of the Scottish Pig,’ BioScience, Vol. 33, No. 2 (February 1983) 99-106
Marina Santos, ‘Lobster Lore,’ MIT Sea Grant College Program (11 May 2021) <https://seagrant.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Lobster_Lore_Print.pdf> [accessed 18 February 2024]
Sir Walter Scott, The Two Drovers, in Chronicles of the Canongate (Paris: Baudry’s Foreign Library, 1832)
Sir Walter Scott, The Waverley Novels, Vol. 1 (Philadelphia: J. Carey and A. Hart, 1839)
Sir Walter Scott, The Fortunes of Nigel (London: George Routledge & Sons, 1875)
Sir John Sinclair (ed.), The Statistical Account of Scotland (21 vol.s) (Edinburgh: William Creech, 1793)
Catherine Smith, ‘a grumphie in the sty: an archeological view of pigs in Scotland, from their earliest domestication to the agricultural revolution,’ Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, Vol. 130 (2002) 705-24
T.C. Smout, ‘The Anglo-Scottish Union of 1707. I. The Economic Background,’ The Economic History Review, New Series Vol. 16, No. 3 (1964) 455-67
T.C. Smout (ed.), Scotland and the Sea (Edinburgh: John Donald Publishers, 1992)
Michael Steer, ‘The Blockade of Brest and the Victualling of the Western Squadron, 1793-1805,’ The Mariner’s Mirror, Vol. 76, Issue 4 (1990) 307-16
Maisie Steven, The Good Scots Diet (Glendaruel: Argyll, 2003)
J. Stone [?], A Collection of Loyal Songs Written Against the Rump Parliament Between the Years 1659 and 1661 (London: G. Strahan, 1731)
John Toland, Reasons for Naturalizing the Jews in Great Britain and Ireland… Containing also a Defence of the Jews against All vulgar Prejudices in all Countries (London: J. Roberts, 1714)
Jon Townsend, ‘18th century Sailor’s food [sic]– Ships Provisions,’ Savoring the Past (22 March 2013) <https://www.savoringthepast.net/2013/oh3/22/18th-century-sailors-food-ships-provisions/> [accessed 19 November 2021]
David Vassberg, ‘Concerning Pigs, the Pizarros, and the Agro-Pastoral Background of the Conquerors of Peru’, Latin American Research Review, Vol.13, No. 3, 1978 <https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/23BDAA04EE40B6FF82B2E3B377FAF008/S0023879100031289a.pdf/div-class-title-concerning-pigs-the-pizarros-and-the-agro-pastoral-background-of-the-conquerors-of-peru-div.pdf>
Christopher Whatley, ‘Economic Causes and Consequences of the Union of 1707: A Survey,’ The Scottish Historical Review, Vol. 68, No. 186 part 2 (October 1989) 150-81
