Dictionaries of Japanese mimetic words
defining the mimetic category by the selection of lexical items
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1007/s40607-019-00055-9Keywords:
Mimetic words, Japanese language, Selection of lexical items, Sound-symbolismAbstract
In this paper, an analysis of the selection of lexical items in Japanese mimetic dictionaries is presented to discuss the theoretical defnition of Japanese mimetic words in lexicographic practice from the point of view of Japanese mimetic linguistics. By examining the selection of lexical items listed in six Japanese mimetic dictionaries, this study attempts to determine the way in which dictionary-makers identify and represent the Japanese mimetic words as a lexical category. Adopting a mainly descriptive approach, this paper analyzes the lexical selection of four monolingual and two bilingual mimetic dictionaries. Firstly, formal and etymological criteria for selecting dictionary entries are discussed. Secondly, the coverage of each selection is compared. Next, special attention is given to whether selected mimetics are presented as primary or secondary items (namely lemmatical or non-lemmatical items) from a lexicographic perspective and, fnally, the proportions of each type of item are contrasted. As a conclusion, Japanese mimetic dictionaries show similar patterns in terms of lexical selection. In general, lexicographic practice defnes the Japanese mimetic category as lexical units, mostly adverbs, formed by allegedly sound-symbolic elements with a discrete morphophonological structure. In contrast to the published literature, the largest diferences were observed in the treatment of pseudomimetic words, as well as in the distinction between mimetic expressions containing single or multiple words.
References
Akita, K. 2009. A grammar of sound-symbolic words in Japanese: theoretical approaches to iconic and lexical properties of mimetics. Kobe: Graduate School of Humanities and Social Sciences, Kobe University.
Akita, K. 2013. Onomatope/Onsh?ch? no Kenky?-shi [A research history of mimetics and sound symbolism]. In Onomatope Kenky? no Shatei: Chikazuku Oto to Imi [Sound symbolism and mimetics: rethinking the relationship between sound and meaning in language], ed. K. Shinohara and R. Uno, 333–364. Tokyo: Hitsuji Shobo.
Hamano, S. 1998. The sound-symbolic system of Japanese. Tokyo: Kurosio.
Hamano, S. 2014. Nihongo no Onomatope. Onsh?ch? to K?z? [Onomatopoeia in Japanese: Sound Symbolism and Structure]. Tokyo: Kurosio.
Herlofsky, W. 1990. Translating the Myth: Problems with English and Japanese Imitative Words. In Kotoba no Ky?en: Utage. Kakehi Hisao Ky?ju Kanreki Kinen Ronsh? [Linguistic Fiesta: Festschrift for Professor Hisao Kakehi’s Sixtieth Birthday], ed. K. Hisao, 213–228. Kurosio: Tokyo.
Hinton, L., J. Nichols, and J. Ohala. 1994. Sound symbolism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Inoue, K. 2013. Onomatope no Tagisei to S?z?sei [Polysemy and creativity of onomatopoeia]. In Onomatope Kenky? no Shatei: Chikazuku Oto to Imi [Sound symbolism and mimetics: rethinking the relationship between sound and meaning in language], ed. K. Shinohara and R. Uno, 203–216. Tokyo: Hitsuji Shobo.
Itô, J., and R.A. Mester. 1995. Japanese phonology. In The handbook of phonological theory, ed. J.A. Goldsmith, 817–838. Massachusetts: Blackwell Publishers.
Kadooka, K. 2007. Nihongo Onomatope Goi ni okeru Keitaiteki/On’inteki Taikeisei ni tsuite [On the morphological and phonological systematicity of the onomatopoeic vocabulary of Japanese]. Tokyo: Kurosio.
Kakehi, H. 1993. Ippan-goi to natta Onomatope [Mimetics that became part of the general lexicon]. Gengo 22 (6): 38–45.
Kakehi, H. 2001. Henshin-suru Onomatope [The transforming mimetics]. Gengo 30 (9): 28–35.
Kakehi, H., Ikuhiro Tamori, and Lawrence Schourup. 1996a. Dictionary of iconic expressions in Japanese. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Makino, S. 2007. An Argument for Non-Arbitrary Relationship between Sound and Meaning in Japanese Grammar. In Japanese Linguistics: European Chapter, ed. Y. Ikegami, V. Eschbach-Szabo, and A. Wlodarczyk, 239–250. Tokyo: Kurosio.
Malkiel, Y. 1990. Diachronic problems in phonosymbolism. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
Mito, Y., and H. Kakehi. 1984. Nichiei Taish? Giseigo (Onomatope) Jiten [Japanese–English contrastive onomatopoeia dictionary]. Tokyo: Gaku Shobo.
Tamamura, F. 1984. Onsh?ch?go no Gokei (Sono 1) [Forms of sound-symbolic words, part 1]. D?shisha Kokubungaku [Doshisha University Department of Japanese Literature] 24: 74–79.
Tamori, I., and L. Schourup. 1999. Onomatope Keitai to Imi [Onomatopoeia: form and meaning]. Tokyo: Kurosio.
Tamori, I. 2002. Onomatope: Gion/gitaigo o Tanoshimu [Onomatopoeia: enjoying mimetics]. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.
Tsuji, S. 2003. Les Impressifs Japonais: Analyse des Gitaigo et Inventaire des Impressifs Japonais. Lyon: Presses Universitaires de Lyon.
Waida, T. 1984. English and Japanese onomatopoeic structures. Stud English 36: 55–79.
Dictionaries cited
Atoda, M., and K. Hoshino. 1995. Giongo/gitaigo Tsukaikata Jiten: Tadashii Imi to Y?h? ga Sugu Wakaru [Usage guide to Japanese onomatopoeias]. Tokyo: Sotakusha.
Hida, Y., and H. Asada. 2002. Gendai Giongo Gitaigo Y?h? Jiten [Usage dictionary of present-day mimetics]. Tokyo: Tokyodo Shuppan.
Kakehi, H., I. Tamori, and L. Schourup. 1996b. Dictionary of iconic expressions in Japanese. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Ono, H. 1984. A practical guide to Japanese–English onomatopoeia and mimesis. Tokyo: Hokuseido.
Ono, M. 2007. Nihongo Onomatope Jiten: Giongo Gitaigo 4500 [4500 Mimetics: a dictionary of Japanese onomatopoeia]. Tokyo: Shogakukan.
Yamaguchi, N. 2003. Kurashi no Kotoba: Gion/gitaigo Jiten [Language of life: a dictionary of mimetics]. Tokyo: Kodansha.
