Coal versus Coral

Australian Climate Change Politics sees the Great Barrier Reef in Court

Authors

  • Claire Konkes University of Tasmania
  • Cynthia Nixon University of Tasmania
  • Libby Lester University of Tasmania
  • Kathleen Williams University of Tasmania

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1017/qre.2022.10

Keywords:

The Great Barrier Reef, climate change politics, corporate and environmental activism, environmental laws

Abstract

The likelihood that climate change may destroy the Great Barrier Reef has been a central motif in Australia’s climate change politics for more than a decade as political ideologies and corporate and environmental activism draw or refute connections between the coal industry and climate change. The media fuel this debate because in this contest, as ever, the news media always do more than simply report the news. Given that the Reef has also been central to the evolution of Australia’s environmental laws since the 1960s, it is not surprising that the Reef is now a leading actor in efforts to test the capacity of our environmental laws to support action on climate change. In this contribution, we examine the news coverage of the Australian Conservation Foundation’s (ACF) 2015 challenge to Adani’s Carmichael coal mine to observe the discursive struggle between the supporters and opponents of the mine. Our analysis of the case shows that while the courts are arenas of material and symbolic contest in the politics of climate change in Australia, public interest environmental litigants struggle both inside and outside the courts to challenge the privileging of mining interests over the public interest.

Author Biographies

Claire Konkes, University of Tasmania

Dr Claire Konkes is a Senior Lecturer and Head of Discipline at The Media School, University of Tasmania. Her research continues to explore the role of media, especially news media, in the development of policy and law, especially in relation to gendered violence and the environment.

Cynthia Nixon, University of Tasmania

Dr Cynthia Nixon has a bachelor’s degree in Environmental Engineering, a Master’s in Environmental Law and a PhD in Media. Her research has focused on the intersection of strategic communication, litigation, media, and activism. She has worked for over 15 years in the energy and paper industries and is currently a consultant working to improve the sustainability of organisations by improving their environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance. Cynthia’s current focus is supporting the rapidly growing renewable energy sector as the world transitions to a cleaner energy landscape.

Libby Lester, University of Tasmania

Professor Libby Lester is Director of the Institute for Social Change and Professor of Journalism, Media and Communications at the University of Tasmania, Australia. She works to understand the place of public debate in local and global decision-making, and her research on environmental communication and conflict is published widely.

Kathleen Williams, University of Tasmania

Dr Kathleen Williams is the Director of Creative Curriculum and a Senior Lecturer in Media at the University of Tasmania, Australia. She primarily researches the cultural, environmental and industrial impacts of changing media technologies and practices.

References

Australian Associated Press. 2015. ‘Adani mine faces another challenge’, The Weekend Australian, 10 November, https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/business-spectator/adani-mine-faces-another-challenge/news-story/3af7a4986539b3c5b56fc8a91d552226.

Anderson, A. 1997. Media, culture and the environment. London: Routledge.

Australian Conservation Foundation. 2016, ‘ACF versus the Environment Minister – our Adani court case explained’, https://www.acf.org.au/acf_vs_environment_minister.

Bacon, W. and Nash, C. 2012, ‘Playing the media game’, Journalism Studies 13 (2): 243–58.

Barcan, R. 2020. ‘The campaign for legal personhood for the Great Barrier Reef: Finding political and pedagogical value in a spectacular failure of care’, Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space 3(3): 810–32.

Bowen, J. and Bowen, M. 2002. The Great Barrier Reef: History, science, heritage. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.

Bradley, J. 2019. ‘How Australia’s coal madness led to Adani’, The Monthly, April, https://www.themonthly.com.au/issue/2019/april/1554037200/james-bradley/how-australia-s-coal-madness-led-adani?cb=1612648184

Breit, R. 2011. Professional communication: Legal and ethical issues (2nd ed.). London: LexisNexis Butterworths.

Burt, J. 2019. ‘Adani could be “ice-breaker” for six more proposed Galilee Basin mines, resources body says’, ABC News, 12 June, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-06-12/adani-approval-could-be-galilee-basin-ice-breaker/11194510

Carvalho, A. 2008. ‘Media(ted) discourse and society: Rethinking the framework of critical discourse analysis’, Journalism Studies 9: 161–77.

Carvalho, A., Van Wessel, M. and Maeseele, P. 2017. ‘Communication practices and political engagement with climate change: A research agenda’, Environmental Communication 11 (1): 122–35.

Christensen, G. 2016, ‘MP urges Labor to support job creating Bill’, media release, 8 February, https://www.georgechristensen.com.au/bygeorge/mp-urges-labor-to-support-job-creating-bill.

Commonwealth of Australia. 2009. First Independent Review of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999: Interim report. Canberra: Australian Government, https://www.environment.gov.au/system/files/resources/5d70283b-3777-442e-b395-b0a22ba1b273/files/interim-report.pdf.

Cottle, S. 2006, Mediatized conflict: Developments in media and conflict studies. London: McGraw-Hill.

Couldry, N. and Hepp, A. 2013. ‘Conceptualizing mediatization: Contexts, traditions, arguments’. Communication Theory 23: 191–202.

Courier-Mail. 2015. ‘Balancing the rights of developers and climate’,10 November, p. 22.

Cullinan, C. 2008. ‘If nature had rights’, Orion Magazine, https://orionmagazine.org/article/if-nature-had-rights.

Cunningham, M., Van Uffelen, L. and Chambers, M. 2019. ‘The changing global market for Australian coal’, Reserve Bank of Australia Bulletin, September, pp. 28–38, https://www.rba.gov.au/publications/bulletin/2019/sep/the-changing-global-market-for-australian-coal.html.

Currell, M. J., Irvine, D. J., Werner, A. D. and McGrath, C. 2020. ‘Science sidelined in approval of Australia’s largest coal mine’, Nature Sustainability 3(8): 644–9.

Fahy, D. 2017. ‘Objectivity as trained judgment: How environmental reporters pioneered journalism for a “post-truth” era’. Environmental Communication, 12(7): 855–61.

Foxwell-Norton, K. and Konkes, C. 2018. ‘The Great Barrier Reef: News media, policy and the politics of protection’, International Communication Gazette, 81(3): 211–34.

Foxwell-Norton, K. and Lester, L. 2017, ‘Saving the Great Barrier Reef from disaster, media then and now’, Media Culture and Society 39: 568–81.

Frost, P. 2016. ‘Lawyers: Carmichael emissions 3x more than reduction target’, Central Queensland News, 3 May, https://www.cqnews.com.au/news/Lawyers-Carmichael-emissions-3x-more-than-reducti/3015419.

Geoscience Australia 2021. ‘Coal’, https://www.ga.gov.au/digital-publication/aecr2021/coal.

Goodie, J. and Wickham, G. 2002. ‘Calculating “public interest”: Common law and the legal governance of the environment’, Social & Legal Studies 11(1): 37–60.

Grech, A., Pressey, R. L. and Day, J. C. 2016. ‘Coal, cumulative impacts, and the Great Barrier Reef’, Conservation Letters 9(3): 200–7.

Hannam, P. 2016. ‘Australian Conservation Foundation loses Federal Court case on Adani coal’, Sydney Morning Herald, 29 August, https://www.smh.com.au/environment/climate-change/australian-conservation-foundationloses-federal-court-case-on-adani-coal-20160829-gr3au2.html.

Hjarvard, S. 2013. The mediatization of culture and society, London: Routledge.

Hepburn, J., Burton, B. and Hardy, S. 2011. ‘Stopping the Australian coal export boom: Funding proposal for the Australian anti-coal movement’, Media Watch, ABC TV, https://www.abc.net.au/mediawatch/transcripts/1206_greenpeace.pdf.

Hobbs, M. and McKnight, D. 2014. ‘“Kick this mob out”: The Murdoch media and the Australian Labor Government (2007 to 2013)’, Global Media Journal, 8(2): 1–13.

Hulme, M. 2012. ‘How climate models gain and exercise authority’. In Hastrup, K. H. and Skrydstrup, M. (eds), The social life of climate change models. London: Routledge, pp. 40–54.

Hutchins, B. and Lester, L. 2015. ‘Theorizing the enactment of mediatized environmental conflict’, International Communication Gazette 77(4): 337–58.

Johns, G. 2015. ‘Making people’s lives tougher is hardly an act of charity’, The Australian, 9 November, p. 12.

Jolley, C. and Rickards, L. 2020. ‘Contesting coal and climate change using scale: Emergent topologies in the Adani mine controversy’, Geographical Research, 58(1): 6–23.

Karp, P. 2020. ‘Adani coalmine won’t get federal rail funding, Liberal minister says’, The Guardian, 4 February, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/feb/04/adani-coalmine-wont-get-federal-rail-funding-liberal-minister-says.

Kitzinger, J. 2009. ‘Framing and frame analysis’. In Devereux, E. (ed.), Media studies: Key issues and debates. London: Sage, pp. 134–61.

Konkes, C. 2018, ‘Green lawfare: Environmental public interest litigation and mediatized environmental conflict’, Environmental Communication, 12(2): 191–203.

Konkes, C. and Foxwell-Norton, K. 2021. Science communication and mediatised environmental conflict: A cautionary tale. Public Understanding of Science, 30(4): 470–83.

Konkes, C. and Lester, L. 2016. ‘Justice, politics and the social usefulness of news’, Crime, Media, Culture 12(1): 17–35.

Lester, L. 2017. ‘Transnational discourses of risk and responsibility from Australia: Coal, pollution and the Great Barrier Reef’. In Hook, G. D., Lester, L., Ji, M, Edney, K. and Pope, C. G. (eds), Environmental pollution and the media: Political discourses of risk and responsibility in Australia, China and Japan. London: Routledge, pp. 45–74.

Lester, L. 2019. Global trade and mediatised environmental protest: The view from here. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

Lester, L. and Hutchins, B. 2012. ‘The power of the unseen: Environmental conflict, the media and invisibility’, Media, Culture & Society, 34(7): 847–63.

Lowe, I. 2014. ‘Wild law embodies values for a sustainable future’. In Maloney, M. and Burdon, P. (eds), Wild law in practice. London: Routledge, pp. 3–16.

McAllister, L., Daly, M., Chandler, P., McNatt, M., Benham, A. and Boykoff, M. 2021. ‘Balance as bias, resolute on the retreat? Updates & analyses of newspaper coverage in the United States, United Kingdom, New Zealand, Australia and Canada over the past 15 years’, Environmental Research Letters 16(9), doi: 10.1088/1748-9326/ac14eb.

McCarthy, J. 2016. ‘Australian Conservation Foundation ordered to pay costs for Adani case’, Courier-Mail, 9 September, https://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/crime-and-justice/australian-conservation-foundation-ordered-to-pay-costs-for-adani-case/news-story/20a030d675a2edb873a9888fd1e152ea.

McCutcheon, P. 2020, ‘How is Clive Palmer maintaining his political influence at the Queensland election?’, ABC News, 28 October, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-10-28/qld-election-how-clive-palmer-maintaining-political-influence/12814534.

McGrath, C. 2021. ‘Carmichael Coal (‘Adani’) mine cases in the Federal Court’, Environmental Law website, http://envlaw.com.au/carmichael-coal-mine-federal-court.

McKenna, M. and Maher, S. 2015. ‘Risk to reef new front in coal campaign’, The Australian, https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nationalaffairs/climate/risk-to-great-barrier-reef-new-front-in-adani-mine-coal-campaign/newsstory/64ddff50142413e1301dad1b2124d087.

McKinnon, E. 2016. ‘ACF versus the Environment Minister – our Adani court case explained’. Australian Conservation Foundation, https://www.acf.org.au/acf_vs_environment_minister.

McKnight, D. 2005. ‘Murdoch and the culture war’, in Manne, R (ed.), Do not disturb: Is the media failing Australia? Melbourne: Black Inc, pp. 53–74.

McKnight, D. 2012. Rupert Murdoch: An investigation of political power. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.

McKnight, D. and Hobbs, M. 2017. ‘Fighting for coal: Public relations and the campaigns against lower carbon pollution policies in Australia’. In Brevini, B. and Murdock, G. (eds), Carbon capitalism and communication, London: Macmillan, pp. 115–29.

Minerals Council of Australia. 2021. Coal: Building Australia’s future, https://www.minerals.org.au/coal-building-australias-future.

Murphy, B. and McGee, J. 2018. ‘Lawfare, standing and environmental discourse: Phronetic analysis’, University of Tasmania Law Review 37(2): 131–68.

Nixon, C., Konkes, C., Lester, L. and Williams, K. 2021. Mediated visibility and public environmental litigation: The interplay between inside and outside court during environmental conflict in Australia. Laws 10(2): 35.

Preston, B. J. 2016. ‘The contribution of the courts in tackling climate change’, Journal of Environmental Law 28(1): 11–17.

Readfern, G. 2015. ‘Time to examine the fossil fuel industry’s relationship with Queensland’s government’, The Guardian, 9 October, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/planet-oz/2015/oct/09/time-to-examine-the-fossil-fuel-industrys-relationship-with-queenslands-government.

Robertson, J. 2015. ‘Conservation group challenges approval of Carmichael coalmine as “illegal”’, The Guardian, 9 November, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/nov/09/conservation-group-challenges-approval-of-carmichael-coalmine-as-illegal.

Robertson, J. 2016. ‘Adani Carmichael coalmine faces new legal challenge from Conservation Foundation’, The Guardian, 19 September, https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/sep/19/adani-carmichael-coalmine-faces-new-legal-challenge-from-conservation-foundation.

Samuel, G. 2020. ‘Independent review of the EPBC Act’, Commonwealth of Australia, https://apo.org.au/sites/default/files/resource-files/2021-01/apo-nid310681.pdf.

Schliebs, M. 2016, ‘Bid to halt Adani’s Carmichael coal mine fails’, The Australian, 29 August, https://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/mining-energy/bid-to-haltadani-carmichael-coal-mine-fails/news-story/06dfb23b53b83298ed6fb40e78c9d4b8.

Schuijers, L. and Young, M. A. 2021, Climate change litigation in Australia: Law and practice in the sunburnt country. In Alogna, I., Bakker, C. and Gauci, J.-P. (eds), Climate change litigation: Global perspectives. Leiden: Brill, pp. 47–78.

Seccombe, M. 2018. ‘Rinehart’s secret millions to the IPA’, The Saturday Paper. 28 July–3 August, https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/edition/2018/07/28.

Slezak, M. 2016a. ‘Great Barrier Reef: New chapter opens in the fight to save natural wonder from mining’, The Guardian, 10 April, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/apr/10/great-barrier-reef-new-chapteropens-in-the-fight-to-save-natural-wonder-from-mining.

Slezak, M. 2016b. ‘Activists launch fresh court challenge over Carmichael coalmine’, The Guardian, 3 May, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/may/03/activists-launch-fresh-court-challenge-over-carmichael-coalmine.

Slezak, M. 2020. ‘Australia’s Future Fund “in bed with Adani” after freedom of information request reveals $3.2 million investment’, The Guardian, 16 December, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-12-16/future-fund-invests-millions-in-adani-project/12984734.

Smee, B. 2019. ‘Adani mine would be “unviable” without $4.4 bn in subsidies, report finds’, 29 August, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/aug/29/adani-mine-would-be-unviable-without-44bn-in-subsidies-report-finds.

Stevens, M. 2016. ‘Adani prepares for an end to lawfare with a smaller, cheaper Carmichael’, Australian Financial Review, 21 September, https://www.afr.com/news/economy/adani-prepares-for-an-end-to-lawfare-with-a-smaller-cheaper-carmichael-20160921-grla4o.

Stutzer, R., Rinscheid, A., Oliveira, T. D., Loureiro, P. M., Kachi, A. and Duygan, M. 2021. ‘Black coal, thin ice: The discursive legitimisation of Australian coal in the age of climate change’, Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 8(1): 1–9.

Tankard, J. 2003. ‘The empirical approach to the study of framing’, in Stephen, R., Gandy, O. and Grant, A. (eds), Framing public life. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum, pp. 95–106.

van Vonderen, J. 2015. ‘Australian Conservation Foundation challenges Adani’s Carmichael coal mine in Federal Court’, ABC News, 9 November, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-11-09/adani-mine-australian-conservation-foundationcourt-challenge/6923598.

Wangan and Jagalingou Family Council. 2019. ‘Latest news’, https://wanganjagalingou.com.au/category/latest-news.

Wickham, G. and Goodie, J. A. 2013. Legal and political challenges of governing the environment and climate change: Ruling nature. London: Routledge.

Zhou, N. 2020. ‘Crooked not courageous: Adani renames Australian group Bravus, mistaking it for “brave”’, The Guardian, 5 November, https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/nov/05/crooked-not-courageous-adani-renames-australian-group-bravus-mistaking-it-for-brave.

Published

2021-12-01

How to Cite

Konkes, C., Nixon, C., Lester, L., & Williams, K. (2021). Coal versus Coral: Australian Climate Change Politics sees the Great Barrier Reef in Court. Queensland Review, 28(2), 132–146. https://doi.org/10.1017/qre.2022.10

Issue

Section

Articles