The Function of 'the tragic' in Henry Reynolds' Narratives of Contact History
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1017/S1321816600000684Keywords:
Henry Reynolds, narratives of contact history in Australia, 'the tragic', Aboriginal responsesAbstract
This paper discusses the ways in which ideas of ‘the tragic’ function in recent narratives of contact history in Australia. ‘Contact history’ is used here to refer to first and second generation contact between Aboriginal people and the European invaders in Australia in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, and I shall be primarily concerned with those historical narratives which attempt to ‘re-write’ history to include Aboriginal responses during this period. Within Australian historiography this project is said to have commenced in the 1970s, prompted by wider events in the Australian community such as the Aboriginal land rights movement (Curthoys 1983, 99). One of the best-known contributors to this project of inclusion has been Henry Reynolds, now the author of eight books dedicated to it. I shall be examining two of Reynolds' most recent contributions to this area: With the White People (1990) and The Fate of a Free People (1995). At the same time that Reynolds and other professional historians have engaged in this project, there has been an increasing body of work by Aboriginal writers — much of it classified as fiction rather than academic historiography — examining these same themes of initial contact and resistance to invasion. In order to clarify some of my arguments about the function of the tragic mode in Reynolds' work, I shall also discuss a recently published short story by the Aboriginal writer, Gerry Bostock.
References
Beckett, J. ed 1994, Past and Present: The Construction of Aboriginality, Canberra: Aboriginal Studies Press.
Bostock, G. 1994, ‘Colebe’ in Meanjin, 1994 Vol. 53, No. 4, 613–618.
Coltheart, L. 1994, ‘The Moment of Aboriginal History’ in Past and Present: The Construction of Aboriginality, ed Beckett, J., Canberra: Aboriginal Studies Press, 1994.
Curthoys, A. 1983, ‘Rewriting Australian History: Including Aboriginal Resistance’ in Arena, 1983, No. 62, 96–110.
Elder, B. 1988, Blood on the Wattle: Massacres and Maltreatment of Australian Aborigines since 1788, Sydney: Griffin Press.
Gellrich, M. 1988, Tragedy and Theory: The Problem of Conflict since Aristotle, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Heilman, R.B. 1960, ‘Tragedy and Melodrama: Speculations on Generic Form’ in Tragedy: Vision and Form, 1965, ed Corrigan, R.W., Pennsylvania: Chandler Publishing Company.
Moretti, F. 1983, Signs Taken For Wonders, Great Britain: The Thetford Press.
Rae, Ellis V. 1981, Trucannini: Queen or Traitor?, Canberra: Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies.
Reynolds, H. 1995, Fate of a Free People, Melbourne: Penguin Australia.
Reynolds, H. 1990, With the White People, Melbourne: Penguin Australia.
Roe, M. 1963, ‘Review of Manning Clark’, Quadrant 25 S, 73–76.
Rowse, T. 1993, ‘Mabo and Moral Anxiety’ in Meanjin 1993, No. 2, 229–244.
Suleri, S. 1992, The Rhetoric of English India, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
White, H. 1973. Metahistory, Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
White, H. 1978, Tropics of Discourse, Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.
