Hazardous Beginnings
Childbirth Practices in Frontier Tropical Australia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1017/S1321816600006401Keywords:
Nineteenth century Eurocentricism, pro-natalist policies, infant and maternal mortality rates, childbirthAbstract
Europeans living in the northern half of the Australian continent during the nineteenth century were united, and spurred on by, a dominant ideology of material progress, combined with a strong fear of being engulfed, both numerically and culturally, by foreign invaders. These bulwarks of Eurocentricism gave voice to strongly pro-natalist policies, coupled with intense immigration drives. The image of vast, uninhabited stretches of country waiting to be tamed by resolute, hard-working Britons added to the momentum for increased population. Progress, conceived in the masculinist framework of aggressive expansion, ruthless destruction of the Aboriginal people, economic development and environmental exploitation, needed not only capital, brawn and sheer determination to succeed but, also, healthy young citizens. Demographers graphs, however, fuelled anxiety that this dream might be undermined - for infant and maternal mortality rates in the tropics and sub-tropics were high compared with the rest of Australia and Britain. Masculinist attributes alone could not build the new society. Childbirth was potentially a hazardous and lethal undertaking which threatened to deprive the nascent colony of many fertile women and, in their demise, future generations.
References
An earlier version of this chapter was published in The Journal of Australian Studies 29 (1991):64–79.
Rubinstein, Annette, “Subtle Poison: The Puerperal Fever Controversy in Victorian Britain”, Historical Studies 20, April (1983):420–438; W. Wertz, Richard and C. Wertz, Dorothy, Lying-in (NY: Free Press, 1977); Pat Quiggan, No Rising Generation. Women and Fertility in Late Mneteenth Century Australia (Canberra: Department of Demography Research School of Social Sciences, ANU, 1988), pp.40–41.
Patrick, Ross, A History of Health and Medicine in Queensland, 1824–1960 (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1987), p.375. For a more general discussion on maternal mortality which negates the medical argument see Kerreen M. Reiger, The Disenchantment of the Home. Modernising the Australian Family, 1880–1940 (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1985), chapter 4.
Lewis, M., “The Problem of Maternal Mortality and population growth in Australia, 1880–1939: some ideological considerations”, Community Health Studies 4 (1980): 104.
Figures taken from Registrar General's Report: Vital Statistics for the years 1878, 1900, 1953 and the Report of Director General, Department of Health and Medical Services, 1946, QPP 2, 1947, p.291.
QPP, 1881, pp.xxxvi; for details of Melanesian deaths see Kay Saunders, Workers in Bondage. The Origins and Bases of Unfree Labour in Queensland, 1824–1916 (St Lucia: University of Queensland Press, 1982); Ralph Shlomowitz, “Epidemiology and the Pacific Labor Trade”, Journal of Interdisciplinary History 19 (1989):600–601.
Queensland Votes and Proceedings [QVP] 3, 1885, p.322.
QVP, 1876, p. 849.
Carmichael, Gordon A., “So Many Children: Colonial and Post Colonial Demographic Patterns” in Gender Relations in Australia, eds. Saunders, Kay and Evans, Raymond (Sydney: Harcourt, Brace and Jovanovich, 1992) p.133.
Jamieson, James, “The Present State of Puerperal Fever Question”, Australian Medical Journal, [AMJ] 15 June (1884):245.
QVP, 1879, p. 957. Concern was also expressed in England over the high maternal mortality rates in England and Wales, The British Medical Journal, [BMJ] 12 October 1878, p. 567.
Coghlan, T.A., “Deaths in Childbirth in New South Wales”, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society 63 (1898):67–68. See also C. Dyhouse, “Working Class Mothers and infant mortality in England, 1895–1914”, Journal of Social History 12, 2 (1978).
QVP 3, 1886, pp. 1408–9, QPP, 1915–16, 1, p.30, QPP, 1923, p.2. See also F.B. Smith, The People's Health 1830–1910 (London: Croom Helm, 1979), p.13.
Bolton, G.C., A Thousand Miles Away. A History of North Queensland to 1920 (Brisbane: Jacaranda Press, 1963), p.66. The Registrar-General's 1879 report noted that deaths in all categories for all ages were particularly high in the new mining centres due to accidents and the lack of public health infrastructure. This pattern continued in the next decade; for, in Cooktown, the port for the Palmer River goldfields, the ratio of deaths per 1000 remained at a high of 1 per 110 live births whereas Brisbane's rate had fallen to 1 to 254.
QVP, 1893, pp.xviii, 36–37.
QVP, 2, 1878, p.1297; QVP, 1, 1900, p.1382.
Holthouse, Hector, ed. S'pose I Die? The Story of Evelyn Maunsell (Sydney: Angus and Robertson, 1977), p.85.
Thearle, M.J., “Palaeolithic Medicine with particular reference to Children of Australian Aborigines.” Proceedings of the Twenty-Eighth International Conference for the History of Medicine, (paris, 1982).
Quoted in Colin Roderick, In Mortal Bondage: The Strange Life of Rosa Praed (Sydney: Angus and Robertson, 1948), p.10.
Mrs Praed, Campbell, My Australian Girlhood. Sketches and Impressions of Bush Life (London: T. Fisher Unwin, 1904), p.10.
“An Englishwoman's First Experiences in the Bush” cited in Michael Cannon, Life in the Country: Australia in the Victorian Age (Melbourne: Nelson: 1978), p.93.
Inquest conducted to inquire into the death of Mrs S, 2 April 1882, JUS/N33, QSA; see also Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Hospitals of the Colony, QVP, 1886, for other cases of indigent immigrant women, pp. 1637 passim.
Inquest conducted to inquire into the death of Mrs Margaret S of Blackall, 13 October, 1884. JUS/N109, QSA.
Case of Bridget L, 31 October, 1888, JUS/N160, QSA.
Case of Susannah and Ann C, Supreme Court Records CCT 3B/N24, QSA; See also case of Eliza and Elizabeth H, 18 February, 1878, Supreme Court Files, CCT2/67, QSA.
Carroll Smith-Rosenberg, “The Female World of Love and Ritual: Relations between women in Nineteenth Century America” in The Signs Reader. Women, Gender and Scholarship, eds. Abel, Elizabeth and Abel, Emily R. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1983), pp.27–55.
Spearrltt, Katie, “The Poverty of Protection: Women and Marriage in Colonial Queensland, 1870 to 1900”, B.A. Honours Thesis, History Department, University of Queensland, 1988.
Grimshaw, Patricia, “Tasman Sisters: Lives of the Second Sex” in Tasman Relations: New Zealand and Australia, 1788–1988, ed. Sinclair, Keith (Auckland: Auckland University Press, 1987), pp.224–245 overestimates the degree of generational networks.
Inquest into death of Mary Anne B, Logan 31 July 1890. JUS/N179, QSA.
Gilmore, Mary, quoted in Thearle, John and Gregory, Helen, ‘Choices for Childbirth. Midwifery in Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Century Queensland”, unpublished paper, p.14.
Fullerton, G., quoted in Thearle and Gregory, “Choices for Childbirth”, P.14.
Praed, My Australian Girlhood, pp .172–173 .
Nora Murray-Prior, Correspondence to Rosa Praed, 1880–81, MS. OM81-71, John Oxley Library, Brisbane.
Smith-Rosenberg, , “The Female World of Love and Ritual”, p.49.
Porter, Roy, “A Touch of Danger: the Man-Midwife as Sexual Predator”, in Sexual Underworlds in the, Enlightenment, eds. Rousseau, G.S. and Porter, Roy (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1987), p.219.
Inquest to inquire into the death of infant, Job B, 23 August 1891. JUS/N192, QSA.
Toowoomba Chronicle, 14 October, 1874.
Gordon, Douglas, “The Death of Mrs Trueman of Tiaro. Medical Practice on the Mary River Eighty Years Ago”, MJA 1 (1960) :249; refer also to J. Hagger, Colonial Australian Medicine (Melbourne: Rigby, 1976), p.118 passim.
McConnel, Mary, Memoirs of Days Long Gone By. By the Wife of an Australian Pioneer. (Brisbane, n.d), p.23, Fryer Memorial Library, University of Queensland.
Jane Collins to William Collins, Mudoolan, 30 August, 1867, OM 82–64, John Oxley Library, Brisbane.
Queensland Notes, Dawn, October, 1891, p.23.
Patrick, “Health and Medicine in Queensland”, p.376.
Nye, L.J.J., “The Practice of Medicine Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow”, MJA 11 (1965):524.
Litoff, Judy Barrett, American Midwives 1860 to the Present (Westport: Greenwood, 1978); Reiger, The Disenchantment of the Home, pp.87–88; James Jamieson, “Childbirth Mortality in the Australian Colonies”, AMJ 15 October (1887).
Balls-Headley, W., “Antiseptic midwifery”, AMJ 15 July, 1888.
Thomas Murrary-Prior diary, entry 2 September 1889. T. Murray-Prior papers, Mitchell Library, Sydney; refer also to Judith Wright, Generation of Men (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1959), pp.91–99.
Nora Murray-Prior to Rosa Praed, September, 1888. MS OML 81–71, John Oxley Library.
Lizzie Landsborough memoirs, Lucy North Papers, JOL.
Allen, William, diary 6 June 1881, William Allen and Mary Allen Papers, La Trobe Library, Melbourne.
Thearle and Gregory, “Choices for Childbirth”, P.18, passim, for an intensive coverage of this process in Australia refer to Reiger, The Disenchantment of the Home, pp.106–109.
