The Decay of Reform
Police and Politics in Post-Fitzgerald Queensland
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1017/S1321816600001501Keywords:
1989 Fitzgerald Report, Queensland police and governmental corruption, public sector reform, Criminal Justice CommissionAbstract
The 1989 Fitzgerald Report into police and governmental corruption in Queensland has been a model for public sector reform in Australia. It is especially timely to consider the impact of those reforms in light of the current overhaul of the largest police agency in Australia, the New South Wales Police Service, and of continuing problems with public sector probity in other states. Queensland made significant advances in improving electoral and administrative processes, and creating external independent oversight of the police. Nonetheless, unforeseen gaps in the Fitzgerald agenda allowed reactionary forces to dilute the reform process. Three primary areas remain ‘unreconstructed’. Reform has not been firmly established from the top down, beginning with progressing the system of representative democracy and opening up cabinet. Additionally, the Police Service appears to have successfully resisted the prescribed re-orientation away from law enforcement to community policing. Detection and control of misconduct also remain weak. A more interventionist Criminal Justice Commission is needed, with more proactive strategies for developing compliance with ethical standards.
References
Bingham, M., 1996, Report on the Review of the Queensland Police Service, Kingswood Press, Brisbane.
CJC, 1995, Ethical Conduct and Discipline in the Queensland Police Service: The Views of Recruits, First Year Constables and Experienced Officers, Criminal Justice Commission, Brisbane.
CJC, 1996, Report on the Investigation into a Memorandum of Understanding, etc., Criminal Justice Commission, Brisbane.
Coaldrake, P., 1989, Working the System: Government in Queensland, UQ Press, Brisbane.
de Maria, W., 1994a, Unshielding the Shadow Culture: Queensland Whistleblower Study, Department of Social Work and Social Policy, University of Queensland, Brisbane.
de Maria, W., 1994b, Wounded Workers: Queensland Whistleblower Study, Department of Social Work and Social Policy, University of Queensland, Brisbane.
Eades, D., 1995, ‘Cross examination of Aboriginal children: The Pinkenba case’, Aboriginal Law Bulletin, vol. 3, no. 75, pp. 10–11.
EARC, 1996, Report on Queensland Legislative Assembly Electoral System, Volume 1 — The Report, Government Printer, Brisbane.
Fitzgerald, G., 1989, Report of a Commission of Inquiry Pursuant to Orders in Council, Goprint, Brisbane.
Fitzgerald, R., 1996, ‘An honest chief, but still right for the job?’, Courier Mail, 3 September, p. 11.
Four Corners, 1996, Black and Blue, ABC Television, Sydney.
Franklin, M., 1996, ‘Beanland foiled by Nationals on sex law, FOI’, Courier Mail, 14 December, p. 2.
Giles, D., 1995 ‘Look out Mr Bigs’, Courier Mail, 8 October, p. 4.
Koch, T., 1994, ‘Police now clean: CJC’, Courier Mail, 9 March, p. 1.
Meryment, E., 1997, ‘CJC “incompetent and biased” during Davies inquiry’, Courier Mail, 18 February, p. 12.
Metcalf, F., 1997, ‘Borbidge orders review of PS travel rules amid conflict of interest row’, Courier Mail, 19 June, p. 3.
Morley, P. & Callinan, R., 1996, ‘Police top jobs on open market’, Courier Mail, 30 August, p. 1.
Morley, P., 1997, ‘Travel rules still loose’, Courier Mail, 12 April, p. 26.
Petersen, D., 1995, ‘Hobbling FOI’, Courier Mail, 18 November, p. 27.
Ransley, J., 1992, ‘Reform of parliamentary processes: An assessment’, in Keeping Them Honest: Democratic Reform in Queensland, eds Hede, A., Prasser, S. & Neylan, M., UQ Press, Brisbane.
Stevens, B. & Wanna, J., 1993, The Goss Government, Macmillan, Melbourne.
Walker, J., 1992, ‘Rivals in justice’, Australian, 3 July, p. 9.
Woodyatt, T., 1995, ‘Why we need the Criminal Justice Commission and how it could be better’, Queensland Review, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 58–61.
