The gatekeepers
The role of lawyers in the New Zealand commercial mediation market
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/mtp.32583Keywords:
mediation, commercial, lawyers, dispute resolutionAbstract
Mediation is one form of dispute resolution used in resolving commercial disputes in New Zealand. Lawyers play a key role as gatekeepers to commercial mediation. This article explores the role that these gatekeepers are playing in the New Zealand private commercial mediation market. The findings are based on a survey and interviews carried out in late 2015 and early 2016. Prior to this study there was no comprehensive information on the attitude of New Zealand commercial lawyers to mediation. The evidence reported in this article suggests that lawyers are very aware of commercial mediation, and support it, but largely on their own terms. They are not undermining it. In fact, lawyers believe they are contributing positively to the mediation process. Clients have a more limited knowledge of mediation but usually follow their lawyer’s recommendations. Thus lawyers play a key role as gatekeepers to commercial mediation. The main reason lawyers recommend mediation is cost (i.e. it is cheaper than litigation). Lawyers prefer legally trained mediators with experience and a good reputation. Lawyers report high mediation settlement rates and high overall quality of mediations. Overall, the ‘gatekeepers’ are generally happy with the standard of commercial mediation in New Zealand. However, mediation exists to serve the clients, not the gatekeepers. The views of actual users are necessary to complete the picture of the New Zealand commercial mediation market.
References
Agapiou, A. (2015) The factors influencing mediation referral practices and barriers to its adoption: a survey of construction lawyers in England and Wales. International Journal of Law in the Built Environment 7(3): 231–47. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJLBE-07-2014-0018
Agapiou, A. and Clark, B. (2011) Scottish construction lawyers and mediation: an investigation into attitudes and experiences. International Journal of Law in the Built Environment 3(2): 159–81. https://doi.org/10.1108/17561451111148266
Betancourt, J. C. and Lee, J. (2016) Mediation in England and Wales: Why should it be mandatory? Mediation Theory and Practice 1(1): 95–110. https://doi.org/10.1558/mtp.v1i1.28333
Boulle, L. (2011) Mediation: Principles, Process, Practice (3rd edn). Chatswood: LexisNexis.
CEDR (2016) The Seventh Mediation Audit: A Survey of Commercial Mediator Attributes and Experience. London: Centre for Effective Dispute Resolution.
Clark, B. (2012) Lawyers and Mediation. Berlin: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-23474-3
Clark, B. and Dawson, C. (2007) ADR and Scottish commercial litigators: a study of attitudes and experience. Civil Justice Quarterly 26: 228–49.
Farmer, J. (2008) Civil litigation in crisis? Paper presented at the New Zealand Bar Association and Legal Research Foundation Civil Litigation Conference, Auckland, 22 February.
Global Pound Conference Series (2016) Local voting results. Retrieved on 8 May 2017 from http://globalpoundconference.org/gpc-series-data/local-voting-results.
Grant, A. (2012) Mediation’s rise and litigation’s demise. NZLawyer 185: 13.
Leathes, M. (2016) Data will defeat the ‘deadening drag of status quoism’: the Global Pound Conference Series has kicked off. Mediate.com. Retrieved on 8 May 2017 from www.mediate.com/articles/DataWillDefeat.cfm.
Loddenkemper, T. (2000) Mediation in civil and commercial disputes in New Zealand: an empirical and theoretical approach to how to raise its acceptance. LLM thesis, University of Canterbury, New Zealand.
Moore, C. (2015) Advancing women in the profession. LawTalk 887: 5.
Morris, G. (2013) Towards a history of mediation in New Zealand’s legal system. Australasian Dispute Resolution Journal 24: 86–101.
Morris, G. (2016) From anecdote to evidence: the New Zealand commercial mediation market. New Zealand Business Law Quarterly 22(1): 10–30.
Morris, G. and Lamb, A. (2016) Gatekeepers to Commercial Mediation in New Zealand Project Report. Research paper. Wellington: Resolution Institute, Victoria University of Wellington.
Morris, G. and Schroder, D. (2015) LEADR/Victoria University Commercial Mediation in New Zealand Project Report. Research paper. Wellington: Victoria University of Wellington.
Pol, R., Mayson, S., Maister, D. and Balls, A. (2009) The Business of Law (2nd edn). Wellington: Brookers.
Sidoli del Ceno, J. (2011) An investigation into lawyer attitudes towards the use of mediation in commercial property disputes in England and Wales. International Journal of Law in the Built Environment 3(2): 182–98. https://doi.org/10.1108/17561451111148275
Statistics New Zealand (2015) Subnational population estimates at 30 June 2015. Retrieved on 8 May 2017 from www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats/population/estimates_and_projections/SubnationalPopulationEstimates_HOTPAt30Jun15.aspx.
Stipanowich, T. J. (2015) The international evolution of mediation: a call for dialogue and deliberation. Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 46: 1191–244.
Stipanowich, T. J. and Lamare, J. R. (2014) Living with ADR: evolving perceptions and use of mediation, arbitration, and conflict management in Fortune 1000 Corporations. Harvard Negotiation Law Review 19(1): 1–68.
Sturrock, J. (2007) Reflections on commercial mediation in Scotland. Arbitration 73: 77–83.
Van der Vel, S. (2015) Visit from mediation services. Retrieved on 8 May 2017 from www.adls.org.nz/for-the-profession/news-and-opinion/2015/10/9/visit-frommediation-services.
Winkelmann, H. (2011) ADR and the civil justice system. Paper presented at the AMINZ Conference, Auckland, 4–5 August.
