Fabricated Nature
Where Are the Boundaries?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/ecot.2006.11.1.9Keywords:
technology, GM, nature, CreationAbstract
Problems associated with our use of technology have multiplied as the technologies themselves have become ever more powerful and particularly since we can now manipulate life itself. Genetical manipulation encapsulates for many the questions, fears and confusions raised by technological advances. The Prince of Wales’s criticisms of GM have been useful in crystallizing these. Some of the issues he has raised are due to misapprehension (such as the claim that the transfer of genes can only occur ‘naturally’ between organisms that interbreed; this is factually incorrect) but others highlight important topics about the relation between mankind and his environment.
A persisting problem is that this relationship is distorted for us by the dominance of the Enlightenment enterprise that revealed so much about the natural world and its mechanisms. Crucially, this obscures the reality that we are more than mere apes—we are individuals created in God’s image—and that the apparently limitless opportunities that emerge from modern knowledge bring with them enormous responsibilities as well as enormous privileges—responsibilities to others, to our world, and to God. Lacking omniscience, we must accept the discipline of the ‘precautionary principle’ and the inter-dependence of scientific advance and social cohesion. We need wisdom as well as knowledge. In this respect, we can learn hugely from the history of the land which the Creator entrusted to humankind and the treatment of which is described in the older Testament. It teaches us about the limits of any one approach by itself—whether we espouse naturalism (or scientism), regulation, altruism or societal controls. Failure to look beyond ourselves and our own interests is likely to get us no further than an unstable modern version of the Tower of Babel.
References
Alexander, D.R. 2003 Worshipping God with Technology (Cambridge Papers, 12, No. 4; Cambridge: Jubilee Centre).
Ashby, E., and M. Anderson 1981 The Politics of Clean Air (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
Barbour, I. 1992 Ethics in an Age of Technology (London: SCM Press).
Berry, R.J. 2003 God’s Book of Works (London: T. & T. Clark).
Berry, R.J. (ed.) 2006 Environmental Stewardship: Critical Perspectives—Past and Present (London: T. & T. Clark).
Blair, T. 1999 ‘Foreword’, in A Better Quality of Life: 3 (London: The Stationery Office, Cm 4345).
Borgmann, A. 1984 Technology and the Character of Contemporary Life (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
Bruce, D. 2001 ‘How Far Should We Take the Precautionary Principle?’ (Lecture given at the Linnean Society, 26 April).
Bruce, D., and D. Horrocks (eds.) 2001 Modifying Creation? GM Crops and Food (London: Evangelical Alliance).
Brueggemann, W. 1977 The Land (Philadelphia: Fortress Press).
Carson, R. 1962 Silent Spring (Boston: Houghton Mifflin).
Catherwood, F. 1983 ‘The New Technology: The Human Debate’, in J.R.W. Stott (ed.), The Year 2000 AD (Basingstoke: Marshalls): 126-45.
Christian Aid 1999 Selling Suicide (London: Christian Aid).
Cooley, D.R., and G.A. Goreham 2004 ‘Are Transgenic Organisms Unnatural?’, Ethics and the Environment 9: 46-55.
Cupitt, D. 1984 The Sea of Faith (London: British Broadcasting Corporation).
Deane-Drummond, C. 1996 A Handbook in Theology and Ecology (London: SCM Press).
Theology and Biotechnology (London: Geoffrey Chapman).
Creation through Wisdom (Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark).
Biology and Theology Today (London: SCM Press).
Deane-Drummond, C., and B. Szerszynski (eds.) 2003 Re-Ordering Nature: Theology, Society and the New Genetics (London: T. & T. Clark).
Donovan, N., and D. Halpern 2002 Life Satisfaction: The State of Knowledge and the Implications for Government (London: Cabinet Office Strategy Unit).
Forum for Technology, Citizens and the Market 2004 What’s There to Talk About? (London: Royal Society of Arts).
Fox, M.V. 1989 Qohelet and his Contradictions (Sheffield: Almond Press).
Fukuyama, F. 2002 Our Posthuman Future: Consequences of the Biotechnology Revolution (London: Profile Books).
Grove-White, R. 1992 ‘Human identity and the environmental crisis’, in J. Ball, M. Goodall, C. Palmer and J. Reader (eds.) The Earth Beneath (London: SPCK): 13-34.
Grove-White, R., P. Macnaghten, S. Mayer and B. Wynne 1997 Uncertain World: Genetically Modified Organisms, Food and Public Attitudes in Britain (Lancaster: Centre for the Study of Environmental Change).
Hamilton, C. 2003 Downshifting in Britain: A Sea-change in the Pursuit of Happiness (Canberra: The Australia Institute, Paper no. 58).
Harrison, R. 1964 Animal Machines (London: Vincent Stuart).
‘Case Study: Farm Animals’, in R.J. Berry (ed.) Environmental Dilemmas (London: Chapman & Hall): 118-35.
Huang, J., R. Hu, S. Rozelle and C. Pray 2005 ‘Insect-resistant GM Rice in Farmers’ Fields: Assessing Productivity and Health Effects in China’, Science 308: 688-90.
Huxley, A. 1958 Brave New World Revisited (New York: Harper).
Jeeves, M.A., and R.J. Berry 1998 Science, Life and Christian Belief (Leicester: Apollos).
Johnson, P.E. 1995 Reason in the Balance: The Case Against Naturalism in Science, Law and Education (Downer’s Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press).
Jones, D.G. 2005 Designers of the Future: Are Biomedical Scientists Saints or Sinners? (Oxford: Monarch).
Kasser, T. 2002 The High Price of Materialism (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
Lewin, B. 2006 Essential Genes (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson).
Moore, A. 1889 ‘The Christian Doctrine of God’, in C. Gore (ed.), Lux Mundi (London: John Murray): 57-109.
Moore, P. 2000 Babel’s Shadow: Genetic Technologies in a Fracturing Society (Oxford: Lion).
Moule, C.F.D. 1964 Man and Nature in the New Testament (London: Athlone Press).
Murphy, R.E. 1992 Ecclesiastes (Word Bible Commentary, 23A; Dallas: Word Books).
Myers, D.G. 2000 ‘The Funds, Friends, and Faith of Happy People’, American Psychologist 55: 56-67.
Nuffield Council on Bioethics 1999 Genetically Modified Crops: Ethical and Social Issues (London: Nuffield Council).
The Use of Genetically Modified Crops in Developing Countries (London: Nuffield Council).
O’Neill, O. 2004 ‘Accountability, Trust and Informed Consent in Medical Practice and Research’, Clinical Medicine 4: 269-76.
Ostertag, E.M., and H.H. Kazazian 2005 ‘LINEs in mind’, Nature 435: 890-91.
Peacocke, A.R. 2004 Creation and the World of Science (Oxford: Oxford University Press, rev. edn).
Pennock, R.T. 1999 Tower of Babel: The Evidence Against the New Creationism (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press).
Perry, J.N. 2003 ‘Genetically-modified Crops’, Science & Christian Belief 15: 141-64.
Peters, T. and G. Bennett, G. 2002 Bridging Science and Religion (London: SCM Press).
Polkinghorne, J.C. 1994 Science and Christian Belief (London: SPCK).
Porritt, J. 2000 Playing Safe: Science and the Environment (London: Thames & Hudson).
Prince of Wales 1998 ‘Seeds of Disaster’, The Daily Telegraph, 8 June.
‘A Royal View’, in Chris Patten, Tom Lovejoy, John Browne, Gro Brundtland, Vandana Shiva and HRH the Prince of Wales, Respect for the Earth (London: Profile Books): 80-89.
Rattray Taylor, G. 1972 Rethink: A Paraprimitive Solution (London: Secker & Warburg).
Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution 1989 Thirteenth Report: The Release of Genetically Engineered Organisms to the Environment (London: HMSO, Cm 720).
Schumacher, E.F. 1973 Small is Beautiful (London: Blond & Briggs).
Soil Association 1999 Contrasting the Use of Genetic Engineering in Medicine and Agriculture (Bristol: Soil Association Briefing Paper).
Summerton, N. 2001 ‘Foreword’, in Bruce and Horrocks (eds.) 2001: vii-x.
Westermann, C. 1971 Creation (trans. J.J. Scullion: London: SPCK).
White, L. 1967 ‘The Historical Roots of our Ecologic Crisis’, Science 155: 1203-207.
Williams, R. 2004 ‘Changing the Myths We Live By’ (Lecture given at Lambeth Palace, 5 July).
