Post-Pandoran Depression or Na'vi Sympathy

Avatar, Affect, and Audience Reception


  • Matthew Alan Holtmeier University of St. Andrews



Ecosophy, Avatar, Ethics, Affect, Environments, Audience Reception, Felix Guattari, Gilles Deleuze


Purporting to send an environmentally and spiritually healthy message, Avatar seems like an ideal candidate to positively impact audience members' positions towards the environment on a large scale. Indeed, director James Cameron said that “Avatar asks us all to be warriors for the Earth.” Since Avatar was released in theaters, however, there have been two overwhelming trends in response to the film: either, a seemingly immediate change in the spectators' worldview and relationship with the environment; or, the creation of an unachievable desire for the hyper-real techno-spiritual world of Pandora. These responses – environmentally proactive Na'vi sympathy and a debilitating post-Pandoran depression – offer examples of two, very different, relationships with the world. At the base of these relationships is the film's ability to provoke emotional response in audiences, which engenders positive or negative relationships with the environment.

Author Biography

  • Matthew Alan Holtmeier, University of St. Andrews
    University of St. Andrews, Department of Film Studies, PhD Student


Anonymous Posters. 2010a. ‘How Avatar has Empowered you and this Community—Community Tree Planting Tracker’, Online:

Anonymous Posters. 2010b. ‘ive been thinking’, Online:

Anonymous Posters. 2009–10a. ‘Ways to cope with the depression of the dream of Pandora being intangible’, Online:

Anonymous Posters. 2009–10b. ‘Ways to cope with the depression of the dream of Pandora being intangible. Part 2’, Online:

Anonymous Posters. 2009–10c. ‘Ways to cope with the depression of the dream of Pandora being intangible. Part 3’, Online:

Anonymous Posters. 2009–10d. ‘Ways to cope with the depression of the dream of Pandora being intangible. Part 4’, Online:

Bogue, Ronald. 2010. ‘To Choose to Choose—to Believe in This World’, in David Norman Rodowick (ed.), Afterimages of Gilles Deleuze’s Film Philosophy (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press): 115-34.

Deleuze, Gilles. 1986. Cinema 1 (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press).

———. 1989. Cinema 2 (New York: The Athlone Press).

Genosko, Gary. 2009. Felix Guattari: A Critical Introduction (New York: Pluto Press).

Guattari, Felix. 2000. The Three Ecologies (New York: The Athlone Press).

Hintz, Adam. 2009. ‘Avatar’, YouTube. Online:

Jenkins, Henry. 2010. ‘Avatar Activism’, Le Monde diplomatique. Online:

Katib, Haitham A. 2010. ‘Bilin Reenacts Avatar Film 12-02-2010 By Haitham Al Katib’, YouTube. Online:

Piazza, Jo. 2010. ‘Audiences Experience “Avatar” Blues’, CNN, January 11. Online:

Spitzer, Melaina. 2010. ‘Avatar in the Amazon’, PRI’s The World, January 29. Online:

Svetkey, Benjamin. 2010. ‘James Cameron on Returning to Avatar’, Entertainment Weekly 1116/1117, August 20/27.



How to Cite

Holtmeier, M. A. (2011). Post-Pandoran Depression or Na’vi Sympathy: Avatar, Affect, and Audience Reception. Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature and Culture, 4(4), 414-424.