Refuse Usage and Architectural Reuse in the Field
A View from the Early Islamic Plot-and-Berm Agroecosystem to the South of Caesarea/Qaysariyya (Israel)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/jia.23644Keywords:
Caesarea, Early Islamic agriculture, water harvesting, Plot-and-Berm agroecosystem, aeolian sand and dunes, refuse management, anthrosol, architectural reuseAbstract
Based on the mostly unpublished finds of a 1970s excavation and the initial results of a 2020 survey and excavation of the remains of an Early Islamic Plot-and-Berm (P&B) agroecosystem south of ancient Caesarea/Qaysariyya, this study discusses the agricultural incorporation of refuse in a pristine aeolian sand environment. The P&B agroecosystem, characterized by anthro-terrain/earthworks of sunken agricultural plots delimited by sand berms, comprises an innovative initiative to cultivate dunefields on a high groundwater table. The key element for the sustainability of this unique agrotechnology was refuse. The refuse, extracted from nearby town dumps, included ash, carbonate, trace elements and artifacts. It was probably sorted into small artifacts and grey loam. It was then brought to the fields, not only combined to stabilize the erodible and initially unvegetated berm surface until today, but also partly altered the physical and chemical properties of the sand and increased its fertility, mainly in the plots, to form sandy loam anthrosols. The pristine aeolian sand substrate enabled a clear and quantitative stratigraphic and pedological differentiation of the refuse additions. The transportation of human waste to the fields and its incorporation into the natural sediment to form an anthrosol formed part of the "waste stream" of Caesarea's Early Islamic population. Such human-modified soil environments by means of manuring, gained a specific signature and would have been considered "soil places" which became part of the local onomasticon of placenames and probably created "cultural soilscapes." The clear aeolian sandy substrate makes the P&B agroecosystems an excellent case study on soil enrichment by refuse, and enlightens us about the relative amounts and methodologies of refuse extraction, sorting, transportation, and incorporation.
References
'Ad, U. 2009 “Remains of a farming complex and irrigation system from the end of the Byzantine – beginning of the Early Islamic periods in the agricultural hinterlands of Caesarea.” 'Atiqot 61: 49–60 (Hebrew; English summary, 133–134).
Arnon, Y. D. 2007 “Excavation in Marcus Street, Ramla: Pottery, oil lamps and carved stone vessels.” Contract Archaeology Reports 2: 38–99.
a Caesarea Maritima, the Late Periods (700–1291 CE). British Archaeological Reports International Series 1771. Oxford: Archaeopress.
b “The ceramic oil lamps of the transitional and medieval periods (640–1300): A chronological and typological study.” In Caesarea Reports and Studies. Excavations 1995–2007 within the Old City and the Ancient Harbor, edited by K. G. Holum, J. A. Stabler and E. G. Reinhardt, 213–269. British Archaeological Reports International Series 1784. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Avisar, A. 2021 “The Effect of Eucalyptus Trees on Soil Composition and Water Regime in a Coastal Sandy Habitat: A Change in Overall Ecosystem Functioning.” Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Tel Aviv University (Hebrew).
Avni, G. 2014 The Byzantine-Islamic Transition in Palestine: An Archaeological Approach. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
“Early Islamic irrigated farmsteads and the spread of qanats in Eurasia.” Water History. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12685-018-0225-6
“Terraced fields, irrigation systems and agricultural production in Early Islamic Palestine and Jordan: Continuity and innovation.” Journal of Islamic Archaeology 7(2): 111–137.
Ayalon, E., E. Gilboa and S. Harpazi. 1990 “A public building of the Early Arabic period and Crusader remains at Tel Qasile—the 12th–13th seasons.” Israel—People and Land 5–6: 9–22 (Hebrew; English summary, p. 11).
Ayalon E., E. Gilboa and Z. Shacham. 1988 “A public building of the Early Arab period at Tell Qasile.” Israel—People and Land 4: 35–52 (Hebrew; English summary, 7–8).
Buckingham, H. 2019 “Metals.” In The Leon Levy Expedition to Ashkelon. Ashkelon 8: The Islamic and Crusader Periods, by T. Hoffman, 629–642. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns.
Cytryn-Silverman, K. 2010 “The ceramic evidence.” In Ramla. Final Report on the Excavations North of the White Mosque, by O. Gutfeld, 97–211. Qedem 51. Jerusalem: Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Dey, H., B. Goodman-Tchernov and J. Sharvit. 2014 “Archaeological evidence for the tsunami of January 18, AD 749: A chapter in the history of Early Islamic Qaysariyah (Caesarea Maritima).” Journal of Roman Archaeology 27: 357–373.
Ellenblum, R. 2012 The Collapse of the Eastern Mediterranean: Climate Change and the Decline of the East, 950–1072. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Forbes, H. 2013 “Off-site scatters and the manuring hypothesis in Greek survey archaeology: An ethnographic approach.” Hesperia 82(4): 551–594.
Forste, K. 2021 “An intrasite analysis of agricultural economy at Early Islamic Caesarea Maritima, Israel.” Ethnobiology Letters 12(1): 58–69.
Fuks, D., O. Amichay and E. Weiss. 2020 “Innovation or preservation? Abbasid aubergines, archaeobotany, and the Islamic Green Revolution.” Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 12(2). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-019-00959-5
Gadot, Y., U. Davidovich, G. Avni, Y. Avni, M. Piasetzky, G. Faershtein and N. Porat. 2016 “The formation of a Mediterranean terraced landscape: Mount Eitan, Judean Highlands, Israel.” Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 6: 397–417.
Gardner, W. G. 1965 “Water content.” In Methods of Soil Analysis, 9, edited by C. A. Black, 82–127. Madison, WI: American Society of Agronomy.
Gendelman, P. and U. ‘Ad. 2019 “Caesarea Maritima—a view from outside: The periphery of the Roman and Byzantine metropolis.” In Judaea/Palaestina and Arabia: Cities and Hinterlands in Roman and Byzantine Times. Proceedings of the 19th International Congress of Classical Archaeology Cologne/Bonn, 22–26 May 2018: Archaeology and Economy in the Ancient World, Panel 8.6, edited by A. Lichtenberger, O. Tal and Z. Weiss, 19–37. Heidelberg: Propylaeum.
Given, M. 2018 “Conviviality and the life of soil.” Cambridge Archaeological Journal 28(1): 127–143.
Hamburger, H. 1950 “Caesarea coin-finds and the history of the city.” Yediot. Bulletin of the Israel Exploration Society 15: 78–82 (Hebrew).
Hoffman, T. 2019 The Leon Levy Expedition to Ashkelon. Ashkelon 8: The Islamic and Crusader Periods. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns.
Huster, Y. 2015 The Leon Levy Expedition to Ashkelon. Ashkelon 5: The Land Behind Ashkelon. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns.
Jones, R. 2009 “Manure and the medieval social order.” In Land and People: Papers in Memory of John G. Evans, edited by M. J. Allen, N. Sharples and T. O’Connor T, 215–225. Oxford: Prehistoric Society/Oxbow.
Kedar, Y. and Y. Ziv. 1964 “The water supply of ancient Caesarea.” Yediot. Bulletin of the Israel Exploration Society 28: 122–131 (Hebrew).
Kidron, G. J. 2010 “Under-canopy microclimate within sand dunes in the Negev Desert.” Journal of Hydrology 392(3–4): 201–210.
Klein, M. and M. Lichter. 2006 “Monitoring changes in shoreline position adjacent to the Hadera power station, Israel.” Applied Geography 26(3–4): 210–226.
Kutiel, P., A. Danin and G. Orshan. 1979 “Vegetation of the sandy soils near Caesarea, Israel. I. Plant communities, environment and succession.” Israel Journal of Plant Sciences 28(1): 20–35.
Liu, L. and T. Bo. 2020 “Effects of checkerboard sand barrier belt on sand transport and dune advance.” Aeolian Research 42: 100546.
Loeppert, R. H. and D. L. Suarez. 1996 “Carbonate and gypsum.” In Methods of Soil Analysis, Part 3: Chemical Methods (SSSA Series, Vol. 5), edited by D. L. Sparks, A. L. Page, P. A. Helmke, R. H. Loeppert, P. N. Soltanpour, M. A. Tabatabai, C. T. Johnson and M. E. Sumner, 437–474. Madison, WI: American Society of Agronomy.
Lucke, B., S. al-Karaimeh and G. Schörner. 2019 “Channels, terraces, pottery, and sediments – A comparison of past irrigation systems along a climatic transect in northern Jordan.” Journal of Arid Environments 160: 56–73.
Mesqui, J. 2014 Césarée Maritime. Ville fortifiée du Proche-Orient. Paris: Picard.
Morriss, V. 2019 “Reimagining the Palestinian ribat and their role in the creation of the Islamic maritime frontier.” In Fortificación, espiritualidad y frontera en el islam medieval: ribats de al-Andalus, el Magreb y más allá, edited by J. Albarrán and E. Daza, 33–56. Madrid: La Ergástula.
Nasir-i, Khusrau. 1881 C. Schefer, edited and translated. Sefer Nameh. Relation du voyage de Nassiri Khosrau en Syrie, en Palestine, en Égypte, en Arabie et en Perse. Paris: Ernest Leroux.
Patrich, J. 2011 “Caesarea in transition: the archaeological evidence from the southwest zone (Areas CC, KK, NN).” In Shaping the Middle East: Jews, Christians, and Muslims in an Age of Transition, 400–800 CE, edited by K. G. Holum and H. Lapin, 33–64. Bethesda: University of Maryland Press.
Porat, N., U. Davidovich, Y. Avni, G. Avni and Y. Gadot. 2018 “Using OSL measurements to decipher soil history in archaeological terraces, Judean Highlands, Israel.” Land Degradation & Development 29(3): 643–650.
Porath, Y. 1975 “The gardens of Caesarea.” Qadmoniot 30–31: 90–93 (Hebrew).
“Pipelines of the Caesarea water supply system.” 'Atiqot: Hebrew Series 10: 101–110 (Hebrew; English summary, 19*–20*).
“Tunnel-well (qanat) systems and settlements from the Early Islamic period in the ‘Arava.” 'Atiqot 86: 1*–81* (Hebrew; English summary, 113–116).
Raban, A. and Y. Arnon. 2006 “‘There is not on the Romaean sea a city more beautiful’: Caesarea and its water installations during the Early Islamic period.” Cathedra 122: 177–202 (Hebrew; English summary, 211–212).
Ramsay, J. and K. Holum. 2015 “An archaeobotanical analysis of the Islamic period occupation at Caesarea Maritima, Israel.” Vegetation History and Archaeobotany 24(6): 655–671.
Reifenberg, A. 1950–1951 “Caesarea: A study in the decline of a town.” Israel Exploration Journal 1: 20–32.
Roskin, J. 2020 “Comment on Liu et al. 2018. Ground-active arthropod response to distance from the Mediterranean seashore in coastal sand areas of western Israel.” Arid Land Research and Management 34(3): 353–359.
Roskin J, D. Sivan, G. Shtienberg, E. Roskin, N. Porat and R. Bookman. 2015 “Natural and human controls of the Holocene evolution of the beach, aeolian sand and dunes of Caesarea (Israel).” Aeolian Research 19: 65–85.
Roskin, J., D. Sivan, G. Shtienberg, N. Porat and R. Bookman. 2017, “Holocene beach buildup and coastal aeolian sand incursions off the Nile littoral cell.” In EGU General Assembly Conference Abstracts (p. 844).
Roskin, J. and I. Taxel. 2021a “‘He who revives dead land’: Groundwater harvesting agroecosystems in sand along the southeastern Mediterranean coast since early medieval times.” Mediterranean Geoscience Reviews. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42990-021-00058-5
b “Groundwater-fed plot-and-berm agroecosystems in aeolian sand in the Mediterranean Basin.” In Advances in Geoethics and Groundwater Management: Theory and Practice for a Sustainable Development. Proceedings of the 1st Congress on Geoethics and Groundwater Management (GEOETH&GWM’20), Porto, Portugal 2020, edited by M. Abrunhosa, A. Chambel, S. Peppoloni and H. I. Chaminé, 473–478. Cham: Springer.
Rowell D. L. 1994 Soil Science: Methods and Application. New York: Longman Scientific and Technical.
Sánchez, R. and M. Cuellar. 2016 “Coastal interdune agroecosystems in the Mediterranean: A case study of the Andalusian Navazo.” Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems 40(9): 895–921.
Schaffer, G. 2020 “The driving forces inducing land cover changes in Israel’s northern Sharon Plain from the end of the nineteenth century to the present time.” Historical Geography 48(1): 102–132.
Schiffer, M. B. 1996 Formation Processes of the Archaeological Record. 2nd edition. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press.
Behavioral Archaeology: Principles and Practices. London and Oakville: Equinox.
Shaharabani, M. 1985 “An instrument for measuring carbonate content in the soil.” Unpublished seminar dissertation. The Department of Geography, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan (Hebrew with English abstract).
Shtienberg, G., S. Shalev, D. Sivan, R. Shahack-Gross, J. Dix, N. Waldmann, J. Roskin, A. Yasur-Landau and R. Bookman. 2017 “Anthropogenic overprints on natural coastal aeolian sediments: a case study from the periphery of ancient Caesarea, Israel.” Anthropocene 19: 22–34.
Shtienberg, G., J. K. Dix, J. Roskin, N. Waldmann, R. Bookman, O. M. Bialik and D. Sivan. 2017 “New perspectives on coastal landscape reconstruction during the late Quaternary: A test case from central Israel.” Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 468: 503–519.
Stacey, D. 2004 Excavations at Tiberias, 1973–1974. The Early Islamic Periods. Israel Antiquity Authority Reports 21. Jerusalem: Israel Antiquities Authority.
Stern E. J., S. Y. Waksman and A. Shapiro. 2020 “The impact of the crusades on ceramic production and use in the southern Levant: Continuity or change?” In Multidisciplinary Approaches to Food and Foodways in the Medieval Eastern Mediterranean, edited by S. Y. Waksman, 113–146. Lyon: Maison de l’Orient et de la Méditerranée.
Taxel, I. 2014 “Luxury and common wares: Socio-economic aspects of the distribution of glazed pottery in Early Islamic Palestine.” Levant 46(1): 118–139.
a “Early Islamic Palestine: Toward a more fine-tuned recognition of settlement patterns and land uses in town and country.” Journal of Islamic Archaeology 5(2): 153–180.
b Fragile Biography: The Life Cycle of Ceramics and Refuse Disposal Patterns in Late Antique and Early Medieval Palestine. BABESCH Supplements 35. Leuven: Peeters.
Taxel, I. and J. Roskin. Forthcoming “An Early Islamic groundwater-harvesting Plot-and-Berm sand agroecosystem to the south of Caesarea: preliminary results of the 2020 survey and excavation.” In Proceedings of the 12th ICAANE Conference.
Taxel, I. D. Sivan, R. Bookman and J. Roskin. 2018 “An Early Islamic inter-settlement agroecosystem in the coastal sand of the Yavneh dunefield, Israel.” Journal of Field Archaeology 43(7): 551–569. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00934690.2018.1522189
Van der Veen, M. 2014 “The materiality of plants: Plant–people entanglements.” World Archaeology 46(5): 799–812.
Yannai, E. 2009 “Excavations at Or ‘Aqiva (North).” 'Atiqot 61: 51–73.
Watson, A. M. 1983 Agricultural Innovation in the Early Islamic World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Whitcomb, D. 2011 “Qaysariyah as an early Islamic settlement.” In Shaping the Middle East: Jews, Christians, and Muslims in an Age of Transition, 400–800 CE, edited by K. G. Holum and H. Lapin, 65–82. Bethesda: University of Maryland Press.
Wilkinson, T. J. 2003 Archaeological Landscapes of the Near East. Tucson: The University of Arizona Press.
Yaalon, D. H. 1967 “Factors affecting the lithification of eolianite and interpretation of its environmental significance in the coastal plain of Israel.” Journal of Sedimentary Research 37(4): 1189–1199.
Zviely. D., E. Kit and M. Klein. 2007 “Longshore sand transport estimates along the Mediterranean coast of Israel in the Holocene.” Marine Geology 238(1–4): 61–73.
