The Unfulfilled Promise of Cross-Cultural, Interdisciplinary Ancient History


  • Ryan Nichols California State University



Ancient China, G.E.R. Lloyd, Ancient Greece, Interdisciplinary Research, Psychology


This commentary focuses on G.E.R. Lloyd’s latest work, Ambivalences of Rationality (2018). The book is summarized chapter by chapter. Criticisms are presented with special attention to Lloyd’s unusual wealth of research from developmental psychology, cross-cultural psychology, anthropology, experimental linguistics and cognitive science. The commentary concludes that Lloyd has done a disservice to cited researchers in the mind sciences who investigate cross-cultural differences.

Author Biography

  • Ryan Nichols, California State University

    Ryan Nichols is a professor of philosophy at California State Fullerton. Ryan’s interdisciplinary research is now focused on questions about the origins and maintenance of Chinese culture. In this area he writes about interactions between the physical ecology, culture, social psychology, emotion and cognition.


Blackburn, S. 2016. The Oxford Dictionary of Philosophy. Third edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bloom, A. H. 1979. “The Impact of Chinese Linguistic Structure on Cognitive Style.” Current Anthropology 20(3): 585–86.

Bloom, A. H. 1981. The Linguistic Shaping of Thought: A Study in the Impact of Language on Thinking in China and the West. Hillsdale, NJ: L. Erlbaum.

Boroditsky, L. 2001. “Does Language Shape Thought? Mandarin and English Speakers’ Conceptions of Time.” Cognitive Psychology 43(1): 1–22.

Chen, J.-Y. 2007. “Do Chinese and English Speakers Think about Time Differently? Failure of Replicating Boroditsky (2001).” Cognition 104(2): 427–36.

Friedman, M., H.-C. Chen and J. Vaid. 2006. “Proverb Preferences across Cultures: Dialecticality or Poeticality?” Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 13(2): 353–59.

Goody, J. 1977. The Domestication of the Savage Mind. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kelemen, D. 1999. “Why Are Rocks Pointy? Children’s Preference for Teleological Explanations of the Natural World.” Developmental Psychology 35(6): 1440–52.

Kelemen, D. 2004. “Are Children ‘Intuitive Theists’? Reasoning about Purpose and Design in Nature.” Psychological Science 15(5): 295–301.

Kelemen, D., and E. Rosset. 2009. “The Human Function Compunction: Teleological Explana­tion in Adults.” Cognition 111(1): 138–43.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 1996. Adversaries and Authorities: Investigations into Ancient Greek and Chinese Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 2005. The Delusions of Invulnerability: Wisdom and Morality in Ancient Greece, China, and Today. London: Duckworth.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 2007a. Ancient Worlds, Modern Reflections: Philosophical Perspectives on Greek and Chinese Science and Culture. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 2007b. Cognitive Variations: Reflections on the Unity and Diversity of the Human Mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 2011. Disciplines in the Making: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Elites, Learning, and Innovation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 2014. The Ideals of Inquiry: An Ancient History. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 2015. Analogical Investigations: Historical and Cross-cultural Perspectives on Human Reasoning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lloyd, G. E. R. 2018. The Ambivalences of Rationality: Ancient and Modern Cross-cultural Explorations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

McCauley, R. N. 2011. Why Religion Is Natural and Science Is Not. New York: Oxford University Press.

Mercier, H., J. Zhang, Y. Qu, P. Lu, and J.-B. Van der Henst. 2015. “Do Easterners and Westerners Treat Contradiction Differently?” Journal of Cognition and Culture 15(1–2): 45–63.

Nichols, R. 2021. “Cross-cultural Cognitive Variation: A Review of Evidence about Holistic Cognitive Style for the Sake of Improving Cultural Evolutionary Understanding.” Under review.

Nisbett, R. E. 2003. The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently – and Why. New York: Free Press.

Parry, J. 1985. “The Brahmanical Tradition and the Technology of the Intellect.” In Reason and Morality, ed. J. Overing, 200–225. London and New York: Tavistock Publications.

Peng, K., and R. E. Nisbett. 1999. “Culture, Dialectics, and Reasoning about Contradiction.” American Psychologist 54(9): 741–54.

Wellman, H. M., F. Fang, D. Liu, L. Zhu, and G. Liu 2006. “Scaling of Theory-of-mind Understandings in Chinese Children.” Psychological Science 17(12): 1075–81.

Yeh, D., and D. Gentner. 2005. “Reasoning Counterfactually in Chinese: Picking up the Pieces.” In Proceedings of the Twenty-seventh Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society, 2410–15. Permalink:





Discussion / 3

How to Cite

Nichols, R. . (2021). The Unfulfilled Promise of Cross-Cultural, Interdisciplinary Ancient History. Journal of Cognitive Historiography, 6(1-2), 180–190.