The Performance of Interreligious Dialogue in the Realm of International Relations
A Critical Reflection
Keywords:
Interreligious Dialogue, International Relations, Performance, Performativity, track 1.5 diplomacy, critical religion, International Conference on Cohesive Societies, KAICIID, G20 Interfaith Summit, Abraham AccordsAbstract
Interreligious Dialogue (IRD) is neither a simple concept, nor a simple practice. Even before we consider the issues of such things as the ethics, hermeneutics, and praxis of understanding across diverse worlds of meaning, it is something that is enacted and performed according to social, cultural, and political discourses. The agendas of participants, sponsors, and any supposed audience all have consequences for the performativity of IRD. This paper will specifically focus on the concept of performance in relation to IRD in the political sphere, most particularly the way that IRD has become part of international relations. Attention will be given to typologies and framings of IRD, including what does, or does not, get classed as being IRD, or “true” dialogue, but herein no definition is prescribed, taking a broad approach. We will look at some specific examples of IRD in relation to track 1.5 diplomacy, noting how it relates to a securitised framing of dialogue and to what Oddbjørn Leirvik has termed “necessary dialogue”. The whole paper will be framed within the concept of performance, or performativity, which will be the main analytical approach, but taking a wider critical religious studies approach to considering how IRD is performed, or operates, within international relations.References
Abdelnour, M. G. (2022) ‘Prophet Abraham: A Figure of Exclusivism or Ecumenism?, ’Interreligious Relations (Occasional Papers), no. 28, available at: https://www.rsis.edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/IRR-Issue-28-Jan-to-Mar-2022.pdf (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Abu-Nimer, M., and Nelson, R. K. (eds) (2021) Evaluating Interreligious Peacebuilding and Dialogue: Methods and Frameworks, Berlin, De Gruyter.
Adams, B. (2021) ‘Religious Engagement with the G20,’ in Steiner, S. and Christie, J. (eds), Religious Diplomacy and the United Nations: Religious Engagement as Loyal Opposition, Lanham, MA, Lexington Books, pp.201-12.
Admirand, P. (2020) ‘Atheist Critiques of the New Atheists: Advancing Atheist-Theist Dialogue, ’Interreligious Studies and Intercultural Theology, vol. 4 no.2, pp.176-200.
Anderson, B. (1983) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, London, Verso.
Austin, John. (1962) How to Do Things with Words, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
Barbato, M. P., Joustra, R. J., and Hoove, D. R. (eds) (2019) Modern Papal Diplomacy and Social Teaching in World Affairs, London and New York, NY: Routledge.
Barbarto, M. (2020a) ‘Postsecular Plurality in the Middle East: Expanding the Postsecular Approach to a Power Politics of Becoming, ’Religions, vol. 11.162, DOI: 10.3390/rel11040162.
Barbato, M. (ed.) (2020b) The Pope, the Public, and International Relations, Cham, Springer.
Barbato, M. (2018). Jain Approaches to Plurality: Identity as Dialogue, “Currents of Encounter” series, Leiden, Brill.
Barbato, M. (2017) ‘Diplomatic Language in the Deepavali Messages of the Pontifical Council for Interreligious Dialogue, ’The Review of Faith & International Affairs, vol. 15 no.4, pp.93-104.
Blée, F. (2014) ‘Can Christians Engage in Non-Christian Practices? Eastern Meditation and Contemplative Prayer,’ in Hedges, P.(ed.), Controversies in Contemporary Religion, vol. 3, Santa Barbara, CA, Praeger, pp.277–304.
Brodeur, P. (2021) ‘Interworldview Dialogue (IWVD): The Emergence of an Applied Theory for Conflict Transformation and Peacebuilding,’ in Redekop, Gloria Neufeld and Redkop, Vern Neufelf (eds), Transforming: Applying Spirituality, Emergent Creativity, and Reconciliation, Lanham, MA, Lexington Books, pp.137-61.
Brodeur, P. (2005) ‘From the margins to the centres of power: The increasing relevance of the global interfaith movement, ’Cross Currents, vol. 55 no. 1, pp.42-53.
Butler, J. (1990) Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity, New York, NY, Routledge.
Butler, J. (2015) Notes toward a Performative Theory of Assembly, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press.
Butler, J. (2018) ‘Gender Performativity’ (video), Open Culture, available from: www.openculture.com/2018/02/judith-butler-on-gender-performativity.html. (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Chia, J. M-T. (2022), ‘Buddhist Diplomacy: Potential for Regional Cohesion, ’RSIS Commentary No. 22046, available at: https://www.rsis.edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/CO22046.pdf. (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Chia, E. K-F. (2018), World Christianity Encounters World Religions: A Summa of Interfaith Dialogue, Collegeville, MN, Liturgical Press Academic.
Cornille, C. (2012) ‘Meaning and Truth in the Dialogue between Religions,’ in Depoortere, F. and Lambkin, M. (eds), The Question of Theological Truth. Philosophical and Interreligious Perspectives, Amsterdam, Rodopi, pp.137-156.
Cotter, C. and Robertson, D.(eds). (2016), After World Religions: Reconstructing Religious Studies, New York, NY, Routledge.
Dalton, K. (2014) ‘Abrahamic Religions: On Uses and Abuses of History by Aaron W. Hughes, Oxford University Press: New York, 2012, ’Religion, vol.44, no. 4, pp.684-686.
Driscoll, C. and Miller, M. (2019) Method as Identity: Manufacturing Distance in the Academic Study of Religion, Lanham, MD: Lexington.
Egnell, H. (2006) Other Voices: A Study of Feminist Approaches to Religious Plurality East and West, Uppsala: Studia Missionalia Svecana.
Fahy, J. and Haynes, J. (2018) ‘Introduction: Interfaith on the World Stage,’ The Review of Faith & International Affairs, vol. 16, no.3, pp.1-8.
Fitzgerald, T. (2011) Religion and Politics in International Relations: the Modern Myth, London: Continuum.
Fox, J. and Sandler, S. (eds) (2004) Bringing Religion into International Relations, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Goldenberg, N. (2013) ‘Theorizing Religions as Vestigial States in Relation to Gender and Law: Three Cases, ’Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion, vol. 29, no.1, pp.39-52
Gopin, M. (2009) To Make the Earth Whole: The Art of Citizen Diplomacy in an Age of Religious Militancy, Lanham, Md: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
Gregson, N, and Rose, G. (2000) ‘Taking Butler Elsewhere: Performativities, Spatialities and Subjectivities, ’Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, vol. 184, pp.433–452.
Grung, A. H. (2017) ‘Interreligious Dialogue in the Squeeze between Diplomacy and Contextual Practices,’ The Journal of Interreligious Studies, vol. 9, pp.37-44. Available at: http://irstudies.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Grung.Interreligious-Dialogue-in-the-.Squeeze-between-Diplomacy-and-Contextual-Practices.pdf. (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Gusha, I. S. (2022) ‘KAICIID: An Emerging Significant Player in Global Interfaith and Development Initiatives,’ in, Citando, E. and Gusha, I. S. (eds), Interfaith Networks and Development, Cham: Springer, pp. 80-96.
Guzansky, Y and Marshall, Z. A. (2020) ‘The Abraham Accords: Immediate Significance and Long-Term Implications,’ Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs, vol.14, no. 3, pp.379-389.
Habermas, J. (2017 [2012]) Postmetaphysical Thinking II, trans. Ciaran Cronim, Cambridge: Polity Press.
Halafoff, A. (2013) The Multifaith Movement: Global Risks and Cosmopolitan Solutions, New York, NY: Springer.
Hasan, M. (2013). ‘Religion and Politics in International Relations: The Modern Myth,’ Politics, Religion & Ideology, vol. 14, no. 1,pp.161-162,
Hassan, R. (2014) ‘Engaging in Interreligious Dialogue: Recollections and Reflections of a Muslim Woman,’ Journal of Ecumenical Studies, vol.49, no.1, pp.134–139.
Haynes, J. (2013) An Introduction to International Relations and Religion, London: Routledge.
Hedges, P. (2023) ‘Is Interreligious Dialogue in International Relations “Dialogue-Washing” for Authoritarian Regimes? An Exploration of KAICIID and ICCS as Track 1.5 Diplomacy,’ The Review of Faith and International Affairs, vol.21, no.2, pp. 67-82, DOI: 10.1080/15570274.2023.2200276.
Hedges, P. (2022a) ‘Why the Theology Without Walls Program Fails Both as Scholarship and a Resource to the SBNR: A Friendly Condemnation,’ Journal of Interreligious Studies, vol. 34, pp.18-33.
Hedges, P. (2022b) ‘Theology With and Without (W&W) Walls, Scholarship W&W Walls, and Decolonization W&W Walls: A Rejoinder to Rory D. McEntee,’ Journal of Interreligious Studies, vol.35, pp.80-99.
Hedges, P. (2022d) ‘Reflection: Rethinking the Possibility and Meaning of Dialogue in a Globalised and Religiously Diverse World: A Mid-Covid Perspective from Southeast Asia,’ Journal of Dialogue Studies, no. 9, pp. 228-35.
Hedges, P. (2021a) Understanding Religion: Theories and Methods for Studying Religiously Diverse Societies, Oakland, CA: University of California Press.
Hedges, P. (2021b) Religious Hatred: Prejudice, Islamophobia and Antisemitism in Global Context, London: Bloomsbury.
Hedges, P. (2020a) ‘Conceptualising Social Cohesion in Relation to Religious Diversity: Sketching a Pathway in a Globalised World,’ Interreligious Relations, no.16, https://www.rsis.edu.sg/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/IRR-Issue-16-May-2020.pdf. (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Hedges, P. (2020b) ‘Decolonizing Interreligious Studies,’ in Gustaffson, H. (ed.), Interreligious Studies: Dispatches From an Emerging Field, Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, pp. 164-70.
Hedges, P. (2019) ‘The Secular Realm as Interfaith Space: Discourse and Practice in Contemporary Multicultural Nation-States,’ Religions, issue 10.9.498. Available at: https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/10/9/498/htm. (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Hedges, Paul. (2018a) ‘Anglican Interfaith Relations from 1910 to the C21st,’ in Strong, R. (ed.), The Oxford History of Anglicanism, Vol. 5: “The C20th”, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.76-97.
Hedges, P. (2018b) ‘Can Interreligious Dialogue Provide a New Space for Deliberative Democracy in the Public Sphere?: Philosophical Perspectives from the Examples of the UK and Singapore,’ Interreligious Studies and Intercultural Theology, vol.2, no. .1, pp.: 5-25.
Hedges, P. (2018c) ‘Encounters with Ultimacy?: Autobiographical and Critical Perspectives in the Academic Study of Religion,’ Open Theology, vol. 4, no. 1, , pp. 355-372.
Hedges, P. (2017a) ‘Should Interfaith and Interreligious Dialogue include Atheists? Towards an Interworldview Perspective,’ Interreligious Insight, vol.15, no.1, pp.38-47.
Hedges, P. (2017b) Towards Better Disagreement: Religion and Atheism in Dialogue, London: Jessica Kingsley.
Hedges, P. (2017c). ‘Multiple Religious Belonging after Religion: Theorising Strategic Religious Participation in a Shared Religious Landscape as a Chinese Model, Open Theology, Vol. 3 no. 1, pp. 48–72.
Hedges, P. (2010) Controversies in Interreligious Dialogue and the Theology of Religions, London: SCM.
Hedges, P. and Liu, Y. (2022) ‘Interreligious Studies and Law: Decolonizing Freedom of Religion and Belief,’ in Mosher, L.(ed.), The Georgetown Companion to Interreligious Studies, Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press, pp.99-107.
Hedges, P. and Mohamed Taib, M. I. (2019) ‘The Interfaith Movement in Singapore: Precarious Toleration and Embedded Autonomy,’ in Fahy, J. and Bock, J. J. (eds), The Interfaith Movement: Mobilising Religious Diversity in the 21st Century. London and New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 139-56.
ICCS. (2022) ICCS website, www.iccs.sg. (Accessed 23 June 2022).
Ipgrave, Julia. (2019) ‘A Peace and Reconciliation Centre in London’s Financial District,’ in Ipgrave, J. (ed.), Interreligious Engagement in Urban Spaces, Cham: Palgrave-Macmillan, pp.127-36.
Jeong, H. W. (2021).‘The Abraham Accords and Religious Tolerance: Three Tales of Faith-Based Foreign-Policy Agenda Setting,’ Middle East Policy, vol. 28 no. 1, pp. 36-50.
Johnston, D. and Sampson, C. (eds) (1994) Religion, the Missing Dimension of Statecraft, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Jones, P. (2022) ‘Pagans and Dialogue: Pagans in Interreligious and Interconvictional Dialogue,’ Journal of Dialogue Studies vol. 10, pp.144-65.
Jurgensmeyer, M. (ed.) (2005) Religion in Global Civil Society, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
KAICCID. N.D. (2021) ‘The Advisory Forum,’ https://www.kaiciid.org/advisoryforum. (Accessed 31 August 2021.)
Keane, J. (2001) ‘Global Civil Society?,’ in Anheier, H., Glasius, M., and Kaldor, M. (eds), Global Civil Society, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.23-47.
King, U. (1998) ‘Feminism: The Missing Dimension in the Dialogue of Religions,’ in May, J. D. (ed.), Pluralism and the Religions: The Theological and Political Dimensions, London: Cassell, pp.40-55.
Leirvik, O. (2014) Interreligious Studies: A Relational Approach to Religious Activism and the Study of Religion, London: Bloomsbury.
Levenson, J. (2012) Inheriting Abraham: The Legacy of the Patriarch in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Lincoln B. (2005) ‘Theses on Method,’ Method and Theory in the Study of Religion, vol.17, no.1, pp. 8–10.
McCarthy, K. 2018. ‘(Inter)Religious Studies: Making a Home in the Secular Academy,’ in Patel, E., Peace, J. H,, and Silverman, N. (eds), Interreligious/Interfaith Studies: Defining a New Field, Boston: Beacon Press.
McEntee, R. (2022) ‘Theology Without Walls’s Potential as Decolonial & Democratic Praxis: A Response,’ Journal of Interreligious Studies, no.34, pp.34-65.
McLarren, K. and Stahl, B.(2020) ‘The Holy See as Hybrid Actor: Religion in International, Transnational, and World Society,’ in Barbato, M. (ed.), The Pope, the Public, and International Relations: Postsecular Transformations, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 189-201.
Magid, J. (2022) ‘Blinken: Saudi Arabia is a “critical partner” in expanding Abraham Accords,’ The Times of Israel (3 June 2022). Available at: https://www.timesofisrael.com/blinken-saudi-arabia-is-a-critical-partner-in-expanding-abraham-accords/. (Accessed 9 June 2022).
Malik, J. (2013) ‘Integration of Muslim Migrants and the Politics of Dialogue: The Case of Modern Germany,’ Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, vol.33, no. 4, pp.495-506.
Mandal, A. and Pattni, R. (2022) ‘Hindus and Dialogue: Implications of using Dialogic Structure in Expressing Philosophy,’ Journal of Dialogue Studies. Vol. 10, pp. 80-103.
Masters, C. (2009) ‘Judith Butler,’ in Edkins, J. and Vaughan-Williams, N. (eds), Critical Theorists and International Relations, London: Routledge, pp.114-24.
Mavelli, L. and Petito, F. (2012) ‘The postsecular in International Relations: an overview,’ Review of International Studies, vol. 38, pp. 931-42.
Merdjanova, I. and Brodeur, P. (2009) Religion as a Conversation Starter: Interreligious Dialogue for Peacebuilding in the Balkans 1990-2008, London: Continuum Press.
Miller, D. (2020) ‘A Modest Reply to Timothy Fitzgerald,’ Method & Theory in the Study of Religion, vol. 32, no. 4-5, pp.423-433.
Miller, D. (2014) ‘The politics of religious repetition: The depoliticization of genealogical critique,’ Method and Theory in the Study of Religion, vol.26, no.3, pp.287-307.
Millet, R. (2013) ‘The Mormon–Evangelical Dialogue,’ in Cornille, C. (ed), The Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Inter-Religious Dialogue, Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, pp.468-478.
Mohamed Taib, M. I. (2016) ‘“Nones” in Inter-faith Dialogue: The Case for Inclusion,’ IPS Commons (November 1, 2016). Available at: https://ipscommons.sg/nones-in-inter-faith-dialogue-the-case-for-inclusion/. Accessed 24 July 2022.
Mohamed, K. (2015) ‘Interreligious Dialogue as Lay, Institutional, and Academic: Muslim Perspectives,’ in Hedges, P. (ed.), Contemporary Muslim-Christian Encounters: Developments, Diversity and Dialogues, London: Bloomsbury, pp.51–66.
Moyaert, M. (2020) ‘The Scholar, the Theologian, and the Activist,’ in Gustafson, H. (ed.), Interreligious Studies: Dispatches from a Field, Waco: Baylor University Press, pp.34–42,
Moyaert, M. (2014) ‘Inappropriate Behavior? On the Ritual Core of Religion and its Challenges to Interreligious Hospitality,’ Journal for the Academic Study of Religion, vol.27, no.2, pp.222-42.
Moyaert, M. (2013) ‘Interreligious Dialogue,’ in Cheetham, D., Pratt, D, and Thomas, D. (eds), Understanding Interreligious Relations, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.193-217.
Muslim World League (MWL). (2022) ‘World faith leaders convene in Saudi Arabia for first time in ground-breaking conference to build bridges with Muslim leaders,’ PR Newswire, available at: https://www.prnewswire.com/ae/news-releases/world-faith-leaders-convene-in-saudi-arabia-for-first-time-in-ground-breaking-conference-to-build-bridges-with-muslim-leaders-301547147.html (Accessed 9 June 2022).
Owen, M. and King, A.. (2019) ‘Enhancing the Efficacy of Religious Peacebuilding Practice: An Exploratory Evidence-Based Framework for Assessing Dominant Risks in Religious Peacebuilding,’ Religions, No. 10.12, 641, available at: https://doi.org/10.3390/rel10120641 (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Özervarli, M. S. (2017) ‘Between tension and rapprochement: Sunni-Shi'ite relations in the pre-modern Ottoman period, with a focus on the eighteenth century,’ Historical Research, vol.90, no.249, pp.526–542.
Petito, F. and Hatzopoulos, P. (2003) Religion in International Relations: The Return from Exile, New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.
R20. (n.d.). ‘R20 Becomes a Recurring Agenda: 2022 in Indonesia, 2023 in India,’ https://r20-indonesia.org/en/news_media/news/detail/r20-becomes-a-recurring-agenda.html (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Race, A. (2008) ‘Interfaith Dialogue: Religious Accountability between Strangeness and Resonance,’ in Hedges, P. and Race, A. (ed), Christian Approaches to Other Faiths, London: SCM, pp. 155-72.
Race, A. and Hawkins, W. (eds). (2022) Unutterable Joy: An anthology of writing from The World Congress of Faiths towards interreligious dialogue and understanding, London: World Congress of Faiths.
Schilbrack, K. (2017) ‘A Realist Social Ontology of Religion,’ Religion, vol.47, no. .2, pp.161–78.
Sheikh, M. K. (2012) ‘How does religion matter? Pathways to Religion in International Relations,’ Review of International Studies, vol.38, pp.365-392.
Smith, J. Z. (1998) ‘Religion, Religions, Religious,’ in Taylor, M. C. (ed.), Critical Terms for Religious Studies, Chicago, Il: Chicago University Press, pp.269–84.
Smith, Wilfred Cantwell. (1978 [1962]) The Meaning and End of Religion, London: SPCK.
Steiner, S. (2019) ‘Transnational Interfaith Diplomacy: The Interfaith G8/G20 Shadow Summits,’ in Fahy, J. and Bock, J-J. (eds), The Interfaith Movement: Mobilising Religious Diversity in the 21st Century. London and New York, NY: Routledge, pp. 198-218.
Steiner, S. (2018) Moral Pressure for Responsible Globalization: Religious Diplomacy in the Age of the Anthropocene, Leiden: Brill.
Steiner, S. and Christie, J. D. (eds). (2021) Religious Soft Diplomacy and the United Nations: Religious Engagement as Loyal Opposition, Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
Taira, T. (2017) ‘Categorizing “Religion”: From Case Studies to Methodology,’ Implicit Religion, vol.20, no.4, pp.377-84.
Tambiah, S. (1979) ‘A Performative Approach to Ritual: Radcliffe-Brown Lecture,’ Proceedings of the British Academy, no.65, pp.113–69.
Tamir, C., Connaughton, A. and Salazar, A. M. (2020) ‘The Global God Divide,’ Pew Research Centre (20 July 2020), available at: https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2020/07/20/the-global-god-divide/ (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Weisse, W. and Meir, E. (2022) ‘Dialogical Theology and Dialogical Practice,’ Scriptura: Journal for Biblical, Theological and Contextual Hermeneutics, vol.121, no.1, pp.1-16.
Welle, J. (2013) ‘The Evolution of the Assisi Gathering: To Humanism and Beyond?,’ Journal of Ecumenical Studies, vol.48, no.3, pp.377-90.
Wilson, R. B. (2015) ‘The Nexus Between U.S. Foreign Policy and Conflict Resolution or Protraction: The Case of North Korea,’ George Mason University unpublished PhD thesis. Available at: http://ebot.gmu.edu/handle/1920/9863. (Accessed 17 April 2023).
Woolf Centre. (N.D.) ‘Measures of Success: Evaluating the Impact of Interfaith Dialogue,’ Available at: https://www.woolf.cam.ac.uk/research/projects/measures-of-success-evaluating-the-impact-of-interfaith-dialogue (Accessed 9 June 2022).
Young, S. (2016) ‘Judith Butler: Performativity,’ Critical Legal Thinking (14 November), http://criticallegalthinking.com/2016/11/14/judith-butlers-performativity/#fnref- (Accessed 17 April 2023).
