Convergence and Asymmetry

Observations on the Current State of Jewish-Christian Dialogue


  • Alana M. Vincent University of Chester



Jewish-Christian dialogue, Messianic Judaism, supersessionism


Drawing on a survey of forty-five statements on the status of JewishChristian dialogue, this article argues that the theme of convergence which underlies a substantial portion of this dialogue programme arises from an asymmetric power relationship, in which Christian institutions have been insufficiently attentive to the issue of Jewish self-understanding.

Author Biography

Alana M. Vincent, University of Chester

Alana M. Vincent is Associate Professor of Jewish Philosophy, Religion and Imagination at the University of Chester. In addition to her work on Jewish-Christian dialogue, she specializes in modern Jewish religious practice, Holocaust memory, and religion and literature. She is active in local interfaith outreach and CCJ (UK), and is currently serving a term as the president of the International Society for Religion, Literature and Culture.


Alderman, Geoffrey. 1990. The British Chief Rabbinate: A Most Peculiar Practice. European Judaism 23.2: 45-58.

Ariel, Yaakov. 2012. A Different Kind of Dialogue? Messianic Judaism and Jewish-Christian Relations. Crosscurrents 62.3: 318-327. DOI:

Atlan, Henri. 2009. Chosen People. In 20th Century Jewish Religious Thought: Original Essays on Critical Concepts, Movements, and Beliefs, ed. Arthur Allen Cohen and Paul Mendes-Flohr, 55–60. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society.

Barnes, Michael. 2020. Waiting on Grace: A Theology of Dialogue. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI:

Batnitzky, Leora. 2011. How Judaism Became a Religion. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. DOI:

Biale, David. 2002. Preface to Cultures of the Jews: A New History, ed. David Biale. New York: Schocken Books.

Blackburn, Anne M. 2011. The Text and the World. In The Cambridge Companion to Religious Studies, ed. Robert A. Orsi, 151–67. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI:

Burkeman, Danny. 2004. Why are there so few Jewish statements on Christianity or Jewish-Christian Relations? European Judaism 37.1: 111-123. DOI:

Catane, Yaron. 2020. Jewish-Christian Relations and Modern Developments: the Role of the Chief Rabbinate in Interreligious Dialogue. In Jews in Dialogue: Jewish Responses to the Challenges of Multicultural Contemporaneity, ed. Magdalena Dziaczkowska and Adele Valeria Messina, 102–40. Leiden, Brill. DOI:

Center for Jewish–Christian Understanding and Cooperation [CJCUC]. 2015. To Do the Will of Our Father in Heaven: Toward a Partnership Between Jews and Christians. 31 December. (accessed 9 August 2020).

Central Conference of American Rabbis [CCAR]. 1885. Declaration of Principles/The Pittsburgh Platform. (accessed 10 August 2020).

Commission for Religious Relations with Jews [CRRJ]. 2015. “The Gifts and the Calling of God are Irrevocable” (Romans 11:29): A Reflection on Theological Questions Pertaining to Catholic-Jewish Relations on the Occasion of the 50th Anniversary of “Nostra Aetate” (No. 4). The Holy See.

Commission on Faith and Order of the World Council of Churches. 1967. The Church and the Jewish People. 9 August. (accessed 9 August 2020).

Community of Protestant Churches in Europe. 2001. Church and Israel.

Cook, Michelle. 2003. Justice, Jesus, and the Jews: A Proposal for Jewish-Christian Relations. Liturgical Press.

D’Costa, Gavin. 2017a. Review of Searching Her Own Mystery: Nostra Aetate, the Jewish People, and the Identity of the Church by Mark S. Kinzer. Nova et Vetera 15.3: 941–5. DOI:

---. 2017b. Supersessionism: Harsh, Mild or Gone for Good? European Judaism 50.1: 99-107. DOI:

---. 2018a. Developing the Conversation: A Divine Messiah and a Catholic Zionism. Pro Ecclesia 27.4: 437-443. DOI:

---. 2018b. The Mystery of Israel: Jews, Hebrew Catholics, Messianic Judaism, the Catholic Church, and the Mosaic Ceremonial Laws. Nova et Vetera 16.3: 939-977. DOI:

---. 2019. Catholic Doctrines on the Jewish People After Vatican II. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Effron, John M. 2016. German Jewry and the Allure of the Sephardic. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. DOI:

Eisen, Arnold M. !983. The Chosen People in America: A Study in Jewish Religious Ideology. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

Faith and Order Commission [of the Church of England; FOC]. 2019. God’s Unfailing Word: Theological and Practical Perspectives on Christian–Jewish Relations. London: The Archbishops’ Council.

Fitzgerald, Timothy. 2000. The Ideology of Religious Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Frank, Daniel H., ed. 1993. A People Apart: Chosenness and Ritual in Jewish Philosophical Thought. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.

Freud-Kandel, Miri. 2015. The British Chief Rabbinate: A Model for Leadership or Decline? Modern Judaism 25.2: 119-133. DOI:

Gurkan, Leyla. 2009. The Jews as a Chosen People: Tradition and Transformation. London: Routledge. DOI:

Hartman, Donniel. 2007. The Boundaries of Judaism. London: Continuum.

Harvey, Graham. 2013. Food, Sex and Strangers: Understanding Religion as Everyday Life. London: Routledge.

Imhoff, Sarah, and Hillary Kaell. 2017. Lineage Matters: DNA, Race, and Gene Talk in Judaism and Messianic Judaism. Religion and American Culture 27.1: 95-127. DOI:

Inter Faith Consultative Group of the Archbishops’ Council [Church of England]. 2001. Sharing One Hope?: The Church of England and Christian-Jewish Relations. London: The Archbishops’ Council.

International Council of Christians and Jews [ICCJ]. 1947. An Address to the Churches. Seelisburg (Switzerland) 1947. (accessed 9 August 2020).

Kaell, Hillary. 2015. Born-again seeking: explaining the gentile majority in messianic Judaism. Religion 45.1: 42-65. DOI:

---. 2020. “Semi-Public Hints of Jewish Lineage in Messianic Judaism. Ethnos, DOI: 10.1080/00141844.2020.1745862 DOI:

Kellenbach, Katharina von. 2020. Guilt and the Transformation of Christian-Jewish Relations. Studies in Christian-Jewish Relations 15.1: 1-21. DOI:

Kessler, Edward. 2002. Understanding Christianity Today—Jewish Perspectives: Dabru Emet: A Jewish Statement About Christianity. Reviews in Religion and Theology 9.5: 479-487. DOI:

Kinzer, Mark S. 2015. Searching Her Own Mystery: Nostra Aetate, the Jewish People, and the Identity of the Church. Eugene, OR: Cascade Books.

Kollontai, Pauline. 2004. Messianic Jews and Jewish Identity. Journal of Modern Jewish Studies 3.2: 195-205. DOI:

Krell, Marc A. 2003. Intersecting Pathways: Modern Jewish Theologians in Conversation with Christianity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Leuenberg Church Fellowship. 2001. Church and Israel: A Contribution from the Reformation Churches in Europe to the Relationship between Christians and Jews. 23 June. (accessed 9 August 2020).

Masuzawa, Tomoko. 2005. The Invention of World Religions: or, How European Universalism was Preserved in the Language of Pluralism. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. DOI:

Meyer, Michael. 1995. Response to Modernity: A History of the Reform Movement in Judaism. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.

Moran, Gabriel. 2008. Uniqueness: Problem or Paradox in Jewish and Christian Traditions. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock.

National Jewish Scholars Project [NJSP]. 2000. Dabru Emet: A Jewish Statement on Christians and Christianity. Baltimore: Institute for Christian and Jewish Studies. (accessed 9 August 2020).

Owen, Suzanne. 2011. The World Religions Paradigm: Time for a change. Arts and Humanities in Higher Education10.3: 253-268. DOI:

Persoff, Meir. 2008. Faith Against Reason: Religious Reform and the British Chief Rabbinate, 1840-1990. Edgware: Valentine Mitchell.

Rosen, David. 2012. Orthodox Judaism and Jewish-Christian Dialogue. (accessed 2 May 2016).

Rutishauser, Christian. 2007. The 1947 Seelisberg Conference: The Foundation of the Jewish-Christian Dialogue. Studies in Christian-Jewish Relations 2.2: 34-53. DOI:

Shapiro, Faydra. 2012. Jesus for Jews: The Unique Problem of Messianic Judaism. The Journal of Religion and Society14: 1-17.

Simpson, William W., and Ruth Weyl. [2009.] The Story of the International Council of Christians and Jews. (accessed 4 May 2020).

Second Vatican Council. 1965. Declaration on the Relation of the Church to Non-Christians: Nostra Aetate. The Holy See. (accessed 9 August 2020).

Signer, Michael. 2003. Dabru Emet: A Contextual Analysis. Théologiques 11.1-2: 187-202. DOI:

Soloveitchik, Joseph. 1964. Confrontation. Tradition: A Journal of Orthodox Thought 6.2, 5–28.



How to Cite

Vincent, A. M. (2020). Convergence and Asymmetry: Observations on the Current State of Jewish-Christian Dialogue. Interreligious Studies and Intercultural Theology, 4(2), 201–223.