21st Century Evangelists?


  • Dorothy Grosvenor Napier University



caring, feminist, gender, nurse, religious, spiritual, suffering


This article discusses the outcomes of a doctoral study into why nurses are asked to give spiritual care to patients. Tensions between bodily nursing care and spiritual care were explored in semi-structured interviews with eighteen experienced nurses. Interview materials were interpreted within feminist frameworks of caring and spiritualities as patriarchal constructions rooted in Christianities. Themes of nursing care described as spiritual demonstrated that body/spirit dualisms persisted despite secularisms. However, since spiritual care remained a confused and nebulous concept, how the addition of spiritual care by nurses will remedy the stresses and distressed described in the study is questioned.

Author Biography

Dorothy Grosvenor, Napier University

Dorothy Grosvenor is lecturer in the School of Acute and Continuing Care Nursing, Napier University, Edinburgh.


BORDO S. 1993 Unbearable weight: Feminism, Western culture and the body, University of California Press, Berkeley.

BRADSHAW A. 1994 Lighting the lamp: the spiritual dimension of nursing care, Scutari, London.

CAMBELL A. GILLETT G. & JONES G. 2001 Medical Ethics (3rd ed.), Oxford University Press, Oxford.

CHRIST C. Why women need the goddess Phenomenological, Psychological and Political reflections, In Womanspirit Rising, CHRIST C.P. &
PLASKOW J. (eds.) 1979, Harper & Ross. San Francisco, pp. 73-87.

COUTTS F. 2001 Editorial, Scottish Journal of Healthcare Chaplaincy, 2: 1:1.

DALY M. 1973 Beyond God the Father, Beacon Press, Boston.

DOYLE D. 1996 in DOWNIE R. and RANDELL R. (eds.) Palliative Care Ethics, Oxford University Press, Oxford, viii.

FAWCETT T. & NOBLE A. 2004 The challenge of spiritual care in a multi-faith society experienced as a Christian nurse, Journal of Clinical Nursing 13 2 136-142.

GERSTEL N. & GALLAGHER S. 2001 Men’s Category Gender and the contingent Character of Care, Gender and Society 15 2 197-217.

GRAHAM H 2000 Socio-economic Change and Inequalities in Men‘s and Women’s health in the UK, In Gender Inequalities in Health, Graham H. (ed.) Buckingham, Open University Press, Milton Keynes.

GROSVENOR D. (2005) Care matters: spiritual care by nurses from feminist perspectives. Unpublished doctoral thesis, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.

HAMPSON D. 1990 Theology and Feminism, Blackwell, Oxford.

HAMPSON D. 1996 On Autonomy and Heteronomy in Hampson D. (ed.) Swallowing a Fishbone, SPCK, London.

HEELAS P. 2005 The Spiritual Revolution, Blackwell, Oxford.

HOCHSCHILD A. 1983 The Managed Heart, Commercialisation of Human Feeling, University of California, Berkeley.

KING U. 1997 Spirituality in HINNELS J. (ed.) A New Handbook of Living Religions, Blackwell, Oxford pp. 667-81.

JANTZEN G. 1995 Power, Gender and Christian Mysticism Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

LAWER J. 1991 Behind the Screens: Nursing, Somology, and the Problem of the Body, Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh.

LEONARD D. & SPEAKMAN M. 1986 ‘Women in the Family: Companions or Caretakers?’ In V. BEECHING & E. WHITELEGG (eds.) Women in Britain Today, Open University Press, London.

LISTER R. 1997 Citizenship: Feminist Perspective, McMillan. London

MACE G. 1999 Five Images that Open Minds, The Guardian, p.5.

NURSING and MIDWIFERY COUNCIL 2004 Code of Professional Conduct, London, NMC.

PATEMAN C. 1988 The Sexual Contract. Stanford, Stanford University Press.

ROSS L. 1997 Nurses’ Perceptions of Spiritual Care, Avebury, Hants

SAVAGE J. 1995 Nursing Intimacy: An Ethnographic Approach to Nurse- Patient Interaction, Scutari, London.

SMITH P. 1992 The Emotional Labour of Nursing, How nurses care, Macmillan, London.

STOLL R. 1979 Guidelines for Spiritual Assessment American, Journal of Nursing 79 1574-1577.

SYDIE R. 1987 Natural Women, Cultured Men, a feminist perspective on sociological theory, Open University Press, Buckingham.

TURNER B.S 1996 The Body & Society (2nd ed.) SAGE, London, p.148.

TSCHUDIN V. 2003 Ethics in ‘nursing’ The Caring Relationship (3rd ed.) Butterworth Heinemann, London.

WALBY S. 1990 Theorising Patriarchy, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.

WHEEN F. 2004 How Mumbo-Jumbo Conquered The World A Short History of Modern Delusion, Harper Collins, London. p. 193.



How to Cite

Grosvenor, D. (2013). Nurses: 21st Century Evangelists?. Health and Social Care Chaplaincy, 3–8.