The theological vindication of resistance against enforced motherhood
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/bar.28201Keywords:
voluntary motherhood, abortion, pregnancy, autonomy, suffragistsAbstract
For the suffragists of the 19th century, women’s enfranchisement was a central goal. Yet the right to vote was not nearly as vital to the suffragists as the right to one’s own bodily freedom. Furthermore, as they saw it, bodily autonomy was a ‘sacred’ right: it was grounded theologically. Most concerning to the suffragists were the ways in which women of their time were forced against their will
to become mothers. This article presents the suffragists’ theological grounds for resisting enforced motherhood. As I argue, doing so serves three purposes. First, it helps pro-choice Christians understand the ways in which their faith might support the defense of abortion access. Second, it foregrounds the political theological insights of the all too often overlooked suffragists. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, it gives the lie to a widespread mischaracterization of the suffragists as would-be advocates of the contemporary anti-abortion movement.
References
Alter, C. (2023a) Police arrest suspect for rape of 13-year-old who was unable to get an abortion. Time, September 7.
Alter, C. (2023b) She wasn’t able to get an abortion. Now she’s a mom. Soon she’ll start 7th grade. Time, August 14.
Anon (1868) Editorial: Infanticide. Revolution, August 6, p. 74.
Anon (1870) When is it not murder to take life? Woodhull & Claflin’s Weekly, October 8, p. 11.
Anon (2022) Ohio Attorney General on lack of investigation into alleged child rapist: ‘not a whisper.’ Fox News, July 11.
Anthony, S. B., Gage, M. J., and Stanton, E. C. (eds) (1881) History of Woman Suffrage, Volume 1. New York: Charles Mann.
Bachiochi, E. (2021) The Rights of Women: Reclaiming a Lost Vision. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
Basile, K. C., Breiding, M. J., and Smith, S. G. (2016) Disability and risk of recent sexual violence in the United States. American Journal of Public Health 106(5): 928–33. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2015.303004
Basile, K. C., Smith, S. G., Liu, Y., Kresnow, M., Fasula, A. M., Gilbert, L., and Chen, J. (2018) Rape-related pregnancy and association with reproductive coercion in the U.S. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 55(6): 770–6. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amepre.2018.07.028
Belluck, P. (2022) They had miscarriages, and new abortion laws obstructed treatment. New York Times, July 17.
Belluck, P. (2023) Religious freedom arguments underpin wave of challenges to abortion bans. New York Times, June 28.
Bennett, J., and Chambers, V. (2020) Suffrage isn’t ‘boring history.’ It’s a story of political geniuses. New York Times, July 10.
Bridgewater, P. (2001) Un/re/dis covering slave breeding in thirteenth amendment jurisprudence. Washington and Lee Journal of Civil Rights and Social Justice 7(1): 11–43.
Clark, E. B. (1988) Self-ownership and the political theory of Elizabeth Cady Stanton. Connecticut Law Review 21(4): 905–42.
Conspirator (1868) Child murder. Revolution, April 9, p. 217.
Corbin, C. M. (2023) Religious liberty for all? A religious right to abortion. Wisconsin Law Review 2: 475–511.
Dam, A. V. (2021) Less than 1% of rapes lead to felony convictions. At least 89% of victims face emotional and physical consequences. Washington Post, September 28.
Davis, D. H. (2000) Six religious dimensions of the Declaration of Independence. In Religion and the Continental Congress, 1774–1789: Contributions to Original Intent 95–116. Religion in America Series. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780195133554.003.0006
Decker, T. (2022) 10-year-old rape victim: Ohio politicians dismiss girl’s trauma. Columbus Dispatch, July 17.
Derr, M. K., MacNair, R., and Naranjo-Huebl, L. (eds) (2005) Prolife Feminism: Yesterday and Today (expanded 2nd edn). Kansas City: Feminism and Nonviolence Studies Association.
Donovan-Smith, O. (2019) A GOP lawmaker used the phrase ‘consensual rape’ during abortion debate. He says he misspoke. Washington Post, May 18.
Edwards, E. (2019) States pushing abortion bans have highest infant mortality rates. NBC News, May 24.
Edwards, J. (2022) Ohio lawmaker calls pregnancies from rape an ‘opportunity’ for victims. Washington Post, April 29.
Eligon, J., and Schwirtz, M. (2012) Senate candidate provokes ire with ‘legitimate rape’ comment. New York Times, August 20.
Gage, M. J. (1868) Is woman her own? Revolution, April 9, pp. 215–16.
Gilman, C. P. (2009) Herland. In D. D. Knight (ed.) The Yellow Wall-Paper, Herland, and Selected Writings. New York: Penguin Books.
Goldberg, M. (2022) A 10-year-old endures the predictable result of an abortion ban. New York Times, July 14.
Goodwin, M. (2022) No, Justice Alito, reproductive justice is in the Constitution. New York Times, June 26.
Gordon, L. (2002) The Moral Property of Women: A History of Birth Control Politics in America (3rd edn). Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
Grimké, S. (1977) Marriage. In G. Lerner (ed.) The Female Experience: An American Documentary 87–97. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill.
Harris, R. (2023) Let the Church arise! Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=288070227232166
Hasday, J. (2000) Contest and consent: a legal history of marital rape. California Law Review 88(5): 1373–505. https://doi.org/10.2307/3481263
Hughes, D. (2012) We’re Not That Susan B. Anthony! Retrieved September 12, 2023, from https://susanb.org/were-not-that-susan-b-anthony
Isenberg, N. (1998) Sex and Citizenship in Antebellum America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Jones, J. S., Alexander, C., Wynn, B. N., Rossman, L., and Dunnuck, C. (2009) Why women don’t report sexual assault to the police: the influence of psychosocial variables and traumatic injury. Journal of Emergency Medicine 36(4): 417–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jemermed.2007.10.077
Kern, K. (2001) Mrs. Stanton’s Bible. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Kirchgaessner, S. (2023) Revealed: senate investigation into Brett Kavanaugh assault claims contained serious omissions. Guardian, April 28.
Lerner, G. (1998) The Feminist Thought of Sarah Grimké. New York: Oxford University Press.
Lerner, G. (2004) The Grimké Sisters from South Carolina: Pioneers for Women’s Rights and Abolition. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press. https://doi.org/10.5149/9780807868096_lerner
Meckler, L. (2020) Betsy DeVos compares choice of abortion to choice of slavery. Washington Post, January 24.
Messerly, M., and Wren, A. (2022) National Right to Life official: 10-year-old should have had baby. Politico, July 14.
Milbank, D. (2023) Republican’s abortion bill risks alienating Asian Americans. Washington Post, May 20.
Mohr, J. C. (1978) Abortion in America: The Origins and Evolution of National Policy, 1800–1900. New York: Oxford University Press.
Palin, S. (2010) America by Heart: Reflections on Family, Faith, and Flag. New York: HarperCollins.
Pew Research Center (2015) Religious Landscape Study. Washington, D.C.: PRC.
Pew Research Center (2022) America’s Abortion Quandary. Washington, D.C.: PRC. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2022/05/06/americas-abortion-quandary
Robertson, K. (2022) Facts were sparse on an abortion case. But that didn’t stop the attacks. New York Times, July 14.
Robins-Early, N. (2023) South Carolina passes six-week abortion ban after heated debate. Guardian, May 23.
Rubin, J. (2022) A 10-year-old rape victim’s plight shows why politicians should stay out of abortion. Washington Post, July 14.
Samuels, F. M. D. (2022) Many states that restrict or ban abortion don’t teach kids about sex and pregnancy. Scientific American, July 26.
Schneir, M. (ed.) (1994) Declaration of sentiments. In Feminism: The Essential Historical Writings 76–82. New York: Vintage Books.
Siegel, L. W. (1995) The marital rape exemption: evolution to extinction. Cleveland State Law Review 43(2): 351.
Siegel, R. (1992) Reasoning from the body: a historical perspective on abortion regulation and questions of equal protection. Stanford Law Review 44(2): 261–381. https://doi.org/10.2307/1228947
Simmons-Duffin, S. (2022) Her miscarriage left her bleeding profusely. An Ohio ER sent her home to wait. NPR, November 15.
Simmons-Duffin, S. (2023) A Good Friday funeral in Texas. Baby Halo’s parents had few choices in post-Roe Texas. NPR, April 6.
Stanton, E. C. (1857) Letter to Gerrit Smith. In Elizabeth Cady Stanton Papers: General Correspondence. Washington, DC: Library of Congress. Also quoted on page 326 of Kramarae, C., and Russo, A. (eds.) (2001) The Radical Women’s Press of the 1850s, Vol. 2. London and New York: Routledge.
Stanton, E. C. (1868a) Governor Geary and Hester Vaughan. Revolution, December 10, pp. 353–5.
Stanton, E. C. (1868b) Hester Vaughan. Revolution, November 19, p. 74.
Stanton, E. C. (1992) The solitude of self. In E. C. DuBois (ed.) The Elizabeth Cady Stanton–Susan B. Anthony Reader: Correspondence, Writings, Speeches 246–54. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
Stanton, E. C., and Anthony, S. B. (2000) The Selected Papers of Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony, Volume 2 (ed. A. D. Gordon). New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Stevenson, A. (2015) The woman-slave analogy: rhetorical foundations in American culture, 1830–1900. Dissertation, University of Queensland.
Stone, L., and Blackwell, A. B. (1987) Friends & Sisters: Letters Between Lucy Stone and Antoinette Brown Blackwell, 1846–93 (eds C. Lasser and M. D. Merrill). Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Stringfellow, T. (1981) A brief examination of scripture testimony on the institution of slavery. In D. G. Faust (ed.) The Ideology of Slavery: Proslavery Thought in the Antebellum South, 1830–1860 136–67. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press.
Thomas, T. A. (2012) Misappropriating women’s history in the law and politics of abortion. Seattle University Law Review 36(1): 1. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2016513
Thomas, T. A. (2016) Elizabeth Cady Stanton and the Feminist Foundations of Family Law. New York: New York University Press.
Thompson, A., and Tapp, S. (2023) Criminal Victimization, 2022. NCJ 307089. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Justice.
Townsend, H. (2023) Second middle passage: how anti-abortion laws perpetuate structures of slavery and the case for reproductive justice. Journal of Constitutional Law 25(1): 185–232.
Truman, J. L., and Morgan, R. E. (2022) Violent Victimization by Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity, 2017–2020. NCJ 304277. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of Justice.
Walker, A. S. (2023) Most abortion bans include exceptions. In practice, few are granted. New York Times, January 21.
Weiser, B., Fadulu, L., and Christobek, K. (2023) Donald Trump sexually abused and defamed E. Jean Carroll, jury finds. New York Times, May 9.
Williams, V. (2021) Ben Carson likens abortion to slavery, wants to see Roe v. Wade overturned. Washington Post, November 26.
Woodhull, V. (1974) The principles of social freedom. In M. B. Stern (ed.) The Victoria Woodhull Reader 3–43. Weston: M&S Press.
Zernike, K. (2023) Texas judge says doctors can use ‘good faith judgment’ in providing abortions. New York Times, August 5.
Ziegler, M. (2023) Roe: The History of a National Obsession. New Haven: Yale University Press. https://doi.org/10.12987/9780300271874
Zink-Sawyer, B. A. (2003) From Preachers to Suffragists: Woman’s Rights and Religious Conviction in the Lives of Three Nineteenth-Century American Clergywomen. Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press.
