People of the book, women of the body
ultra-orthodox Jewish women’s reproductive literacy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/bar.15686Keywords:
reproduction, ultra-orthodox jews, Judaism, pregnancy, israel, women, literacy, embodiment, bodies, bodyAbstract
Jews have often been referred to as ‘People of the book.’ This is because books, specifically those that contain rabbinic legal discourse, are understood to be authoritative guides for Jewish life, and those who have achieved mastery in the content of the books are considered authorities. Although ‘people of the book’ is often used to refer to all Jews, book culture has been almost entirely constructed by men, particularly among ultra-Orthodox Jews. This article offers a different framework, one which sees women’s religious authority growing out of embodied experiences. Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) women challenge the dominant paradigm for religious authority by insisting that their pregnant bodies replace books and rabbis. While a woman’s body might be seen as an impediment to her religious authority, I argue that women become capable of exercising religious authority through their embodied experiences of bearing children. During my two years of ethnographic research with Haredi women in Jerusalem, I found that after giving birth to two or three children, Haredi women felt authorized to make decisions about their pregnancies without consulting a rabbi. After a woman has two or three children, she develops what I refer to as ‘reproductive literacy,’ meaning she knows how to use her embodied reproductive experiences as knowledge, expertise, and thus authority over reproduction. Through a close reading of pregnancy advice books and an analysis of how Haredi women use these books, I show that how Haredi women embody authority to make decisions about the maintenance and continuation of Haredi life.
References
Aran, Gideon. “Denial Does not Make the Haredi Body Go Away.” Contemporary Jewry. 26 (2006): 75-113
Aran, Gideon, Nurit Stadler, and Eyal Ben-Ari, “Fundamentalism and the Masculine Body: the Case of Jewish Ultra-Orthodox Men in Israel,” Religion 38 (2008): 30.
Baumel, Samuel. Sacred Speakers: Language and Culture among the Haredim in Israel. New York: Berghahn Books, 2006.
Benor, Sarah Bunin. Becoming Frum: How Newcomers Learn the Language of Orthodox Judaism. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 2012.
Berninson, Ilana. “Time of Labor: Time of Cancellation.” Hachana Ruchanit L’leida [Spiritual Preparation for Labor] [Hebrew], edited by Moshe and Dafna Hasdai. No publication date.
Bilu, Yoram. “’To make many more Menachem Mendels’: Childlessness, Procreation, and Creation in Messianic Habad,” Contemporary Jewry 32 (2012): 111-134.
Dahari, Sylvia, and Tami Perlman. “Labor: Next to God in Prayer.” Hachana Ruchanit L’leida [Spiritual Preparation for Labor] [Hebrew], edited by Moshe and Dafna Hasdai. No publication date.
Davidman Lynn Tradition in a Rootless World: Women Turn to Orthodox Judaism. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1991.
----. Becoming Un-Orthodox: Stories of Ex-Hasidic Jews. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.
Eilberg-Schwartz, Howard. People of the Body: Jews and Judaism from an Embodied Perspective. Albany: State University of New York Press, 1992.
Englander, Yakir. “The Image of the Male Body in Lithuanian Ultra-Orthodox Thought in Israel and Corresponding Strategies for Forging an A-feminine Public Sphere,” Journal of Contemporary Religion, 29, no. 3 (2014): 457-470.
Fader, Ayala. Mitzvah Girls: Bringing up the Next Generation of Hassidic Jews in Brooklyn. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2009.
----. “Ultra-Orthodox Jewish Interioirity, the Internet, and the Crisis of Faith.” HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 7.1 (2017): 185-206;
Finkelstein, Michal, and Baruch Finkelstein. B’Shaah Tovah: A Medical and Halakhic Guide for Pregnancy and Labor [Hebrew]. Feldheim: Jerusalem 1996.
Friedman, Menachem. “Life and Book Tradition in the Development of Ultraorthodox Judaism,” Judaism Viewed from Within and Without, ed. Harvey Goldberg, 235-256. Albany, NY: SUNY Press, 1987.
Gantz, Michal. “Childbirth and Women’s Strength in the Haredi Community in Israel” [Hebrew]. MA thesis, Hebrew University, 2003.
Goldman Carrel, Barbara. “Hasidic Women's Head-Coverings: A Feminized System of Hasidic Distinction,” in Religion, Dress and the Body ed. By Linda Arthur (New York: Berg, 1999): 163–180;
Goodman, Yehuda. “’You look, Thank God, Quite Good on the Outside’: Imitating the Ideal Self in a Jewish Ultra-Orthodox Rehabilitation Site.” Medical Anthropological Quarterly, 23, no.2 (2009): 122-141.
Grayzer, Nurit. “Spiritual Preparation for Labor.” Hachana Ruchanit L’leida [Spiritual Preparation for Labor] [Hebrew], edited by Moshe and Dafna Hasdai. No publication date.
Gribetz, Sarit Kattan. “Pregnant with Meaning: Women’s Bodies as Metaphors for Time in Biblical, Second Temple, and Rabbinic Literature.” In The Construction of Time in Antiquity: Ritual, Art and Identity, edited by Jonathan Ben-Dov and Lutz Doering, 173–204. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2017.
Han, Sallie. Pregnancy in Practice: Expectation and Experience in Contemporary US. New York: Berghahn Books, 2013.
Hasdai, Moshe and Dafna eds. Hachana Ruchanit L’Leida. (no publication date) [Hebrew].
Heilman, Samuel. The People of the Book: Drama, Fellowship and Religion. Chicago: Chicago University Press, 1983.
Ivry, Tsipy. “Kosher Medicine and Medicalized Halacha: An Exploration of Triadic Relations among Israeli Rabbis, Doctors, and Infertility Patients.” American Ethnologist 37, no. 4 (2010): 662–80.
Ivry, Tsipy, Elly Teman, and Barbara A. Bernhardt, “Pregnancy as a Proclamation of Faith: Ultra-Orthodox Jewish Women Navigating the Uncertainty of Pregnancy and Prenatal Diagnosis.” American Journal of Medical Genetics 155, Part A (2011): 69–80
Jeffay, “In Israel, Haredi and Muslim Women are having Fewer Children.” The Jewish Daily Forward, July 15, 2011. Accessed August 8, 2012. http://forward.com/articles/139391/in-israel-haredi-and-muslim-women-are-having-fewer/
Kirshenblatt-Gimblett, Barbara. “The Corporeal Turn,” The Jewish Quarterly Review, 95 no. 3 2005.
Manolson, G. Outside/Inside: A Fresh Look at Tzniut (Jerusalem: Targum Press Inc, 1997). Finkelstein, Preparing Haredi Girls for their Monthly Cycle and sexual Maturity. (MA dissertation, Hebrew U of Jerusalem, 1999) [in Hebrew];
Oryan, Nothing More beautiful than modesty: Communication models in the socialization of Haredi girls. MA dissertation, University of Haifa [in Hebrew], 1994;
Raucher, Michal. “Ethnography and Jewish Ethics: Lessons from a Case Study in Reproductive Ethics.” Journal of Religious Ethics 44, no. 4 (2016): 636–58
----. Conceiving Authority: Reproductive Agency among Haredi Women in Jerusalem (Indiana University Press, 2020)
Stolow, Jeremy. Orthodox by Design: Judaism, Print Politics, and the ArtScroll Revolution. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2010.
Taragin-Zeller, Lea. “Between Modesty and Beauty: Reinterpreting Female Piety in the Israeli Haredi Community. In Love, Marriage, and Jewish Families Today: Paradoxes of the Gender Revolution. Ed Sylvia Fishman Barack, 308-326. Waltham: Brandeis University Press, 2015.
----. “Have Six, Have Seven, Have Eight Children: Daily Interactions between Rabbinic Authority and Free Will,” Judaism, Sovereignty, and Human Rights. 3 (2017): 113-138. [Hebrew];
Teman, Elly and Tsipy Ivry, “Pregnancy as a Way of Life among Ultra-Orthodox Jewish Women.” Paper presented at the 81st Annual Meeting of the Eastern Sociological Society, February 24–27, 2011, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Teman, Elly and Ayala Frumkin. “God sent Ordeals and their Discontents: Ultra-Orthodox Jewish Women Negotiate Prenatal Testing.” Social Science and Medicine 72, no. 9 (2011): 1527–33.
Toverdovitch, Bracha. “Towards Spiritual Motherhood.” Hachana Ruchanit L’leida [Spiritual Preparation for Labor] [Hebrew], edited by Moshe and Dafna Hasdai. No publication date.
Weingarten, Michael and Eliezer Kitai. “Consultations with Rabbis.” Journal of Religion and Health 34, no. 2 (1995): 135–40.
Weiss, S. “Under Cover: Demystification of Women's Head Covering in Jewish Law,” Nashim, 17 (2009): 89–115; Seigelshifer, V. “From Tichels to Hair Bands: Modern Orthodox Women and the Practice of Head Covering” (M.A. Thesis, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 2006);
Yafeh, Orit. “The Time in the Body: Cultural Construction of Femininity in Ultraorthodox Kindergartens for Girls.” Ethos 35, no. 4 (2007): 516–53.
Yaffe, Nechumi Malovicki, Nevin Solak, Eran Halperin, and Tamar Saguy. “’Poor is Pious’: Distinctiveness Threat Increases Glorification of Poverty among the Poor.” European Journal of Social Psychology 48 (2018): 460-471.
Zalcberg, Sima. “‘Grace is Deceitful and Beauty is Vain’: How Hasidic Women Cope with the Requirement of Shaving One's Head and Wearing a Black Kerchief,” Gender Issues, 24/3 (2007): 13–34;
