Fear and Terror in Buddhist Meditation
A Cognitive Model for Meditation-Related Changes in Arousal and Affect
Keywords:
Meditation, fear, arousal, sensitizationAbstract
This article explores the extent to which cognitive historiography can be employed to comment on debates concerning the interpretation of meditative experiences in select Buddhist texts. In particular, this article considers references to meditation-related fear and other associated emotional, perceptual, and cognitive changes. Qualitative data from Western Buddhist meditation practitioners and meditation teachers are employed to further illustrate the range of fear-related experiences and how they are interpreted. To account for why certain references to fear in Buddhist literature could plausibly be read as representative of meditation-related experiences, this article develops cognitive models based on neuroscientific research on meditation as well as from cognitive and affective neuroscience more broadly. However, this process reveals some current limitations in the field of neuroscience of meditation as well as other methodological difficulties faced by cognitive historiography when attempting to account for religious experiences from other cultures and from distant times.
References
Ahn, Juhn Y. 2007. “Malady of Meditation: A Prolegomenon to the Study of Illness and Zen.” PhD diss., University of California, Berkeley, CA.
Allen, Micah, Martin Dietz, Karina S. Blair, et al. 2012. “Cognitive-Affective Neural Plasticity following Active-Controlled Mindfulness Intervention.” The Journal of Neuroscience 32 (44): 15601–15610.
Amihai, Ido, and Maria Kozhevnikov. 2014. “Arousal vs. Relaxation: A Comparison of the Neurophysiological and Cognitive Correlates of Vajrayana and Theravada Meditative Practices. PLoS ONE 9 (7): e102990. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0102990.
Analayo, Bhikkhu. 2019. “The Insight Knowledge of Fear and Adverse Effects of Mindfulness Practices.” Mindfulness 10: 2172–2185.
Antonova, Elena, Paul Chadwick, and Veena Kumari. 2015. “More Meditation, Less Habituation? The Effect of Mindfulness Practice on the Acoustic Startle Reflex.” PLoS ONE 10 (5): e0123512. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0123512.
Atchley, Rachel, Daniel Klee, Tab Memmott, et al. 2016. “Event-Related Potential Correlates of Mindfulness Meditation Competence.” Neuroscience 320: 83–92. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroscience.2016.01.051.
Brekke, Torkel. 1999. “The Role of Fear in Indian Religious Thought with Special Reference to Buddhism.” Journal of Indian Philosophy 27: 439–467.
Brefczynski-Lewis, J.A., A. Lutz, H.S. Schaefer, et al. 2007. “Neural Correlates of Attentional Expertise in Long-Term Meditation Practitioners.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104 (27): 11483–11488. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0606552104.
Britton, Willoughby B., Jared R. Lindahl, B. Rael Cahn, et al. 2014 “Awakening is Not a Metaphor: The Effects of Buddhist Meditation Practices on Basic Wakefulness.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1307: 64–81. https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.12279.
Buddhaghosa. 1991. The Path of Purification (Visuddhimagga). Translated by Bhikkhu Ñanamoli. Onalaska, WA: BPS Pariyatti Editions.
Chua, Phyllis, Michael Krams, Ivan Toni, et al. 1999. “A Functional Anatomy of Anticipatory Anxiety.” NeuroImage 9: 563–571.
Collins, Steven. 2013. Self and Society: Essays on Pali Literature and Social Theory 1988–2010. Chiang Mai: Silkworm Books.
Coppola, Gianluca, Cherubino Di Lorenzo, Jean Schoenen, et al. 2013. “Habituation and Sensitization in Primary Headaches.” Journal of Headache and Pain 14 (1): 65. https://doi.org/10.1186/1129-2377-14–65.
Craig, A.D. (Bud). 2009. “How do you Feel—Now? The Anterior Insula and Human Awareness.” Nature Reviews Neuroscience 10: 59–70.
Craig, A.D. (Bud). 2011. “Significance of the Insula for the Evolution of Human Awareness of Feelings from the Body.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1225 (1): 72–82.
Critchley, Hugo D. 2005. “Neural Mechanisms of Autonomic, Affective, and Cognitive Integration.” Journal of Comparative Neurology 493 (1): 154–166.
Critchley, Hugo D., D.R. Corfield, M.P. Chandler, et al. 2000. “Cerebral Correlates of Autonomic Cardiovascular Arousal: A Functional Neuroimaging Investigation in Humans.” Journal of Physiology 523 (1): 259–270.
Davidson, Richard J., and Cortland J. Dahl. 2017. “Varieties of Contemplative Practice.” JAMA Psychiatry 74 (2): 121–123. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2016.3469.
Delgado-Pastor, Luis Carlos, Pandelis Perakakis, et al. 2013. “Mindfulness (Vipassana) Meditation: Effects on P3b Event-Related Potential and Heart Rate Variability.” International Journal of Psychophysiology 90 (2): 207–214. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2013.07.006.
Desrosiers, Alethea, David H. Klemanski, and Susan Nolen-Hoeksema. 2013. “Mapping Mindfulness Facets onto Dimensions of Anxiety and Depression.” Behavior Therapy 44 (3): 373–384. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2013.02.001.
Dunn, Barnaby D., Iolanta Stefanovitch, Davy Evans, et al. 2010. “Can You Feel the Beat? Interoceptive Awareness is an Interactive Function of Anxiety- and Depression-Specific Symptom Dimensions.” Behaviour Research and Therapy 48 (11): 1133–1138. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2010.07.006.
Eddy, Marianna D., Tad T. Brunyé, Sarah Tower-Richardi, et al. 2015. “The Effect of a Brief Mindfulness Induction on Processing of Emotional Images: An ERP Study.” Frontiers in Psychology 6: 1391. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01391.
Eidinow, Esther, and Luther H. Martin. 2014. “Editors’ Introduction.” Journal of Cognitive Historiography 1 (1): 5–9.
Eisenstein, Edward M., Doris L. Eisenstein, Jonnalagedda Sarma M. Sarma, et al. 2012. “Some New Speculative Ideas About the ‘Behavioral Homeostasis Theory’ as to How the Simple Learned Behaviors of Habituation and Sensitization Improve Organism Survival Throughout Phylogeny.” Communicative & Integrative Biology 5 (3): 233–239.
Engert, Veronika, Bethany E. Kok, Ioannis Papassotiriou, et al. 2017. “Specific Reduction in Cortisol Stress Reactivity after Social but not Attention-Based Mental Training.” Science Advances 3 (10): e1700495. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.1700495.
Farb, Norman A.S., Zindel V. Segal, and Adam K. Anderson. 2013. “Mindfulness Meditation Training Alters Cortical Representations of Interoceptive Attention.” Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 8 (1): 15–26.
Favrod-Coune, Thierry, and Barbara Broers. 2010. “The Health Effect of Psychostimulants: A Literature Review.” Pharmaceuticals 3 (7): 2333–2361. https://doi.org/10.3390/ph3072333.
Fox, Kieran C.R., Savannah Nijeboer, Matthew L. Dixon, et al. 2014. “Is Meditation Associated with Altered Brain Structure? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Morphometric Neuroimaging in Meditation Practitioners.” Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 43: 48–73.
Fox, Kieran C.R., Matthew L. Dixon, Savannah Nijeboer, et al. 2016. “Functional Neuro-anatomy of Meditation: A Review and Meta-analysis of 78 Functional Neuroimaging Investigations.” Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 65: 208–228.
Geiger, Maximilian J., Susanne Neufang, Dan J. Stein, et al. 2014. “Arousal and the Attentional Network in Panic Disorder.” Human Psychopharmacology 29 (6): 599–603. https://doi.org/10.1002/hup.2436.
Giustarini, Giuliano. 2012. “The Role of Fear (Bhaya) in the Nikayas and in the Abhidhamma.” Journal of Indian Philosophy 40: 511–531.
Goddard, Andrew W., Susan G. Ball, James Martinez, et al. 2010. “Current Perspectives of the Roles of the Central Norepinephrine System in Anxiety and Depression.” Depression and Anxiety 27 (4): 339–350.
Gotink, Rinske A., Rozanna Meijboom, Meike W. Vernooij, et al. 2016. “8-Week Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction Induces Brain Changes Similar to Traditional Long-Term Meditation Practice: A Systematic Review.” Brain and Cognition 108: 32–41.
Graeff, Frederico G., and Cristina M. Del-Ben. 2008. “Neurobiology of Panic Disorder: From Animal Models to Brain Neuroimaging.” Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 32 (7): 1326–1335.
Gritton, Howard J., Ana Kantorowski, Martin Sarter, et al. 2012. “Bidirectional Interactions Between Circadian Entrainment and Cognitive Performance.” Learning & Memory 19 (3): 126–141. https://doi.org/10.1101/lm.023499.111.
Gyatso, Janet. 1999. “Healing Burns with Fire: The Facilitations of Experience in Tibetan Buddhism.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 67 (1): 113–147.
Hakuin. 2009. “Idle Talk On a Night Boat.” In Hakuin’s Precious Mirror Cave, edited and translated by Norman Waddell, 96–114. Berkeley, CA: Counterpoint.
Hamilton, Sue. 2000. Early Buddhism: A New Approach: The ‘I’ of the Beholder. Abingdon: Routledge.
Heintz, Christophe. 2011. “Cognitive History and Cultural Epidemiology.” In Past Minds: Studies in Cognitive Historiography, edited by Luther H. Martin and Jesper Sørensen, 11–28. London: Equinox Publishing.
Henrich, Joseph, Steven J. Heine, and Ara Norenzayan. 2010. “The Weirdest People in the World?” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 33 (2–3): 61–135.
Hölzel, Britta K., Ulrich Ott, Tim Gard, et al. 2008. “Investigation of Mindfulness Meditation Practitioners with Voxel-Based Morphometry.” Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 3 (1): 55–61.
Hölzel, Britta K., Elizabeth A. Hoge, Douglas N. Greve, et al. 2013. “Neural Mechanisms of Symptom Improvements in Generalized Anxiety Disorder Following Mindfulness Training.” NeuroImage: Clinical 2 (1): 448–458.
Hölzel, Britta K., Vincent Brunsch, Tim Gard, et al. 2016. “Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction, Fear Conditioning, and the Uncinate Fasciculus: A Pilot Study.” Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience 10: 124. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnbeh.2016.00124.
Hopper, James W., Paul A. Frewen, Bessel A. van der Kolk, et al. 2007. “Neural Correlates of Reexperiencing, Avoidance, and Dissociation in PTSD: Symptom Dimensions and Emotion Dysregulation in Responses to Script-Driven Trauma Imagery.” Journal of Traumatic Stress 20 (5): 713–725.
Hunter, Elaine C.M., Paul M. Salkovskis, and Anthony S. David. 2014. “Attributions, Appraisals and Attention for Symptoms in Depersonalisation Disorder.” Behaviour Research and Therapy 53: 20–29. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2013.11.005.
Kalk, N.J., D.J. Nutt, and A.R. Lingford-Hughes. 2011. “The Role of Central Noradrenergic Dysregulation in Anxiety Disorders: Evidence from Clinical Studies.” Journal of Psychopharmacology 25 (1): 3–16.
Kandel, Hagar, and Donald W. Pfaff. 2019. “Arousal.” In Stress: Physiology, Biochemistry, and Pathology (Vol. 3), edited by G. Fink, 1–18. New York: Academic Press.
Kapleau, Philip. 1989. Zen: Merging of East and West. Garden City, NY: Anchor Press.
Kasamatsu, Akira, and Tomio Hirai. 1966. “An Electroencephalographic Study on Zen Meditation (Zazen).” Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences 20 (4): 315–336.
Koelega, H.S. 1993. “Stimulant Drugs and Vigilance Performance: A Review.” Psychopharmacology 111: 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02257400.
Koss, Michael C. 1986. “Pupillary Dilation as an Index of Central Nervous System Alpha2-Adrenoceptor Activation.” Journal of Pharmacological Methods 15: 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/0160-5402(86)90002-1.
Lakey, Chad E., Daniel R. Berry, and Eric W. Sellers. 2011. “Manipulating Attention via Mindfulness Induction Improves P300-based Brain-Computer Interface Performance.” Journal of Neural Engineering 8 (2): 025019. https://doi.org/10.1088/1741-2560/8/2/025019.
Lang, R., K. Dehof, K.A. Meurer, et al. 1979. “Sympathetic Activity and Transcendental Meditation.” Journal of Neural Transmission 44: 117–135.
Langner, Robert, and Simon B. Eickhoff. 2013. “Sustaining Attention to Simple Tasks: A Meta-Analytic Review of the Neural Mechanisms of Vigilant Attention.” Psychological Bulletin 139 (4): 870–900.
Lazar, Sara W., Catherine E. Kerr, Rachel H. Wasserman, et al. 2005. “Meditation Experience is Associated with Increased Cortical Thickness.” Neuroreport 16 (17): 1893–1897.
Levenson, Robert W., Paul Ekman, and Matthieu Ricard. 2012. “Meditation and the Startle Response: A Case Study.” Emotion 12 (3): 650–658. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0027472.
Liberzon, Israel, and Phan, K. Luan. 2003. “Brain-Imaging Studies of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder.” CNS Spectrums 8 (9): 641–650.
Lindahl, Jared R., Nathan E. Fisher, David J. Cooper, et al. 2017. “The Varieties of Contemplative Experience: A Mixed-Methods Study of Meditation-Related Challenges in Western Buddhists.” PLoS ONE 12 (5): e0176239. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0176239.
Lindahl, Jared R., and Willoughby B. Britton. 2019. “‘I Have This Feeling of Not Really Being Here’: Buddhist Meditation and Changes in Sense of Self.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 26 (7–8): 157–83.
Lindahl, Jared R., David J. Cooper, Nathan E. Fisher, et al. 2020. “Progress or Pathology? Differential Diagnosis and Intervention Criteria for Meditation-Related Challenges: Perspectives from Buddhist Meditation Teachers and Practitioners.” Frontiers in Psychology: Cultural Psychology 11: 1905. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01905.
Lingpa, Dudjom. 2015. The Vajra Essence: Dudjom Lingpa’s Visions of the Great Perfection, Volume 3. Translated by B. Alan Wallace. Somerville, MA: Wisdom Publications.
Luders, Eileen, Florian Kurth, Emeran A. Mayer, et al. 2012. “The Unique Brain Anatomy of Meditation Practitioners: Alterations in Cortical Gyrification.” Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 6: 34.
Lumma, Anna-Lena, Bethany E. Kok, and Tania Singer. 2015. “Is Meditation Always Relaxing? Investigating Heart Rate, Heart Rate Variability, Experienced Effort and Likeability During Training of Three Types of Meditation.” International Journal of Psychophysiology 97: 38–45.
Magalhaes, Andressa A., Leticia Oliveira, Mirtes G. Pereira, et al. 2018. “Does Meditation Alter Brain Responses to Negative Stimuli? A Systematic Review.” Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 12: 448. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2018.00448.
Mahasi Sayadaw. 1994. The Progress of Insight: A Treatise on Satipatthana Meditation. Translated by Nyanaponika Thera. Kandy, Sri Lanka: Buddhist Publication Society.
Martin, Luther H. 2012. “The Future of the Past: The History of Religions and Cognitive Historiography.” Religio 20 (2): 155–71.
Mazzola, Laure, Jean Isnard, Roland Peyron, et al. 2009. “Somatotopic Organization of Pain Responses to Direct Electrical Stimulation of the Human Insular Cortex.” Pain 146 (1–2): 99–104.
Moeller-Bertram, Tobias, John Keltner, and Irina A. Strigo. 2012. “Pain and Post Traumatic Stress Disorder: Review of Clinical and Experimental Evidence.” Neuropharmacology 62 (2): 586–597.
Morrell, Eric M., and James G. Hollandsworth, Jr. 1986. “Norepinephrine Alterations under Stress Conditions following the Regular Practice of Meditation.” Psychosomatic Medicine 48 (3–4): 270–277.
Namto, Achan Sobin S. 1989. Insight Meditation: Practical Steps Towards Ultimate Truth. Fawnskin, CA: Vipassana Dhura Meditation Society.
Ñanamoli, Bhikkhu, trans. 2002. The Path of Discrimination (Patisambhidamagga). Oxford: Pali Text Society.
Ñanarama, Matara Sri. 1993. The Seven Stages of Purification and the Insight Knowledges. Kandy, Sri Lanka: Buddhist Publication Society.
Nowacki, Andreas, Kathleen Seidel, Philippe Schucht, et al. 2015. “Induction of Fear by Intraoperative Stimulation During Awake Craniotomy: Case Presentation and Systematic Review of the Literature.” World Neurosurgery 84 (2): 470–474.
Osuch, Elizabeth A., Terence A. Ketter, Timothy A. Kimbrell, et al. 2000. “Regional Cerebral Metabolism Associated with Anxiety Symptoms in Affective Disorder Patients.” Biological Psychiatry 48 (10): 1020–1023.
Osuch, Elizabeth A., Brenda Benson, Marilla Geraci, et al. 2001. “Regional Cerebral Blood Flow Correlated with Flashback Intensity in Patients with Posttraumatic Stress Disorder”. Biological Psychiatry 50 (4): 246–253.
Pabongka Rinpoche. 1991. Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand: A Concise Discourse on the Path to Enlightenment. Translated by Michael Richards. Boston, MA: Wisdom Publications.
Red Pine, trans. 2001. The Diamond Sutra: The Perfection of Wisdom. Berkeley, CA: Counterpoint Press.
Ronkin, Noa. 2005. Early Buddhist Metaphysics: The Making of a Philosophical Tradition. Abingdon: RoutledgeCurzon.
Sharf, Robert H. 1995. “Buddhist Modernism and the Rhetoric of Meditative Experience.” Numen 42 (3): 228–283.
Sharf, Robert H. 1998. “Experience.” In Critical Terms for Religious Studies, edited by Mark C. Taylor, 94–116. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Shulman, Eviatar. 2016. Rethinking the Buddha: Early Buddhist Philosophy as Meditative Perception. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Sogen, Omori. 2001. An Introduction to Zen Training. Translated by Dogen Hosokawa and Roy Yoshimoto. Boston, MA: Tuttle Publishing.
Simmons, Alan, Scott C. Matthews, Murray B. Stein, et al. 2004. “Anticipation of Emotionally Aversive Visual Stimuli Activates Right Insula.” Neuroreport 15 (15): 2261–2265.
Simmons, Alan, Irina Strigo, Scott C. Matthews, et al. 2006. “Anticipation of Aversive Visual Stimuli is Associated with Increased Insula Activation in Anxiety-Prone Subjects.” Biological Psychiatry 60 (4): 402–409.
Smart, Colette M., Sidney J. Segalowitz, Bryce P. Mulligan, et al. 2016. “Mindfulness Training for Older Adults with Subjective Cognitive Decline: Results from a Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial.” Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease 52 (2): 757–774. https://doi.org/10.3233/JAD-150992.
Ståhlberg, Linnea, Eva Palmquist, and Steven Nordin. 2018. “Intolerance to Environmental Chemicals and Sounds in Irritable Bowel Syndrome: Explained by Central Sensitization?” Journal of Health Psychology 23 (10): 1367–1377.
Stein, Murray B., Alan N. Simmons, Justin S. Feinstein, et al. 2007. “Increased Amygdala and Insula Activation During Emotion Processing in Anxiety-Prone Subjects.” American Journal of Psychiatry 164 (2): 318–327.
Treves, Isaac N., Lawrence Y. Tello, Richard J. Davidson, et al. 2019. “The Relationship between Mindfulness and Objective Measures of Body Awareness: A Meta-Analysis.” Scientific Reports 9 (1): 17386. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-53978-6.
Turan, Bulent, Carol Foltz, James F. Cavanagh, et al. 2015. “Anticipatory Sensitization to Repeated Stressors: The Role of Initial Cortisol Reactivity and Meditation/Emotion Skills Training.” Psychoneuroendocrinology 52: 229–238. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psyneuen.2014.11.014.
Upatissa. 1961. The Path of Freedom (Vimuttimagga). Translated by N.R.M. Ehara, Soma Thera, and Kheminda Thera. Kandy, Sri Lanka: Buddhist Publication Society.
Vajirañana Mahathera, Paravahera. 1962. Buddhist Meditation In Theory and Practice: A General Exposition According to the Pali Canon of the Theravada School. Kuala Lumpur: Buddhist Missionary Society.
Vestergaard-Poulsen, Peter, Martijn van Beek, Joshua Skewes, et al. 2009. “Long-term Meditation is Associated with Increased Gray Matter Density in the Brain Stem.” Neuroreport 20 (2): 170–174.
Walpurger, Verena, Gabriele Hebing-Lennartz, Heide Denecke, et al. 2003. “Habituation Deficit in Auditory Event-Related Potentials in Tinnitus Complainers.” Hearing Research 181 (1–2): 57–64.
Whalley, Matthew G., Marijn C.W. Kroes, Zoe Huntley, et al. 2013. “An fMRI Investigation of Posttraumatic Flashbacks.” Brain and Cognition 81 (1): 151–159. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bandc.2012.10.002.
Woolf, Clifford J. 2011. “Central Sensitization: Implications for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Pain.” Pain 152, suppl. 3: S2–15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pain.2010.09.030.
Xygalatas, Dimitris. 2014. “On the Way Towards a Cognitive Historiography: Are We There Yet?” Journal of Cognitive Historiography 1 (2): 193–200.
Zeidan, Fadel, Nichole M. Emerson, Suzan R. Farris, et al. 2015. “Mindfulness Meditation-Based Pain Relief Employs Different Neural Mechanisms Than Placebo and Sham Mindfulness Meditation-Induced Analgesia.” Journal of Neuroscience 35 (46): 15307–15325.
Zeimbekis, John, and Athanassios Raftopoulos, eds. 2015. The Cognitive Penetrability of Perception: New Philosophical Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
