Unravelling Paunar
Unveiling an Archaeological Site and Exploring the Nomenclature of Images and Style
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/rosa.26267Keywords:
Gaṅgā-Bhagavatī, Vākāṭaka, Paunar, Pravarpura, PravarsēnaAbstract
Paunar has become a site of contention in the field of archaeology ever since the discovery of sculptures during the construction of the Vinoba Bhave ashram. The disputes surrounding this site primarily revolve around three key aspects: the nomenclature of the place, the interpretation of the images found, and their stylistic attributes. Divided into an introduction and five sections, this paper aims to shed light on these controversies. The first and third sections delve into the discourse regarding the identification of Paunar as Pravarapura, a name prominent in eastern Vakataka copper-plate inscriptions. The central question addressed in these two sections is whether Paunar can truly be equated with Pravarapura or if it was situated elsewhere. The second and fourth sections focus on a reassessment of the religious identity and nomenclature of the discovered images. Lastly, the fifth section investigates the origin of the images themselves, aiming to determine whether they bear an indigenous regional affiliation or if they were introduced from either the northern or southern regions of India. By delving into these aspects, this paper seeks to contribute to the discourse surrounding Paunar, ultimately aiming to provide a more comprehensive understanding of its historical significance and cultural context.
References
Alone, Y. S. 2016. Buddhist Caves of Western India: Forms and Patronage. New Delhi: Kaveri Books.
Altekar, A. S. 1960. ‘The Vakatakas’ In G. Yazdani (ed.), The Early History of Deccan: Parts I–VI: 149-200. London: Oxford University Press.
Bakker, Hans T. 1997. The Vakatakas: an essay in Hindu iconology. Groningen: Egbert Forsten. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004644908
—— (ed.). 2004a. The Vakataka Heritage: Indian Culture at the Crossroads. Groningen: Egbert Forsten.
—— 2004b. ‘Mansar.’ In Bakker 2004a: 71–85. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004486119_007
—— (ed.). 2008. Mansar: The Discovery of Pravaresvara and Pravarapura Temple and Residence of the Vakataka King Pravarasena II. Proceedings of a Symposium at the British Museum. Retrieved from https://pure.rug.nl/ws/portalfiles/portal/95566777/Mansar_2008.pdf
—— 2019. Holy Ground—Where Art and Text Meet (Gonda Indological Studies 20). Leiden: Brill.
Bhattacharya, Binoytosh. 1956. The Indian Buddhist Iconography. New Delhi: Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers.
Bisschop, Peter. 2008. ‘The Skull on Siva’s Head.’ In Bakker 2008 (direct link available therein).
Bosma, Natasja. 2008. ‘The Mansar Sculptures and Ajanta.’ In Bakker 2008 (direct link available therein).
Brown, Robert L. 2004. ‘Vakataka-Period Hindu Sculpture.’ In Bakker 2004a: 59–69. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004486119_006
Chandra, Lokesh. 2002. Dictionary of Buddhist Iconography. New Delhi: International Academy of Indian Culture and Aditya Prakashan.
Dandekar, A., S. Shah, V. Sontakke, S. Vaidya and S. Ganveer. 2018. ‘A Sealing of the Vakataka Queen Prabhavatigupta from Nagardhan Excavations (2015–16).’ In Devendra Handa (ed.), Numismatic Digest: 43–48. Mumbai: IIRNS Publications.
Deo, S. B. 1975–76. ‘A Unique Sculpture from Mansar (Maharashtra)’ Journal of Andhra Historical Research Society XXXV: 275–77.
Deo, S. B. and M. K. Dhavalikar. 1968. Paunar Excavations. Nagpur: Nagpur University Press.
Desai, Kalpana. 1973. Iconography of Visnu, New Delhi: Abhinav Publication.
Donaldson, Thomas. 2001. Iconography of Buddhist Sculptures of Orissa (Vol 1 and 2), New Delhi: Abhinav Publications.
Gupta, Chandrashekhar. 1992. ‘Paunar under the Vakatakas.’ In Ajay Mitra Shastri (ed.), Age of Vakatakas: 119–53. New Delhi: Harman Publishing House.
Harivamsa. Shastri Ramanarayan (tr.), Sri Harivamsa Purana, Gorakhpur: Gita Press, 2014.
Jamkhedkar, A. P. 1985. ‘Bronzes from Ramtek.’ Lalit Kala 22: 13–19.
—— 1991. ‘Vakataka Sculpture.’ In Ratan Parimmo (ed.), The Art of Ajanta-New Perspective vol 1: 194–212. New Delhi: Books and Books.
Joshi, J. P. and A. K. Sharma. 1999–2000. ‘Excavation at Mansar, Distt. Nagpur, Maharashtra– 1997-2000.’ In K. N. Dikshit (ed.), Puratattva: Bulletin of the Indian Archaeological Society: 127–31. New Delhi: Indian Archaeological Society.
—— 2005. ‘Mansar Excavation 1998–2004: The Discovery of Pravarpur’. Puramanthana 3 (Pravarpur Special): 1–26.
Joshi, N. P. 1984. ‘Early forms of Siva.’ In Michael Meister (ed.), Discourses on Siva: Proceedings of a Symposium on the Nature of Religious Imagery: 47–61. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania.
Kannal, Deepak. 1996. Ellora: An Enigma in Sculptural Styles. New Delhi: Books and Books. (Reprinted Pune: Apparent 2018.)
Kannal, D. and Kanika Gupta. 2019. Lupadakhe: Unknown Master Sculptors of Ancient India. New Delhi: Kaveri Books.
Kolte, V. B. 1987. Maharastratil Kahi Tamrapat va Silalekha. Mumbai: Maharashtra Rajya Sahitya Sanskriti Mandal.
Kropman, Martine. 2008. ‘The Seals and Inscriptions from Mansar.’ In Bakker 2008 (direct link available therein).
Kumar, Pushpendra. 2012. Saktism in India. Varanasi: New Bhartiya Books Corporation.
Meshram, P. S. and D. Y. Choudhary. 2012 ‘Bronze Pedestal Inscription of Hamalapuri (Ramtek)’ In Shrinivas Padigar (ed.), Pratnakirti-Recent Studies in Indian Epigraphy, History, Archaeology and Art: 26–29, New Delhi: Agam Kala Prakashan.
Mirashi, Vasudev V. 1963. Corpus Inscriptionum Indicarum Vol. 5: Inscriptions of the Vakatakas, Ootacamund: Government Epigraphist for India.
—— 1981. The History of Inscriptions of the Satavahanas and the Western Ksatrapa. Bombay: Maharashtra State Board for Literature and Culture.
Misra, R. N. 1991. ‘Aspects of the Vakataka Art at Ajanta and Elsewhere.’ In Ratan Parimoo (ed.), The Art of Ajanta-New Perspective vol 1: 186–93. New Delhi: Books and Books.
—— 1992. ‘Vakataka Art: A Reappraisal.’ In Ajay Mitra Shastri (ed.), Age of Vakatakas: 171–76, New Delhi: Harman Publishing House.
Nagata, Kaoru. 2008. ‘The Problem in the Identification of Gana-like Images from Mansar: Is it Siva or Gana?’ In Bakker 2008 (direct link available therein).
Nath, Amarendra. 1988–89. Indian Archaeology: A Review. New Delhi: Archaeological Survey of India.
—— 1994–95. Indian Archaeology: A Review. New Delhi: Archaeological Survey of India.
Nigam L. S. 2004. ‘Impact and Extension of Vakataka Art in Chhattisgarh (Daksina Kosala)’ In Bakker 2004a: 71–85.
Raven, Ellen. 2008. ‘Brick Terraces at Ahichhatra and Mansar: A Comparison.’ In Bakker 2008 (direct link available therein).
Sawant, Reshma. 2012. Historical Archaeology of Vidarbha. New Delhi: Aryan Books International.
Schastok, Sara. 1983. ‘A Sixth Century Kubera Image from Mandosar.’ Chhavi II: 105–08.
Senart, E. 1905–06. ‘The Inscriptions in the caves at Nasik.’ Epigraphia Indica 8: 59–96.
Sharma, A. K. 2018. Further Excavation at Mansar. New Delhi: B. R. Publishing Corporation.
Sharma, I. K. 1992. ‘Some Unique Representation of Siva of the Vakataka period’ In Ajay Mitra Shastri (ed.), Age of Vakatakas: 219–24. New Delhi: Harman Publishing House.
Shastri, Ajay M. 1997. Vakatakas: Sources and History. New Delhi: Aryan Book Publications.
Singh, R. 1972–73. Indian Archaeology: A Review. New Delhi: Archaeological Survey of India.
Sivaramamurthy, C. 1976. Satarudriya: Vibhuti of Siva’s Iconography. New Delhi: Abhinav Publication.
Sontakke, V., S. Ganveer, S. Vaidya and P. Joglekar. 2016. ‘Excavation at Nagardhan, Nagpur District, Maharashtra (2015–2016).’ History Today 17: 43–51.
Spink, Walter M. 1981. ‘Ajanta’s Chronology: Politics and Patronage’ In J. G. Williams (ed.), Kaladarsana: American Studies in the Art of India: 109–26. Leiden: Brill. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004646490_014
Wellsted, T. A. 1934. ‘Notes on the Vakatakas of the Central Province and Berar, and their Country, 4th to 8th Century ad.’ Journal and Proceedings of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, NS, 29 (1933): 158–66.
Williams, Joanna W. 1983. ‘Vakataka art and Gupta Mainstream.’ In Smith Bardwell (ed.), Essays on Gupta Culture: 215–33. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass.
