Monarchy and Aristrocracy as International Factors in Freemasonry
The Case of Prince Frederick of the Netherlands, 1816-1881
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/jrff.v1i1.23Keywords:
Freemasonry, Netherlands, Monarchy, Prince FrederickAbstract
This article treats the role of monarchy in nineteenth century freemasonry in Europe with a focus on Prince Frederick as Grand Master of the Dutch Grand Orient and his far less successful endeavours to add a masonic-monarchical glue to the fusion of the Northern and the Southern Netherlands into a new national configuration. The phenomenon of nineteenth century monarchy is treated initially, elaborating upon the inherent tension between liberal politics and restoration in the aftermath of the Vienna Congress. Some European monarchies chose to identify themselves with the ‘people’ rather than with privileges given by divine authority. Also freemasonry of the nineteenth century was trapped in the same bipolarity between cosmopolitan openness and national delimitation. The biography of Prince Frederick, raised at the Prussian court in Berlin and linked through intermarriage to its throne, illustrates the dilemma of nineteenth century monarchy, faced by the dynamic change of European political culture. His position of Grand Master of the Dutch Grand Orient placed him in the middle of controversies between fraternal and national aspirations. And even if monarchy intended to represent an international factor in freemasonry, the case of Prince Frederick illuminates the entire spectrum of difficulties.
References
Beaurepaire, Pierre-Yves, L’Europe des francs-maçons. XVIIIe—XXIe Siècles (Paris: Belin, 2002).
Bussmann, Walter, Europa von der Französischen Revolution zu den Nationalstaatlichen Bewegungen des 19. Jahrhunderts = Handbuch der Europäischen Geschichte. Band 5. (Stuttgart: Klett, 1981).
Cannadine, D. The Pleasures of the Past (London: Fontana, 1990).
Gollwitzer, H. Die Funktion der Monarchie in der Demokratie, in A.M. Birke and L. Kettenacher (eds), Bürgertum, Adel und Monarchie. Wandel der Lebensformen im Zeitalter des bürgerlichen Nationalismus (München, London, New York: Saur, 1989), 147–59.
Hamill, John, The History of English Freemasonry (London: Addlestone, 1994).
Hoffmann, Stefan-Ludwig, ‘Brothers or Strangers? Jews and Freemasons in Nineteenthcentury Germany’, German History. The Journal of the German History Society 18. 2 (2000), 143–61. doi:10.1191/026635500668870828
—Die Politik der Geselligkeit: Freimaurerlogen in der deutschen Bürgergesellschaft, 1840–1918 (Göttingen: Vandenhoek & Ruprecht, 2000).
—‘Democracy and Associations in the Long Nineteenth Century: Toward a Transnational Perspective’, The Journal of Modern History 75 (June 2003), 269–99. doi:10.1086/380141
Martin, Lucie (ed.), Les Francs-maçons dans la cité. Les cultures politiques de la Francmaçonnerie en Europe, XIXe-XXe siècle (Rennes: Presses Universitaires, 2000).
Morton, Graeme, Boudien de Vries and R.J. Morris (eds.), Civil Society, Associations and Urban Places: Class, Nation and Culture in Nineteenth-century Europe (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2006).
Nord, Philip, ‘Republicanism and Utopian Vision: French Freemasonry in the 1860s and 1870s’, Journal of Modern History 63 (1991), 213–29. doi:10.1086/244313
Önnerfors, Andreas, ‘Between the Sacred and the Secular: Connotations of European Space’, in Anamaria Dutceac and Andreas Önnerfors (eds), Negotiating Europe: Foundations, Dynamics, Challenges (Lund: CFE, 2007), 18–37.
Plat, Wolfgang, Deutsche Träume oder Der Schrecken der Freiheit. Aufbruch ins 19. Jahrhundert (Düsseldorf, Wien: Econ, 1981).
van de Sande, Anton, Telemachus en Nestor. Enkele kanttekeningen bij de maçonnieke verwantschap tussen prins Frederik en Jan Kinker in de jaren 1816–1818. In Cis van Heertum, Ton Jongenelen and Frank van Lamoen (eds), De andere achttiende eeuw (Nijmegen:Vantilt, 2006), 230–43.
—Forthcoming. Prins Frederik der Nederlanden, 1797–1881. Monarchie, natiestaat en vrijmetselarij in de negentiende eeuw.
Witte, Els and F. Borné, Documents relatifs à la franc-maçonnerie belge du XIXe siècle, 1830–1855 (Leuven: Nauwelaerts, 1973).
