Reverse Migration and Village Development in Iran from Late Safavid to Mid-Qajar
A Historical and Archaeological Study
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/jia.27275Keywords:
Afshar-Zand, feudal lords, reverse migration, ruralization, Safavid urbanization, village fortressAbstract
At the end of the Safavid dynasty from the late 17th century into the early 18th century, a “reverse migration” process from cities to villages began in Iran and the weakening of the Safavid dynasty saw the start of a decline in city populations. This situation continued through the Afshar and Zand periods and into mid-Qajar era in the 19th century. This article uses archaeological, architectural and historical data to identify and analyze the political, social and economic factors involved: wars and insecurity in cities; an increase in the power of rural landlords and landowners; the policies of rulers; and natural disasters and humanitarian crises. Most former urbanites turned to agricultural activities, while landlords developed fortifications that in many cases became “landlord villages”.
References
Afzal Al-Molk. 2017. Tarikh va Joghrafiaye Qom [History and Geography of Qom]. Qom: Vahid.
Aghajari, H., Momeni, F. and Khanipour, S. 2018. “Ta’sir-e siasat-e nezami gari-e Nader Shah afshar bar tejarat-e khareji Iran [The influence of Nader Shah’s militarism policies on the Iranian foreign trade].” Journal of Iranian Islamic Period History 9.16: 1–37 (Persian).
Allemagne, H. R. d’. 1956. Az Khorasan Ta Bakhtiari [From Khorasan to Bakhtiari]. Transl. M. A. Farevashi. Tehran: Ebn-e Sina and Amirkabir (Persian). Translation of Du Khorassan au Pays des Backhtiaris (4 vols. Paris: Hachette et Cie, 1911).
Ambraseys, N. N., and Melville, C. P. 1982. A History of Persian Earthquakes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Amirhajloo, S. 2021. “Modiriyat-e manabe va rahbordha-ye ma’ishat mobtani bar baghdari va keshavarzi dar Borkhar Asr Qajar; Bar payeh dadeha-ye bastan shenasi va motoon tarikhi [Resource management and the strategies of livelihood based on horticulture and agriculture in Borkhar during the Qajar period; Utilizing archaeological data and historical sources].” Parseh Journal of Archaeological Studies 17.5: 265–286 (Persian).
Arbab Isfahani, M. M. 1989. Nesf-e Jahan Fi Ta’arif Al-Isfahan. 2nd edn, edited by M. Sotoudeh. Tehran: Amirkabir (Persian).
Ashraf, A. 1974. “Vijhegi ha-ye tarikhi-e shahrneshini dar Iran doreh eslami [Historical features of urbanization in Islamic Iran].” Journal of Social Sciences 4: 7–9 (Persian).
Azkia, M. 1989. “Molahezat-e Nazari Piramoon-e Nezamha-ye Bahreh Bardari Az Zamin; Era’e Yek Ta’rif-e Karbordi Dar Morede Iran [Theoretical considerations regarding land use systems; Provide a practical definition of Iran].” Journal of Social Sciences Letter 3: 161–177 (Persian).
Bastani Parizi, M. E. 1983. Siasat Va Eqtesad-e Asr-e Safavi [Politics and Economy of the Safavid Era]. 3rd edn. Tehran: Safi Alishah (Persian).
Boroumand, S. 2015. “Zarrab Khaneh Farahabad; Shenasaee shavahed-e tarikhi va sekkeh shenasi [Farahabad mint: Recognition of historical and numismatic evidence].” Journal of Iran Local Histories 4.7: 5–15 (Persian).
Brugsch, H. K. 1988. Safari Be Darbar-e Soltan-e Sahebgharan [A Journey to the Palace of Soltan-e Sahebgharan]. Vol. 2. Transl. H. Kordbacheh. Tehran: Ettelaʿat (Persian). Translation of Reise der K. Preussischen Gesandtschaft nach Persien: 1860 und 1861 (Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs’sche Buchhandlung, 1863).
Chardin, J. B. 1927. Travels in Persia. London: Argonaut Press. First published 1686.
–––. 1995. Safarnameh Chardin [The Logbook of Chardin]. Vol. 2. Trans. E. Yaghmaee. Tehran: Toos (Persian). Translation of Travels of Sir John Chardin into Persia and the East Indies (London: Moses Pitt, 1686).
Dehghani, M., and Shaʿbani, R. 2015. “Sakhtar va amalkard-e siasi va nezami-e shahrha dar doreh qodrat giri-e Karim Khan Zand [Political-military structure and function of cities in the reign of Karim Khan Zand].” Journal of History of Islam and Iran 25: 57–81 (Persian).
Drouville, G. 2010. Safarnameh-ye Drouville [The Logbook of Gaspard Drouville]. Transl. J. Mohʿee. Tehran: Nikfarjam (Persian). Translation of Voyage en Perse, fait en 1812 et 1813 (Paris: A la Librairie Nationale et Etrangère, 1825).
Esmaili, S. 2006. Pazhooheshi Dar Sekkeha Va Mohrha-ye Doreh Safavi [A Study on the Seals and Coins of the Safavid]. Tehran: Cultural Heritage and Tourism Organization of Iran (Persian).
Gabriel, A. 1969. Tahghighat-e Joghrafiaee Raje’ be Iran [Geographical Research about Iran]. Transl. F. K. Nouri, edited by H. K. Nouri. Tehran: Ebn-e Sina (Persian). Translation of Die Erforschung Persiens (Vienna: Holzhausen, 1952).
Habibi, M. 2007. Az Shar Ta Shahr [From Shar to the City]. 7th edn. Tehran: University of Tehran (Persian).
Hazin Lahiji. 1953. Tarikh-e Hazin [The History of Hazin]. 3rd edn. Isfahan: Taʿeed (Persian).
Herbert, T. 1928. Travels in Persia 1627–1629, edited by W. Foster. London: George Routledge and Sons. First published 1634.
Homayoun, G. A. 2004. Asnad-e Mosavvar-e Orupaeean Az Iran [Illustrated Documents of Europeans in Iran]. Vol. 2. 2nd edn. Tehran: University of Tehran (Persian).
Jaberi Ansari, M. H. K. 1999. Tarikh-e Isfahan va Rey va Hame-ye Jahan [History of Isfahan and Rey and all World], edited by J. Mazaheri. Isfahan: Mashʿal (Persian).
Jaubert, P. A. E. P. 1968. Mosaferat Be Armanestan Va Iran [Travel in Armenia and Iran]. Transl. A. E. Moghadam. Tehran: Iranian Culture Foundation (Persian). Translation of Voyage en Arménie et en Perse (Paris: Chez Pelicier et Nepveu, 1821).
Kajbaf, A. A., Mansoorian, M. and Foroughi, A. 2018. “Tabʿeen va tahlil-e vazʿiat-e jamʿiat va taʿsir-e keshavarzi bar an dar doreh Safaviyeh [Explaining and analyzing population status and the impact of agriculture on it in the Safavid era].” Journal of Historical Research 10.39: 41–59 (Persian).
Kiani, M. Y. 1986. “Shahr ha-ye eslami” [Islamic cities].” In Nazari Ejmali be Shahrneshini Va Shahrsazi Dar Iran [Brief Review into the Urbanization and urban planning in Iran], edited by M. Y. Kiani. 205–229. Tehran: Homa.
–––. 1995. “Behshahr (Ashrafol Belad), paytakht-e tabestani” [Behshahr (Ashraf al-Belad): the summer capital].” In Paytakht Ha-ye Iran [The Capitals of Iran], edited by M. Y. Kiani, 611–620. Tehran: Administration of Cultural Heritage of Iran (Persian).
Karimi, F. 1989. “Kashan.” In Shahr Ha-ye Iran [The Cities of Iran]. Vol. 3, edited by M. Y. Kiani, 203–233. Tehran: Academic Center for Education, Culture and Research and Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance (Persian).
Krusinski, J. T. 1984. Safarnameh-ye Krusinski; Yaddasht Ha-ye Keshish-e Lahestani-e Asr-e Safavi [The Logbook of Krusinski; Notes of a Polish Priest of the Safavid Era]. Transl. A. Donbali, edited by M. Mir-Ahmadi. Tehran: Toos (Persian). Translation of The History of the Late Revolutions of Persia: Taken from the Memoirs of Father Krusinski (London: J. Pemberton, 1733)
Lafont, F., and Rabino, H. L. 1993. Sanʿat-e Noghan Dar Iran [Sericulture Industry in Iran]. Transl. J. K. Zadeh. Tehran: Institute of Cultural Studies and Research (Persian).
Lambton, A. K. S. 1998. Malek Va Zare Dar Iran [Landlord and Peasant in Persia]. Transl. M. Amiri. 4th edn. Tehran: Elmi Farhangi (Persian).
–––. 2000. Nazariyeh Dowlat Dar Iran [Theory and Practice in Medieval Persian Government]. 2nd edn. Transl. C. Pahlavan. Tehran: Giv (Persian).
Lambton, A. K. S., and Sourdel-Thomine, F. 2007. “Isfahan.” In Historic Cities of the Islamic World, edited by C. E. Bosworth, 167–180. Leiden: Brill.
Mackenzie, C. F. 1980. Safarnameh Shomal; Gozaresh-e Avalin Consul-e Englis Dar Rasht Az Safar Be Mazandaran Va Estar Abad [The Logbook of the North Iran; Report of Charles Francis Mackenzie, the First British Consul in Rasht, to Visit Mazandaran and Astarabad]. Transl. M. Ettehadiyeh. Tehran: Gostareh (Persian). Translation of MS FO 60/245, National Archives, Kew, UK, dated 1859.
Mahjouri, E. 1966. Tarikh-e Mazandaran [The History of Mazandaran]. Vol. 2. Sari: Asar (Persian).
Marvi, M. K. 1985. Alam Araye Naderi. Edited by M. A. Riyahi. Vo1. 1. Tehran: Zavvar (Persian).
Matthee, R. 2008. Siasat-e Tejarat Dar Iran-e Asr-e Safavi [The Politics of Trade in Safavid Iran]. Transl. H. Zandiyeh. Tehran: Research Institute of Hawzeh and University (Persian).
Mohammadi, M., and Rezaei, M. 2020. “Tahlil-e bastan shenakhti-e qelaʿe arbabi shahrestan-e Bahar, Ostan-e Hamedan [Archaeological analysis of landlord’s fortifications in Bahar county, Hamadan Province].” Journal of Historical Sociology 12.1: 232–265 (Persian).
Mohammadmoradi, A., Salehi, K. A. and Raie, H. 2017. “Aghazi bar fahm-e mazareʿe maskoon-e tarikhi dar Yazd [An inception on the perception of the inhabiting farmsteads in Yazd].” Journal of Research in Islamic Architecture 4.4: 1–21 (Persian).
Morier, J. J. N. 2007. Safarnameh James Morier (The Logbook of Morier). Vol. 1, Transl. A. Serri. Tehran: Toos (Persian). Translation of A Journey through Iran, Armenia and Asia Minor to Constantinople in the Years 1808 and 1809 (London: Longman, 1812).
Motevalli, A. 2013. “Shaloodeh ha-ye shahri va monasebat-e ghodrat az foroopashi Afshariyeh ta marg-e Karim Khan-e Zand [Urban bases and power relations from the collapse of Afsharids up to the death of Karim Khan Zand].” Historical Sciences Studies 4.2: 63–83 (Persian).
Naraghi, H. 1966. Tarikh-e Ejtemaee Kashan [The Social History of Kashan]. Tehran: University of Tehran (Persian).
Nomani, F. 1979. Takamol-e Feudalism Dar Iran [The Origin and Development of Feudalism in Iran: 300–1600 AD]. Vol. 1. Tehran: Kharazmi (Persian).
Noorasi, H., and Eʿzazi, S. 2015. “Moʿarefi-ye Masjed-e Khan-e Tiran [An introduction of Khan Mosque in Tiran].” Paper presented at the 2nd National Conference on Archaeology of Iran, University of Birjand. https://en.civilica.com/doc/541013/
Noori, M. 2006. “Simaye koliye tejarat-e kharejiye Iran dar doreh Afshariyeh va Zandiyeh [The general aspect of Iran’s foreign trade in the Afshari and Zandi periods].” Moskuya 3: 131–152 (Persian).
O’Flynn, T. 2017. The Western Christian Presence in the Russias and Qajar Persia, c.1760–c.1870. Studies in Christian Mission 47. Leiden: Brill. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004313545
Olivier, G. A. 1992. Safarnameh Olivier [The Logbook of Olivier]. Transl. M. T. Mirza, edited by G. Varhram. Tehran: Ettelaʿat (Persian). Translation of Voyage dans l’empire othoman, l’Egypte et la Perse (Paris: Chez H. Agasse, 1807).
Otter, J. 1984. Safarname Jonas Otter; Asr-e Nader Shah [The Logbook of Jonas Otter; Nader Shah Era]. Transl. A. Eqbali. Tehran: Javidan (Persian). Translation of Voyage en Turquie et en Perse (Paris: Freres Guérin, 1748).
Pazouki N., and Shadmehr, A. 2005. Asar-e Sabt Shodeh Iran Dar Fehrest-e Asar-e Melli [Recorded Monuments by Iran in the National Monuments from 1931 to 2005]. Tehran: Cultural Heritage and Tourism Organization of Iran (Persian).
Polak, J. 1989. Safarnameh Polak; Iran Va Iranian [The Logbook of Polak; Iran and Iranians]. Transl. K. Jahandari. Tehran: Kharazmi (Persian). Translation of Persien: Das Land und seine Bewohner (Leipzig: F. A. Brodhaus, 1865)
Raei, H. 2016. “Dar jost-o-jooye mazareʿe maskoon-e arbabi doreh Qajar Dar Niasar [In search of manorial residential farms of Qajar dynasty in Niasar].” Studies on Kashan 9.1: 110–131 (Persian).
Ravandi, M. 1978. Tarikh-e Ejtemaee Iran [The Social History of Iran]. Vol. 3. 3rd edn. Tehran: Amirkabir (Persian).
–––. 1985. Tarikh-e Ejtemaee Iran [The Social History of Iran]. Vol. 5. 3rd edn. Tehran: Roozbahan (Persian).
Rezaei, M. 2020. “Payamad ha-ye ejtemaee balaya-ye tabiʿee dar Tabriz [Social consequences of natural disasters in Tabriz].” Social History Studies 10.19: 175–198 (Persian).
Rostam al-Hokama, M. H. A. 2003. Rostam Al-Tavarikh [The Histories of Rostam], edited by M. Mehrabadi. Tehran: Donyaye Ketab (Persian).
Sarfaraz, A. A., and F. Avarzamani. 2012. Sekkeh Ha-ye Iran; Az Aghaz Ta Dore Zandiyeh [Iranian Coins; From the Beginning to the Zandiyeh Era]. 9th edn. Tehran: SAMT (Persian).
Savory, R. M. 2010. Iran-e Asr-e Safavi [Iran Under the Safavids]. Transl. K. Azizi. 19th edn. Tehran: Markaz (Persian).
Shaʿbani, R., and Mohammadi, H. 2008. “Taʿsir-e hamle-ye Mahmoud Afghan bar ozaʿe siasi va ejtemaʿee Iran [The influence of Mahmoud Afghan’s attack on the political and social situation in Iran].” Moskuya 9: 165–206 (Persian).
Sykes, S. P. M. 1956. Tarikh-e Iran [A History of Persia]. Vol. 2. Transl. S. M. F. Daʿee. Tehran: Zavvar (Persian).
–––. 2009. Tarikh-e Mokhtasar-e Iran [A Brief History of Iran]. Transl. H. S. Noori. Tehran: Sales (Persian).
Taheri, A. 1968. Joghrafiyaye Tarikhi-e Gilan, Mazandaran Va Azerbaijan Az Nazar-e Jahangardan [The Historical geography of Gilan, Mazandaran and Azerbaijan According to the Tourists]. Tehran: Central Council of the Imperial Iranian Celebration (Persian).
Tajbakhsh, A. 2001. Tarikh-e Tamadon Va Farhang-e Iran; Doreye Qajariyeh [History of Civilization and Culture of Islamic Iran; Qajar Era]. Shiraz: Navid-e Shiraz (Persian).
Welch, A. 2003. “Safavi Iran seen through Venetian eyes.” In Society and Culture in the Early Modern Middle East; Studies on Iran in the Safavid Period, edited by A. J. Newman, 97–121. Leiden: Brill. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789047401711_009
Werner, C. 2000. An Iranian Town in Transition: A Social and Economic History of the Elites of Tabriz 1747–1848. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz.
Young, R., and Fazeli, H. 2018. “Landlord villages of Iran as examples of political economy and materiality.” Post-Medieval Archaeology 52.1: 34–48. https://doi.org/10.1080/00794236.2018.1460150
Zare, S. 2008. Gozaresh-e Dovomin Fasl-e Barrasi Bastan Shenasi Dar Shahrestan-e Bam [The Report of the Second Season of Archaeological Survey in Bam County]. Archives of administration of cultural heritage in Kerman (Persian).
Zarei, M., and Heidari Babakamal, Y. 2014. “Ahamiyat-e qela va estehkamat-e dore Qajar-e mantagheh Shahdad dar bargharari-e amniyat-e ejtemaee hashiyeh gharbi-e kavir-e Lut [The role of the Qajar fortifications of the Shahdad region in the social security of western margins of the Lut desert).” Pazhoheshha-ye Bastan shenasi Iran 4.6: 195–211 (Persian).
Zarrabi, A. 1999. Tarikh-e Kashan [The History of Kashan], edited by I. Afshar. Tehran: Amirkabir (Persian).