From Polemical to Dialogical Encounter
The Significance of Pluralism in Contemporary Ahmadi Muslim-Christian Relations
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/isit.26564Keywords:
Aḥmadī Muslim-Christian Relations, Interreligious Dialogue, Interfaith Understanding, Ghulām Aḥmad, John Alexander DowieAbstract
In 1902, Ghulam Ahmad, the Indo-Pakistani founder of the Ahmadiyah Muslim Community—a revivalist, messianic movement within Sunni Islam—issued “an answer” to John Alexander Dowie’s, the Scottish-born non-denominationalist Christian preacher and forerunner of modern-day Pentecostalism’s, impassioned renunciation of the Islamic faith. In doing so, Ahmad invited Dowie to engage him in a mubahala, or a “prayer duel” to the death, to determine the truthfulness or fallacy of each other’s faith expression. With Dowie’s subsequent passing in 1907, Ahmad’s presumed “great victory” became one of the foundational narratives upon which Ahmadi Muslims constructed the validity of the Ahmadiyah and, consequently, structured their relationship with Christians. In this article, I explore the general contours of this mubahala invitation as well as Ahmadis differing responses to its historical and contemporaneous narrativization. Due to increased contact between Ahmadis and Christians living in the West, I contend that Ahmadi narratives surrounding this event, while historically polemical in nature, ultimately became the cornerstone upon which a positive and constructive Ahmadi Muslim-Christian engagement could be fostered, namely one built on shared collegiality and reciprocal, interfaith understanding garnered through deep, pluralistic encounter.
References
Ahmad, Khurshid. N.d. “Death of Dr. Dowie.” In A Brief History of Ahmadiyah Muslim Community, translated by Zakaria Virk. https://www.alislam.org/book/brief-history-ahmadiyya-muslim/death-dr-dowie/.
Al-Islam. N.d. “A Spiritual Challenge – Mubahala with Maulvi Sanaullah Amritsari.” Ahmadiyya Muslim Community. https://www.alislam.org/ahmadiyya-history/spiritual-challenge-mubahala-maulvi-sanaullah-amritsari/.
Anjuman-i Isha'at-i Islam, Qadian. 1902. “The Objects of the Magazine.” The Review of Religions, 2–10. https://www.reviewofreligions.org/wp-content/uploads/pdf/RR190201.pdf.
———. 2012. “The Great Victory.” The Review of Religions. https://www.reviewofreligions.org/7840/the-great-victory/.
Black, Lisa. 2012a. “Muslims Part of Zion’s History.” Chicago Tribune, June 24, 2012
———.2012b. “‘Prayer Duel’ Led to Ties with Muslim Movement.” Chicago Tribune, June 24, 2012.
Blumhofer, Edith L. 1989. The Assemblies of God: A Chapter in the Story of American Pentecostalism. Volume 1. Springfield: Gospel Publishing House.
Cook, Philip L. 1970. Zion City, Illinois: John Alexander Dowie’s Theocracy. Edited by Jabez Taylor, 2nd ed. Zion: Zion Historical Society.
Cornille, Catherine. 2008. The Im-Possibility of Interreligious Dialogue. New York: The Crossroad Publishing Company.
Dowie, John Alexander, editor. 1894a. Leaves of Healing 1, no. 1: 1–16.
———. 1894b. Leaves of Healing 1, no. 8: 113–128.
———. 1897a. Leaves of Healing 3, no. 30: 529–544.
———. 1897b. Leaves of Healing 3, no. 34: 529–544.
———. 1900a. Leaves of Healing 6, no. 17: 521–552.
———. 1902. Leaves of Healing 12, no. 17: 513–544.
Evans, Nicholas H. A. 2020. Far from the Caliph’s Gaze: Being Ahmadi Muslim in the Holy City of Qadian. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Faupel, D. William. 2007. “Theological Influences on the Teachings and Practices of John Alexander Dowie.” Pneuma 29, no. 2: 226–253.
Geaves, Ron. 2017. Islam and Britain: Muslim Mission in an Age of Empire. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
Ghulam Ahmad, Mirza. 1902. “An Answer to Dowie’s Prediction of a General Destruction of All Muhammadans.” The Review of Religions 1, no. 9: 337–349.
Gloege, Timothy E. W. 2013. “Faith Healing, Medical Regulation, and Public Religion in Progressive Era Chicago.” Religion and American Culture 23, no. 2: 185–231.
Green, Arnold H. 2001. “Mormonism and Islam: From Polemics to Mutual Respect and Cooperation.” BYU Studies Quarterly 40, no. 4: 199–220.
Haddad, Yvonne Yazbeck and Jane Idleman Smith. 1993. Mission to America Five Islamic Sectarian Communities in North America. Gainesville: University Press of Florida.
Harlan, Rolvix. 1906. “John Alexander Dowie and the Christian Catholic Apostolic Church in Zion.” Doctoral dissertation. The University of Chicago.
Janusko, Robert. 1992. “More on J. A. Dowie (& Son).” James Joyce Quarterly 29, no. 3: 607–613.
Khan, Muhammad Zafrulla. N.d. “Victory of Prayer Over Prejudice.” https://www.alislam.org/book/victory-prayer-prejudice/.
Kuiper, Matthew J. 2021. Da’wa: A Global History of Islamic Missionary Thought and Practice. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Larson, Marion and Sara Shady. 2009. “Interfaith Dialogue in a Pluralistic World: Insights from Martin Buber and Miroslav Volf.” Journal of College and Character 10, no. 3: 1–9.
Lindsay, Gordon. 1980. John Alexander Dowie: A Life Story of Trials Tragedies and Triumphs. Dallas: Christ for the Nations.
Madigan, Daniel A. 2011. “Muslim Christian Dialogue in Difficult Times.” In Catholicism and Interreligious Dialogue. Edited by James L. Heft, 57–74. New York: Oxford University Press.
———.2013 “A Christian Perspective on Muslim Prayer.” In Prayer: Christian and Muslim Perspective. Edited by David Marshall and Lucinda Mosher, 65–72. Washington: Georgetown University Press.
Marable, Manning. 2011. Malcom X: The Life of Reinvention. New York: Basic Books.
Micklem, Nathaniel. 1941. The Theology of Politics. London: Oxford University Press.
Mikati, Rana. 2019. “Cross My Heart and Hope to Die: A Diachronic Examination of the Mutual Self-Cursing (Mubahala) in Islam.” The Journal of the American Oriental Society 139, no. 2: 317–331.
Miller, Emily McFarlan. 2022. “Ahmadi Muslims Inaugurate New Mosque on Site of Historic ‘Prayer Duel.’” Religion News online. https://religionnews.com/2022/09/30/ahmadi-muslims-inaugurate-new-mosque-on-site-of-historic-prayer-duel/.
Moore, Kathleen M. 2014. “Da‘wah in the United States.” In The Oxford Handbook of American Islam. Edited by Yvonne Y. Haddad and Jane I. Smith, 268–285. New York: Oxford University Press.
Padfield, David. N.d. “Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam.” The Church of Christ in Zion, Illinois online. https://www.padfield.com/2000/islam.html.
Patel, Eboo. 2007. Acts of Faith: The Story of an American Muslim, the Struggle for the Soul of a Generation. Boston: Beacon Press.
Ryan, Nancy. 2000a. “Islamic Sect Hosts Conference Feud From 1900s Spurs Zion Event.” Chicago Tribune, August 10, 2000.
———.2000b. “Old Feud Spurs Religious Gathering: Islamic Sect Hosting Event in Honor of Founder Dowie.” Chicago Tribune, August 10, 2000.
———.2000c. “Religious Feud From 1900s Spurs Interfaith Gathering.” Chicago Tribune, August 10, 2000.
———. 2000d. “97 Years Later, Muslims Back in Zion Old Wounds Heal; 2-Day Meeting Seeks Friendship.” Chicago Tribune August 12, 2000.
Sadiq, Muhammad Mufti. 1922. The Moslem Sunrise 1, no. 6: 125–153.
“The End of Dowie.” N.d. Ahmadi Answers. https://ahmadianswers.com/ahmad/truth/prophecies/dowie/.
“2015 Events and Activities.” N.d. Interfaith Conference of Greater Milwaukee. https://interfaithconference.org/2015-events-and-activities.
Valentine, Simon Ross. 2008. Islam and the Ahmadiyya Jama‘at: History, Belief, Practice. New York: Columbia University Press.
Walter, H. A. 1918. The Ahmadiya Movement. Calcutta: Association Press.