The Co-constitution of Bad Religion and Unethical Sales
Fear at the Heart of Japan’s “Spiritual Sales”
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/imre.27205Keywords:
consumer law, psychics, spiritual sales, Japan, fraudAbstract
Legal decisions surrounding activities associated with beliefs often described as “religious” usually conflate with laws and regulations that delineate other aspects of the context in which such activities occur. For example, transactions with psychics or fortune tellers usually need to abide by general consumer protection laws. In this article, I argue that controversies surrounding frauds and other troubles occurring during such transactions point to the equation “bad religion=unethical sales.” To explain my argument, I first compare the rise of “spiritual sales” as a legal category in Japan in the last 35 years, to British regulations of mediumship. I then
proceed to locate the emotion of “fear” at the centre of debates about the appropriateness of these laws for consumer protection. I end up concluding that “spiritual sales” are yet another example in which, today, the consumer’s negative feelings have become the basis for claims of illegality, in contrast to how positive feelings are proof of sincerity and transparency.
References
Abrams, Kathryn and Hila Keren. 2010. “Who’s Afraid of Law and the Emotions?” Minnesota Law Review 94: 1997–2074. https://scholarship.law.umn.edu/mlr/517/
Beek, Jan, Cassis Kilian and Matthias Krings. 2019. “Mapping Out an Anthropology of Defrauding and Faking.” Social Anthropology 27: 425–437. https://doi.org/10.1111/1469-8676.12698
Clements, Luke and Rachel Morris. 1996. “Fraudulent and Incompetent Mediums.” New Law Journal 146: 1574–1576.
de Corde, Henri. 2014. “The Dang Case: When Chakras Opening Leads to a Belgian Criminal Count.” In Legal Cases, New Religious Movements, and Minority Faiths, edited by James T. Richardson and François Bellanger, 119–128. Surrey: Ashgate.
Gaitanidis, Ioannis. 2022. Spirituality and Alternativity in Contemporary Japan Beyond Religion? London: Bloomsbury. https://doi.org/10.5040/9781350262645
Greenfield, Steve. Guy Osborn and Stephanie Roberts. 2012. “From Beyond the Grave: The Legal Regulation of Mediumship.” International Journal of Law in Context 8(1): 97–114. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1744552311000383
Ito, Masataka. 1987. “On the Track of ‘Divine Sales’ People.” Japan Quarterly. July-September, 300–304.
Jameson, Sam. 1985. “Cameramen Wait Passively as Attack Is Committed. Murder in Japan: A Media Event.” The Los Angeles Times. 19 June. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1985-06-19-mn-9226-story.html [accessed 30 September 2023]
Kito Masaki. 2018. ”’Reikan shoho’ o kisei suru shohisha keiyakuho kaiseian ga seiritsu [Proposed amendment to the Consumer Contract Law to regulate ‘spiritual sales’ passed].” Consumer Law News 117: 64–65.
Martin, Craig. 2023. A Critical Introduction to the Study of Religion. 3rd edition. London: Routledge.
McLaughlin , Levi , Aike P. Rots , Jolyon B. Thomas and Chika Watanabe. 2020. “Why Scholars of Religion Must Investigate the Corporate Form.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 88(3): 693–725. https://doi.org/10.1093/jaarel/lfaa041
McCrary, Charles. 2018. “Fortune Telling and American Religious Freedom.” Religion and American Culture 28(2): 269–306. https://doi.org/10.1525/rac.2018.28.2.269
McLaughlin, Levi. 2022. “A Grudge Against the Unification Church Motivated the Murder of Japan’s Most Prominent Politician.” criticalasianstudies.org Commentary Board, July 13. https://doi.org/10.52698/RUVM3596.
Oga Shuichi. 1994. “Fukuoka kenkin sosho hanketsu no hokoku [Report on the judgment in the Fukuoka donation lawsuit].” Consumer Law News 21: 44.
Patrick, Jeremy. 2020. Faith or Fraud: Fortune-Telling, Spirituality, and the Law. Vancouver: UBC Press. https://doi.org/10.59962/9780774863346
Poster, Winifred R. 2022. “Introduction to Special Issue on Scams, Fakes, and Frauds.” New Media & Society 24(7): 1535–1547. https://doi.org/10.1177/14614448221099232
Rivers, Julian. 2010. The Law of Organised Religions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sharkey, Heather J. and Jeffrey Edward Green, eds. 2021. The Changing Terrain of Religious Freedom. Philadelphia, PA: Princeton University Press. https://doi.org/10.9783/9780812298307
RCLN, Religion and Consumers Lawyers’ Network, ed. 1996. Shukyo meimoku ni your akutoku shoho [Malicious business practices in the name of religion]. Tokyo: Ryokufu shuppan.
Shigesawa Atsuko. 1993. “Toyota Shoji fraud victims lose lawsuit.” The Japan News. 7 October.
Tanamura Masayuki. 2022. “Shukyo ni karamu akushitsuna kan’yu koi to hoteki sekinin [Legal liability and malicious solicitation practices involving religion].” Consumer Law News 130: 137–139.
Tsuya Hirotaka, Oga Shuichi, Ibaraki Shigeru and Ishitoya Yutaka. 2000. Sakimono torihiki higai no kyusai [Remedies for futures trading damage]. Tokyo: Minjiho kenkyukai.
White, Erick. 2005. “Fraudulent and Dangerous Popular Religiosity in the Public Sphere: Moral Campaigns to Prohibit, Reform, and Demistify Thai Spirit Mediums.” In Spirited Politics: Religion and Public Life in Contemporary Southeast Asia, edited by Andrew C. Willford and Kenneth M. George, 69–91. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. https://doi.org/10.7591/9781501719486-005
Yamaguchi Hiroshi. 1993. Kensho toitsu kyokai: reikan shoho no jittai [Verification of the Unification Church: The reality of spiritual sales]. Tokyo: Ryokufu shuppan.
———. 2020. “Reikan shoho [Spiritual Sales].” In Shohishaho hanrei hyaku sen [Leading cases in consumer law], 2nd edition, 98–99. Tokyo: Yukihaku.
Yamaguchi Hiroshi, Kito Masaki and Takimoto Taro. 1999. Q&A Shukyo toraburu 110 ban: Shinobiyoru karuto [Q&A for police emergencies for troubles with religion: Creeping cults]. Tokyo: Minjiho kenkyukai.
Yamaguchi Hiroshi, Hirata Hiroshi, Nakamura Shuji, and Kito Masaki. 2000. Karuto shukyo no toraburu taisaku: Nihon to obei no jitsujo to torikumi [Countermeasures against cult issues: Current situations and initiatives in Japan, Europe and the United States]. Tokyo: Kyoiku shiryo shuppankai.
Yamaguchi Hiroshi, Sataka Makoto, Kawai Yasuo, Abe Katsuomi, Kimura Sou, Nakagawa Ryo and Kubouchi Hirotsugu. 2022. Toitsukyokai to no tatakai: 35 nen, soshite korekara [The 35-year struggle against the Unification Church: Looking into the future] Tokyo: Junposha.
Yamauchi Koji. 1987. “Na o katari ni nise chumon: Korinai iyagarase o kokuhatsu [Passing false orders: Accusations of harassment with no recourse].” Asahi Janaru [Asahi Journal] 29(37): 15.
Zenkoku reikan shoho taisaku bengoshi renrakukai, Zenkoku genri undo higaisha chichihaha no kai, Nihon kirisutokyodan toitsu genri mondai renrakukai. 1997. Toitsu kyokai godo kekkonshiki no teguchi to jittai [The modus operandi and reality of the Unification Church’s mass weddings]. Tokyo: Ryokufu shuppan.
