Historical Narratives and Spatial Strategies of Reappropriation in Three Romanian Orthodox Monasteries
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1558/firn.29312Keywords:
multi-religious interaction, Romania, Orthodoxy, pilgrimage, Greek-Catholicism, lived religion, IslamAbstract
Contrary to the abundance of shared religious places throughout south-eastern Europe, multi-religious interaction is not a regular feature in Romania. Pilgrimages and visits to the popular Orthodox monasteries of Prislop and Nicula in Transylvania and Dervent in Dobruja are an exception to this trend. Unsurprisingly, these two regions are historically characterized by a remarkable ethnic and religious diversity. The two Transylvanian monasteries attract practitioners of different Christian denominations (Orthodox, Greek-Catholic, Roman-Catholic and Evangelical), while Dervent is a devotional site for Christians and Muslims (Tatars, Turks and Roma) alike. Common to all three monasteries is the presence of allegedly miracle-working objects, artefacts and bodies: a stone cross at Dervent, the Virgin Mary icon at Nicula, and the tomb of the charismatic monk Arsenie Boca at Prislop, respectively. Based on ethnographic fieldwork conducted in the three monasteries during both important feasts and everyday monastic life, this article is a multidisciplinary exploration of the workings of inter-religious competition, sharing and interaction. It combines the methods typical of ethnographic research with observations on how the religious space is navigated and socialized through the support of cartography and archival satellite images. The article casts light on how the historical narratives and spatial strategies enacted by the Romanian Orthodox Church overlap in the attempt to reclaim legitimate ownership and exclusive primacy over three popular devotional sites with a composite ethnic and religious past.
Downloads
References
Alexa, Liviu 2019 Biserica de piatra a Manastirii Nicula este renovata cu buldozerul, fara avize si autorizatii legale. Online: https://ziardecluj.ro/biserica-de-piatra-a-manastiriinicula-este-renovata-cu-buldozerul-fara-avize-si-autorizatii-legale/ (accessed 9 October 2023).
Banica, Mirel 2014 Nevoia de miracol. Bucharest: Polirom.
Barbu, Daniel 1998 Byzance, Rome, et les Roumains: essais sur la production politique de la foi au Moyen age. Bucarest: Éditions Babel.
Bichis, Cristian (ed.) 2014 Parintele Arsenie Boca ne cheama la el. Marturii de la Prislop. Bucharest: Editura Ortodoxia.
Blasen, Philippe Henri 2011 Le Cas Nicula. Cluj-Napoca: Editura Mega.
Bojor, Victor 1930 Maica Domnului de la Nicula. Gherla: Editura Manastirii de la Nicula.
Buzalka, Juraj 2008 Syncretism among the Greek Catholic Ukrainians in Southeast Poland. In Churches in-between: Greek Catholic Churches in Postsocialist Europe, edited by Stephanie Mahieu and Vlad Naumescu, 183–206. Berlin: LIT.
Ciocioi, Gheorghita, and Serban Tica 2010 Ghidul manastirilor din România. Bucharest: Sophia.
Cobzaru, Dumitru 2020 Monografia Manastirii “Adormirea Maicii Domnului” Nicula. Cluj-Napoca: Editura Renasterea.
Cosma, Valer Simion 2023 Despre preoti si tarani sau cum am intersectat istoria cu antropologia pentru a întelege religia taraneasca. Antropedia. Online: https://antropedia.com/sfertulacademic/valer-simion-cosma-despre-preoti-si-tarani-sau-cum-am-intersectat-istoria-cu-antropologia-pentru-a-intelege-religia-taraneasca/ (accessed 20 September 2023).
Cozma, Ioan 2012 I beni temporali nei rapporti tra ortodossi e greco-cattolici in Romania. Rome: Pontificio Istituto Orientale (Kanonika 18).
Cozma, Ioan 2021 The Interreligious Complex at Vulcana-Bai in Romania: A Multi-Religious Place Between Idealism and Pragmatism. In Geography of Encounters: The Making and Unmaking Spaces, edited by Marian Burchardt and Maria Chiara Giorda, 179–203. London: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-82525-6_9
Crihalmeanu, Florentin 2020 Vecernia la biserica greco-catolica din Nicula. uploaded by Comunicatii— Episcopia de Cluj-Gherla. Online: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_LbNZkdAGq0&t=3607s (accessed 26 September 2023).
Druche, Ionut 2020 Crucile de la Dervent, facatoare de minuni pentru crestini, musulmani, dar si pentru animale. Dobrogea Live, 14 September. Online: https://dobrogealive.ro/crucile-de-la-dervent-facatoare-de-minuni-pentru-cretini-musulmani-dar-ipentru-animale/ (accessed 20 September 2023).
Dumitran, Ana, Eniko Hegedus and Vasile Rus 2011 Fecioarele înlacrimate ale Transilvaniei preliminarii la o istorie ilustrata a tolerantei religioase. exhibition at the National Union Museum, Alba Iulia, 14 October–11 November 2011.
Farcas, Tiberiu 2020 Scandalul De La Nicula. Pozitia Mitropoliei Ortodoxe. Online: https://clujulcultural.ro/scandalul-de-la-nicula-pozitia-mitropoliei-ortodoxe/ (accessed 21 October 2023).
Giusca, Madalina 2020 Religious Tourism and Pilgrimage at Prislop Monastery, Romania: Motivations, Faith and Perceptions. Human Geographies 14(1): 149–67. https://doi.org/10.5719/hgeo.2020.141.9
Hagiul, Macarie 1933 Crucea facatoare de minuni din Dobrogea. Cu acatistul. Cernica: Tipografia seminarului monahal.
Hann, Chris 2014 The Heart of the Matter Christianity, Materiality, and Modernity. Current Anthropology 55(10): S182–S192. https://doi.org/10.1086/678184
Hasluck, Frederick W. 1929 Christianity and Islam Under the Sultans. Edited by Margaret Hasluck. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Reprint 2006.
Jiga Iliescu, Laura 2023 Oneiric Authentication of a Miraculous Shrine: Case Study from a Dobruja Monastery, Romania. Martor 28: 125–37. https://doi.org/10.57225/martor.2023.28.08
Mahieu, Stéphanie 2004 Legal Recognition and Recovery of Property: Contested Restitution of Romanian Greek Catholic Church Patrimony. Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology Working Papers 69: 1–16.
Pacurariu, Mircea 2006 Sfinti daco – romani si români. Apologeticum. Online: https://www.academia.edu/25124641/Mircea_Pacurariu_Sfinti_daco_romani_si_romani.
Petcu, Adrian Nicolae, and Florin Dobrin 2017 Misiunea duhovniceasca a Parintelui Arsenie Boca în mijlocul calugaritelor greco-catolice din tinutul Clujului (mai-iunie 1949). In Slujire—marturisire—patimire în Biserica lui Hristos, edited by Florin Dobrei, 198–214. Alba Iulia: Editura Reîntregirea.
Rohdewald, Stefan 2017 Sari Saltuk im osmanischen Rumelien, der Rus’ und Polen-Litauen. Zugänge zu einer transosmanischen religiösen Erinnerungsfigur (14.–20. Jh.). In Heilig. Transkulturelle Verehrungskulte vom Mittelalter bis in die Gegenwart, edited by Dietlind Hüchtker and Kerstin Jobst, 67–98. Göttingen: Wallstein-Verlag.
Serban, Stelu 2010 Pilgrimage and Nationhood in a Transylvanian Village. In Religion and boundaries: Studies from the Balkans, Eastern Europe, and Turkey, edited by Galia Valtchinova, 167–86. Istanbul: The ISIS Press.
Stan, Lavinia, and Lucian Turcescu 2007 Religion and Politics in Post-Communist Romania. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195308532.001.0001
Tateo, Giuseppe 2020 Under the Sign of the Cross: The People’s Salvation Cathedral and the Church Building Industry in Postsocialist Romania. New York and London: Berghahn Books. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv21hrfz4
Tudor, Andrei 2009 Istoria Crucilor de leac de la Manastirea Dervent. Constanta: Tomis Archiepiscopate Publishing.
Verdery, Katherine 1999 The Political Lives of Dead Bodies. New York: Columbia University Press.
Verzan, Sabin 2016 Sfantul Apostol Andrei. Bucharest: Basilica.
Zerilli, Filippo M. 2008 ‘Real Men’ in Postsocialist Transition. The Greek Catholic Ethic and the Spirit of Neoliberalism in a Transylvanian Village. In Churches In-between. Greek Catholic Churches in Postsocialist Europe, edited by Stéphanie Mahieu and Vlad Naumescu, 233–54. Berlin: LIT Verlag.
