Disposal of a Homicide Victim by Dismemberment and Burning

The Contribution of Forensic Anthropology and Archaeology in Reconstructing the Crime

Authors

  • Julie Roberts Liverpool John Moores University
  • Alison Baldry Lancashire Constabulary

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1558/aefs.18070

Keywords:

Anthropology, Archaeology, Burnt Remains, cutmarks, reconstruction

Abstract

Burning can have a profound effect on the appearance of bone and increase its susceptibility to mechanical damage. In criminal cases where there has been a deliberate attempt to dispose of human remains in this way; there is also often a need to distinguish between damage caused by heat, ante-mortem and peri-mortem trauma, and post-mortem damage. This case demonstrates how the forensic anthropologist and archaeologist contributed to a complex investigation where a homicide victim had been dismembered, burned and concealed. The use of archaeological and anthropological techniques at the scene, in the mortuary and the laboratory, provided evidence that enabled the sequence of events surrounding the disposal of the deceased to be reconstructed. The expert witness testimony given in court showed the benefits of employing these skills and assisted in securing the conviction of the offenders who are both serving life sentences.

Author Biographies

Julie Roberts, Liverpool John Moores University

Dr Julie Roberts is a lecturer in Forensic Anthropology at Liverpool John Moores University. Her research interests are focussed on Disaster Victim Identification (DVI), war crimes investigations, and the identification and interpretation of burnt and / or dismembered remains, particularly in relation to the deliberate disposal of homicide victims.

Alison Baldry, Lancashire Constabulary

Alison Baldry is an archaeologist and CSI at Lancashire Constabulary. She has a particular interest in conflict archaeology and is involved with field projects investigating the history and archaeology of the Great Arab Revolt during WWI. More recent research is WWII focused, based in Italy, with the Military History Live archaeology group. This research is a comprehensive field-based investigation of an entire second World War battlefield.

References

Bontrager, Amanda B and Stephen P. Nawrocki. 2008. “A Taphonomic Analysis of Human Cremains from the Fox Hollow Farm Serial Homicide site”. In The Analysis of Burnt Human Remains by Christopher W Schmidt and Steven A Symes, 211-226. Elsevier, Ltd: Academic Press

Buikstra, Jane E and M Swegle. 1989. “Bone Modification due to Burning: Experimental Evidence”. In Bone Modification by Robsen Bonnichsen and Marcella H Sorg, 247–258. Center for the Study of the First Americans, University of Maine, Orono, ME.

CIfA (Chartered Institute for Archaeologists), 2014. Standards and guidance for forensic archaeologists. https://www.archaeologists.net/sites/default/files/CIfAS&GForensics_2.pdf [Accessed 04/08/2020]

De Gruchy, Spencer and Tracey L Rogers. 2002. “Identifying Chop Marks on Cremated Bone: A Preliminary Study”. Journal of Forensic Sciences 47, no 5: 993-936

John D DeHaan. 2015. “Fire and Bodies”. In The Analysis of Burnt Human Remains, Second Edition by Christopher W. Schmidt and Steven A. Symes, 1-15. Elsevier, Ltd: Academic Press

John D DeHaan and S Nurbakhsh. 2001. “Sustained Combustion of an Animal Carcass and its Implications for the Consumption of Human Bodies in Fires”. Journal of Forensic Sciences 46, no. 5:1076-1081

DeHaan, John D. 2002. Kirks Fire Investigation, Fifth Edition. New Jersey: Prentice Hall: 26

Ellingham, Sarah, T D, Tim J U Thompson, and Meez Islam. 2018. Scanning Electron Microscopy–Energy Dispersive X-Ray (SEM/EDX): A Rapid Diagnostic Tool to Aid the Identification of Burnt Bone and Contested Cremains. Journal of Forensic Sciences 63, no. 2: 504-510

Goncalves, David, Tim J U Thompson and Eugenia Cunha. 2011. “Implications of Heat-Induced Changes in Bone on the Interpretation of Funerary Behaviour and Practice”. Journal of Archaeological Sciences 38: 1308-1313

J L Holden, Phakey P P and Clement J G. 1995. “Scanning Electron Microscope Observations of Heat-Treated Human Bone”. Forensic Science International 74:29-45

Hunter John and Margaret Cox. 2005. Forensic Archaeology: Advances in Theory and Practice. Routledge, Forensic Science Series

Imaizumi, Kazuhiko, K Taniguchi and Y Ogawa. 2014. “DNA Survival and Physical and Histological Properties of Heat-Induced Alterations in Burnt Bones”. International Journal of Legal Medicine 128: 439–446

Mays, Simon. 1999. The Archaeology of Human Bones. London and New York: Routledge: 207-224

Jacqueline I McKinley. 1994. “Bone Fragment Size in British Cremation Burials and its Implications for Pyre Technology and Ritual. Journal of Archaeological Science 21:339-342

Pope, Elayne J and O’Brian C Smith. 2004. “Identification of Traumatic Injury in Burned Cranial Bone: An Experimental Approach”. Journal of Forensic Sciences 49, no. 3:431-440

Reinhardt KJ and MT Fink. 1994. “Cremation in Southwestern North America: Aspects of Taphonomy that Affect Pathological Analysis”. Journal of Archaeological Sciences 21: 597-605

Shipman Patricia, G Foster G. and M Scheoninger. 1984 “Burnt Bones and Teeth: An Experimental Study of Color, Morphology, Crystal Structure and Shrinkage”. Journal of Archaeological Sciences 11: 307-325

Smith, O’Brian C, Steven A Symes, Elayne J Pope, C Gardner. 2001. “Burning Observations I: Identification of Normal Human Anatomical Patterns in a Thermal Event”. Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Science Forensic Science 7: 214

Symes Steven A, Christopher W Rainwater, Erin N Chapman, Desina R Gipson, Andrea L Piper. 2015. “Patterned Thermal Destruction of Human Remains in a Forensic Setting. In The Analysis of Burnt Human Remains, Second Edition by Christopher W. Schmidt and Steven A. Symes, 17-59. Elsevier, Ltd: Academic Press

Thompson, Tim J U. 2015. The Analysis of Heat-Induced Crystallinity Change in Bone. In The Analysis of Burnt Human Remains, Second Edition by Christopher W. Schmidt and Steven A. Symes, 323-339. Elsevier, Ltd: Academic Press

US Marine Corps. 2002. Survival Manual. Mountain Warfare Training Center, Bridgeport, California: 04.6-04.7

Published

2021-05-23

How to Cite

Roberts, Julie, and Alison Baldry. 2021. “Disposal of a Homicide Victim by Dismemberment and Burning: The Contribution of Forensic Anthropology and Archaeology in Reconstructing the Crime”. Archaeological and Environmental Forensic Science 2 (1):39–48. https://doi.org/10.1558/aefs.18070.

Issue

Section

Articles