Peering into the Minds of Gods

What Cross-Cultural Variation in Gods’ Concerns Can Tell Us about the Evolution of Religion


  • Theiss Bendixen Aarhus University
  • Benjamin Grant Purzycki Aarhus University



cognitive science of religion, cultural evolution, behavioral ecology, minds of gods, cultural evolutionary psychology, cognitive anthropology


Cross-cultural beliefs about gods’ concerns point to local socioecological challenges. Such appeals to gods’ concerns provide insights for understanding religious cognition specifically and the evolution of religious systems more generally. Here, we review case studies to this effect, and introduce the “god-problem problem”: to the extent that gods are concerned with local socioecological problems, which criteria does a problem need to satisfy in order to become an object of supernatural attention? We offer some preliminary solutions to this puzzle, which leads to a related, but often-overlooked, question: granted that features of religions may culturally evolve to adaptively fit to and resolve aspects of the local socioecological environment, what are the psychological processes through which this adaptation could occur? We wager that in order to answer the question satisfactorily, contemporary evolutionary approaches need to work together. Psychologically, the socioecological environment provides the initial impetus for a belief or practice by increasing the cognitive salience of a corresponding local problem and its costs. This increased receptivity makes such ideas and corollary behaviors easier to learn and transmit along the routes posited by dual-inheritance theorists. Behaviors feed back to beliefs and can offset the costs of social life in a variety of ways. As such, examining how cognition, social learning, behavior, and ecological pressures inform each other is especially crucial for understanding the persistence, diffusion, and evolution of religious ideas and practices.


Alcorta, C. S. and R. Sosis. 2005. “Ritual, Emotion, and Sacred Symbols: The Evolution of Religion as an Adaptive Complex.” Human Nature 16(4): 323–359.

Alexander, R. 1987. The Biology of Moral Systems. Abingdon: Routledge.

Andersen, M. 2019. “Predictive Coding in Agency Detection.” Religion, Brain & Behavior 9(1): 65–84.

Atran, S. and J. Henrich. 2010. “The Evolution of Religion: How Cognitive By-Products, Adaptive Learning Heuristics, Ritual Displays, and Group Competition Generate Deep Commitments to Prosocial Religions.” Biological Theory 5(1): 18–30.

Baimel, A. 2019. “The Contributions of Eco-spirituality to Pro-environmentalism.” Talk presented at the Fourth Annual Nordic Network for the Cognitive Sciences of Religion, Stockholm, Sweden.

Baldini, R. 2015. “Harsh Environments and ‘Fast’ Human Life Histories: What Does the Theory Say?” BioRxiv 014647.

Baron-Cohen, S. 1995. Mindblindness: An Essay on Autism and Theory of Mind. Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.

Baumard, N., A. Hyafil, I. Morris and P. Boyer. 2015. “Increased Affluence Explains the Emergence of Ascetic Wisdoms and Moralizing Religions.” Current Biology 25(1): 10–15.

Bednar, J. and S. Page. 2007. “Can Game(s) Theory Explain Culture? The Emergence of Cultural Behavior within Multiple Games.” Rationality and Society 19(1): 65–97.

Beheim, B., Q. Atkinson, J. Bulbulia, W. M. Gervais, R. Gray, J. Henrich, M. Lang, M. W. Monroe, M. Muthukrishna, A. Norenzayan, B. G. Purzycki, A. Shariff, E. Slingerland, R. Spicer and A. K. Willard. 2019. “Treatment of Missing Data Determines Conclusions Regarding Moralizing Gods.” Preprint. PsyArXiv.

Bendixen, T. 2019. “Sense or Non-sense? A Critical Discussion of a Recent Evolutionary-Cognitive Approach to ‘Folk-Economic Beliefs.’” Evolution, Mind and Behaviour 17(1): 29–47.

Bendixen, T. and B. G. Purzycki. 2020. “En granskning af gudernes sind: betydningen af guders interesser på tværs af kulturer for religioners ophav og udvikling.” Religion: Tidsskrift for Religionslærerforeningen for Gymnasiet og HF 1: 39–45.

———. In press. “Competing Forces Account for the Stability and Evolution of Religious Beliefs.” The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion.

Bird, D. W., R. B. Bird and C. H. Parker. 2005. “Aboriginal Burning Regimes and Hunting Strategies in Australia’s Western Desert.” Human Ecology 33(4): 443–464.

Bliege Bird, R., B. F. Codding, P. G. Kauhanen and D. W. Bird. 2012. “Aboriginal Hunting Buffers Climate-Driven Fire-Size Variability in Australia’s Spinifex Grasslands.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109(26): 10287–10292.

Bloom, P. 2012. “Religion, Morality, Evolution.” Annual Review of Psychology 63(1): 179–199.

Boehm, C. 2008. “A Biocultural Evolutionary Exploration of Supernatural Sanctioning.” In Evolution of Religion: Studies, Theories, and Critiques, edited by J. Bulbulia, R. Sosis, E. Harris, R. Genet and K. Wyman, 143–152. Santa Margarita, CA: Collins Foundation.

Botero, C. A., B. Gardner, K. R. Kirby, J. Bulbulia, M. C. Gavin and R. D. Gray. 2014. “The Ecology of Religious Beliefs.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111(47): 16784–16789.

Boyd, R. and P. J. Richerson. 1985. Culture and the Evolutionary Process. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Boyer, P. 2001. Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought. New York: Basic Books.

Boyer, P. and M. B. Petersen, M. B. 2018a. “Folk-Economic Beliefs: An Evolutionary Cognitive Model.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 41: 1–17.

———. 2018b. “What Is Seen and What Is Not Seen in the Economy: An Effect of Our Evolved Psychology.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 41: 46–65.

Caluori, N., J. C. Jackson, K. Gray, and M. Gelfand. 2020. “Conflict Changes How People View God.” Psychological Science 31(3): 280–292.

Evans-Pritchard, E. E. 1928. “Oracle-Magic of the Azande.” Sudan Notes and Records 11: 1–53.

———. 1965. Theories of Primitive Religion. London: Clarendon.

Gangestad, S. W., M. G. Haselton, and D. M. Buss. 2006a. “Evolutionary Foundations of Cultural Variation: Evoked Culture and Mate Preferences.” Psychological Inquiry 17(2): 75–95.

———. 2006b. “Toward an Integrative Understanding of Evoked and Transmitted Culture: The Importance of Specialized Psychological Design.” Psychological Inquiry 17(2): 138–151.

Geertz, A. W. 2020. “How Did Ignorance Become Fact in American Religious Studies? A Reluctant Reply to Ivan Strenski.” Studi e Materiali Di Storia Delle Religioni 86(1): 365–403.

Geertz, C. 1973. “Thick Description: Toward an Interpretive Theory of Culture.” In The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays, 3-30. New York: Basic Books.

Gervais, W. M. and J. Henrich. 2010. “The Zeus Problem: Why Representational Content Biases Cannot Explain Faith in Gods.” Journal of Cognition and Culture 10(3-4): 383–389.

Graham, J. and J. Haidt. 2010. “Beyond Beliefs: Religions Bind Individuals into Moral Communities.” Personality and Social Psychology Review 14(1): 140–150.

Guglielmino, C. R., C. Viganotti, B. Hewlett and L. L. Cavalli-Sforza. 1995. “Cultural Variation in Africa: Role of Mechanisms of Transmission and Adaptation.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 92(16): 7585–7589.

Guthrie, S. 1995. Faces in the Clouds: A New Theory of Religion. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Handwerker, P. W. 2001. Quick Ethnography: A Guide to Rapid Multi-Method Research. Altamira: Rowman.

Henrich, J. 2015. The Secret of Our Success: How Culture Is Driving Human Evolution, Domesticating Our Species, and Making Us Smarter. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Henrich, J., M. Bauer, A. Cassar, J. Chytilová and B. G. Purzycki. 2019. “War Increases Religiosity.” Nature Human Behaviour 3(2): 129–135.

Henrich, J., R. Boyd and P. J. Richerson. 2008. “Five Misunderstandings about Cultural Evolution.” Human Nature 19(2): 119–137.

Henrich, J. and N. Henrich. 2010. “The Evolution of Cultural Adaptations: Fijian Food Taboos Protect against Dangerous Marine Toxins.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B. Biological Sciences 277(1701): 3715–3724.

Henrich, J. and R. McElreath. 2003. “The Evolution of Cultural Evolution.” Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews 12(3): 123–135.

Hewlett, B. S., A. De Silvestri and C. R. Guglielmino. 2002. “Semes and Genes in Africa.” Current Anthropology 43(2): 313–321.

Hinde, R. A. 2009. Why Gods Persist: A Scientific Approach to Religion. Abingdon: Routledge.

Janicki, M. G. and D. L. Krebs. 1998. “Evolutionary Approaches to Culture.” In Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology: Ideas, Issues, and Applications, edited by C. B. Crawford and D. L. Krebs, 163–207. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Johnson, D. P. 2014. God Is Watching You: How the Fear of God Makes Us Human. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kaiser, T. 2019. “Nature and Evoked Culture: Sex Differences in Personality Are Uniquely Correlated with Ecological Stress.” Personality and Individual Differences 148: 67–72.

Kendal, R. L., N. J. Boogert, L. Rendell, K. N. Laland, M. Webster and P. L. Jones. 2018. “Social Learning Strategies: Bridge-Building between Fields.” Trends in Cognitive Sciences 22(7): 651–665.

Laland, K. N. and G. R. Brown. 2011. Sense and Nonsense: Evolutionary Perspectives on Human Behaviour. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lang, M. and R. Kundt. 2020. “Evolutionary, Cognitive, and Contextual Approaches to the Study of Religious Systems: A Proposition of Synthesis.” Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 32(1): 1–46.

Lang, M., B. G. Purzycki, C. L. Apicella, Q. D. Atkinson, A. Bolyanatz, E. Cohen, C. Handley, E. K. Klocová, C. Lesorogol, S. Mathew, R. A. McNamara, C. Moya, C. D. Placek, M. Soler, T. Vardy, J. L. Weigel, A. K. Willard, D. Xygalatas, A. Norenzayan and J. Henrich 2019. “Moralizing Gods, Impartiality and Religious Parochialism across 15 Societies.” Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 286(1898): 20190202 (1–10).

Lansing, J. S. 1987. “Balinese ‘Water Temples’ and the Management of Irrigation.” American Anthropologist 89(2): 326–341.

Lansing, J. S., S. Thurner, N. N. Chung, A. Coudurier-Curveur, Ç. Karakas, K. A. Fesenmyer and L. Y. Chew. 2017. “Adaptive Self-Organization of Bali’s Ancient Rice Terraces.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114(25): 6504–6509.

Leeson, P. T. 2014. “Oracles.” Rationality and Society 26(2): 141–169.

Lewens, T. 2015. Cultural Evolution: Conceptual Challenges. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Liénard, P. and E. T. Lawson. 2008. “Evoked Culture, Ritualization and Religious Rituals.” Religion 38(2): 157–171.

Mahalingam, R. 2007. “Culture, Ecology, and Beliefs about Gender in Son Preference Caste Groups.” Evolution and Human Behavior 28(5): 319–329.

McElreath, R., A. V. Bell, C. Efferson, M. Lubell, P. J. Richerson, and T. Waring. 2008. “Beyond Existence and Aiming Outside the Laboratory: Estimating Frequency-Dependent and Pay-Off-Biased Social Learning Strategies.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 363(1509): 3515–3528.

McKay, R. and H. Whitehouse. 2015. “Religion and Morality.” Psychological Bulletin 141(2): 447–473.

McNamara, R. A. and B. G. Purzycki. 2020. “Minds of Gods and Human Cognitive Constraints: Socio-Ecological Context Shapes Belief.” Religion, Brain & Behavior 10(3): 223–238.

Morin, O. 2015. How Traditions Live and Die. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Nettle, D. 2009. “Beyond Nature versus Culture: Cultural Variation as an Evolved Characteristic.” Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 15(2): 223–240.

Norenzayan, A. 2006. “Evolution and Transmitted Culture.” Psychological Inquiry 17(2): 123–128.

———. 2013. Big Gods: How Religion Transformed Cooperation and Conflict. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Norenzayan, A., A. F. Shariff, W. M. Gervais, A. K. Willard, R. A. McNamara, E. Slingerland and J. Henrich. 2016. “The Cultural Evolution of Prosocial Religions.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 39: 1–65.

Pazhoohi, F., M. Lang, D. Xygalatas and K. Grammer. 2017. “Religious Veiling as a Mate-Guarding Strategy: Effects of Environmental Pressures on Cultural Practices.” Evolutionary Psychological Science 3(2): 118–124.

Premack, D. and G. Woodruff. 1978. “Does the Chimpanzee Have a Theory of Mind?” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 1(4): 515–526.

Purzycki, B. G. 2010. “Spirit Masters, Ritual Cairns, and the Adaptive Religious System in Tyva.” Sibirica 9(2): 21–47.

———. 2011. “Tyvan cher eezi and the Socioecological Constraints of Supernatural Agents’ Minds.” Religion, Brain & Behavior 1(1): 31–45.

———. 2013. “The Minds of Gods: A Comparative Study of Supernatural Agency.” Cognition 129(1): 163–179.

———. 2016. “The Evolution of Gods’ Minds in the Tyva Republic.” Current Anthropology 57(S13): S88–S104.

Purzycki, B. G. and T. Arakchaa. 2013. “Ritual Behavior and Trust in the Tyva Republic.” Current Anthropology 54(3): 381–388.

Purzycki, B. G., O. S. Haque, and R. Sosis. 2014. “Extending Evolutionary Accounts of Religion beyond the Mind: Religions as Adaptive Systems.” In Evolution, Religion, and Cognitive Science: Critical and Constructive Essays, edited by F. Watts and L. Turner, 74–91. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Purzycki, B. G. and E. C. Holland. 2019. “Buddha as a God: An Empirical Assessment.” Method & Theory in the Study of Religion 31(4–5): 347–375.

Purzycki, B. G. and R. A. McNamara. 2015 “Ecology, Consensus, and Variation: Issues with Time and Persistence in Religious Systems.” Religion, Brain & Behavior 5(3): 54–57.

———. 2016. “An Ecological Theory of Gods’ Minds.” In Advances in Religion, Cognitive Science, and Experimental Philosophy, edited by H. De Cruz and R. Nichols, 143–167. London: Bloomsbury.

Purzycki, B. G., A. C. Pisor, C. Apicella, Q. Atkinson, E. Cohen, J. Henrich, R. McElreath, R. A. McNamara, A. Norenzayan, A. K. Willard, and D. Xygalatas. 2018a. “The Cognitive and Cultural Foundations of Moral Behavior.” Evolution and Human Behavior 39(5): 490–501.

Purzycki, B. G., C. T. Ross, C. Apicella, Q. D. Atkinson, E. Cohen, R. A. McNamara, A. K. Willard, D. Xygalatas, A. Norenzayan, and J. Henrich. 2018b. “Material Security, Life History, and Moralistic Religions: A Cross-Cultural Examination.” PLoS ONE 13(3): 1–14.

Purzycki, B. G. and R. Sosis. 2009. “The Religious System as Adaptive: Cognitive Flexibility, Public Displays, and Acceptance.” In The Biological Evolution of Religious Mind and Behavior, edited by E. Voland and W. Schiefenhövel, 243–256.

———. 2011. “Our Gods: Variation in Supernatural Minds.” In Essential Building Blocks of Human Nature, edited by U. J. Frey, C. Störmer and K. P. Willführ, 77–93. Berlin and Heidelberg: Springer.

———. In press. Religion Evolving: The Dynamics of Culture, Cognition and Ecology. Sheffield: Equinox.

Purzycki, B. G. and J. Watts. 2018. “Reinvigorating the Comparative, Cooperative Ethnographic Sciences of Religion.” Free Inquiry 38(3): 26–29.

Purzycki, B. G. and A. K. Willard. 2016. “MCI Theory: A Critical Discussion.” Religion, Brain & Behavior 6(3): 207–248.

Rappaport, R. A. 1968. Pigs for the Ancestors: Ritual in the Ecology of a New Guinea People. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

Reynolds, V. and R. Tanner. 1995. The Social Ecology of Religion. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rossano, M. J. 2020. “Ritual as Resource Management.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 375(1805): 20190429 (1–9).

Schaller, M. 2006. “Parasites, Behavioral Defenses, and the Social Psychological Mechanisms through Which Cultures Are Evoked.” Psychological Inquiry 17(2): 96–101.

Schjoedt, U., H. Stødkilde-Jørgensen, A. W. Geertz and A. Roepstorff. 2009. “Highly Religious Participants Recruit Areas of Social Cognition in Personal Prayer.” Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 4(2): 199–207.

Schmitt, D. P. 2006. “Cultural Influences on Human Mating Strategies: Evolutionary Theories, Mechanisms, and Explanations of Change.” Psychological Inquiry 17(2): 116–117.

Sear, R. 2020. “Do Human ‘Life History Strategies’ Exist?” Evolution and Human Behavior. Preprint.

Semyonova, V. G., N. S. Gavrilova, T. P. Sabgayda, O. M. Antonova, S. Y. Nikitina and G. N. Evdokushkina. 2014. “Approaches to the Assessment of Alcohol-Related Losses in the Russian Population.” In Mortality in an International Perspective, edited by J. Anson and M. Luy, 137–168. Berlin: Springer.

Shariff, A., B. G. Purzycki and R. Sosis. 2014. “Religions as Cultural Solutions to Social Living.” In Culture Reexamined: Broadening Our Understanding of Social and Evolutionary Influences, edited by A. B. Cohen, 217–238. Washington, DC: APA.

Shaver, J. H. 2015. “The Evolution of Stratification in Fijian Ritual Participation.” Religion, Brain & Behavior 5(2): 101–117.

Shaver, J. H., G. Fraser and J. A. Bulbulia. 2016. “Charismatic Signaling: How Religion Stabilizes Cooperation and Entrenches Inequality.” In The Oxford Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology and Religion, edited by J. R. Liddle and T. K. Shackelford, 1-30. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Shaver, J. H., B. G. Purzycki, and R. Sosis. 2016. “Evolutionary Theory in the Study of Religion.” In The Oxford Handbook of the Study of Religion, edited by M. Stausberg and S. Engler, 124–136. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Shaver, J. H. and R. Sosis. 2014. “How Does Male Ritual Behavior Vary across the Lifespan?” Human Nature 25(1): 136–160.

Shih, F.-L. 2012. “Generating Power in Taiwan: Nuclear, Political and Religious Power.” Culture and Religion 13(3): 295–313.

Sierksma, F. 1963. “Sacred Cairns in Pastoral Cultures.” History of Religions 2(2): 227–241.

Singh, M., T. J. Kaptchuk and J. Henrich. 2020. “Small Gods, Rituals, and Cooperation: The Mentawai Water Spirit Sikameinan.” Evolution and Human Behavior. Preprint.

Smaldino, P. E. 2014. “The Cultural Evolution of Emergent Group-Level Traits.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences 37(3): 243–254.

Smaldino, P. E. and M. Lubell. 2014. “Institutions and Cooperation in an Ecology of Games.” Artificial Life 20(2): 207–221.

Smith, E. A. 2017. “Three Styles in the Evolutionary Analysis of Human Behavior.” In Adaptation and Human Behavior, edited by L. Cronk, N. Chagnon and W. Irons, 27–46. Abingdon: Routledge.

Soerensen, J. 2004. “Religion, Evolution and an Immunology of Cultural Systems.” Evolution and Cognition 10(1): 61–73.

Sosis, R. 2019. “The Building Blocks of Religious Systems: Approaching Religion as a Complex Adaptive System.” In Evolution, Development and Complexity, edited by G. Y. Georgiev, J. M. Smart, C. L. Flores Martinez and M. E. Price, 421–449. Berlin: Springer.

Sosis, R. and E. R. Bressler. 2003. “Cooperation and Commune Longevity: A Test of the Costly Signaling Theory of Religion.” Cross-Cultural Research: The Journal of Comparative Social Science 37(2): 211–239. https://doi: 10.1177/1069397103037002003

Sosis, R. and J. Bulbulia. 2011. “The Behavioral Ecology of Religion: The Benefits and Costs of One Evolutionary Approach.” Religion 41(3): 341–362.

Sperber, D. 1996. Explaining Culture. Oxford: Blackwell.

Spiro, M. E., B. Kilborne and L. L. Langness. 1987. Culture and Human Nature: Theoretical Papers of Melford E. Spiro. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Sponsel, L. E. 2014. “Spiritual Ecology: Is It the Ultimate Solution for the Environmental Crisis?” Choice 51(8): 1339–13448.

Stearns, S. C. and A. M. M. Rodrigues. 2020. “On the Use of ‘Life History Theory’ in Evolutionary Psychology.” Evolution and Human Behavior. Preprint.*mbehav.2020.02.001

Strassmann, B. I., N. T. Kurapati, B. F. Hug, E. E. Burke, B. W. Gillespie, T. M. Karafet and M. F. Hammer. 2012. “Religion as a Means to Assure Paternity.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109(25): 9781–9785.

Teehan, J. 2016. “Religion and Morality: The Evolution of the Cognitive Nexus.” In The Oxford Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology and Religion, edited by J. R. Liddle and T. K. Shackelford, 1–31.

Terrizzi, J. A. 2017. “Is Religion an Evolutionarily Evoked Disease-Avoidance Strategy?” Religion, Brain & Behavior 7(4): 328–330.

Tooby, J. and L. Cosmides. 1992. “The Psychological Foundations of Culture.” In The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture, edited by J. H. Barkow, L. Cosmides and J. Tooby, 19–136. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Turpin, H., M. Andersen and J. A. Lanman. 2019. “CREDs, CRUDs, and Catholic Scandals: Experimentally Examining the Effects of Religious Paragon Behavior on Co-Religionist Belief.” Religion, Brain & Behavior 9(2): 143–155.

Whitehouse, H., P. François, P. E. Savage, T. E. Currie, K. C. Feeney, E. Cioni, R. Purcell, R. M. Ross, J. Larson, J. Baines, B. ter Haar, A. Covey and P. Turchin. 2019. “Complex Societies Precede Moralizing Gods throughout World History.” Nature 568(7751): 226–229.

Whitehouse, H. and J. A. Lanman. 2014. “The Ties That Bind Us: Ritual, Fusion, and Identification.” Current Anthropology 55(6): 674–695.

Xygalatas, D. and M. Lang. 2016. “Prosociality and Religion.” In Mental Religion, edited by K. N. Clements, 119–133. New York: Macmillan.

Zietsch, B. P. and M. J. Sidari. 2019. “A Critique of Life History Approaches to Human Trait Covariation.” Evolution and Human Behavior. Preprint.



How to Cite

Bendixen, T. ., & Purzycki, B. G. (2020). Peering into the Minds of Gods: What Cross-Cultural Variation in Gods’ Concerns Can Tell Us about the Evolution of Religion. Journal for the Cognitive Science of Religion, 5(2), 142–165.